5 ms·
How are you supposed to monitor your spending if you cannot figure out how much you paid for chicken?
by hammock 9y ago
How are you supposed to monitor your spending if you cannot figure out how much you paid for chicken?
- Kuiper 9y agoYou don't need to "figure out" how much you paid for chicken; it's printed on the receipt. The only thing to "figure out" is "what's the cost per pound if I paid $7 for a 2.3 pound chicken" and maybe you want to do that arithmetic, but for a lot of people, "this chicken cost $7 and I estimate that it will feed me and my partner for maybe 2-3 meals" is the only 'calculation' that needs to happen. Larger calculations like "how much did I spend last month on groceries" are easily assessed simply by looking at a credit card statement. Being financially responsible does not necessarily entail knowing the exact dollar-to-calorie or dollar-to-weight ratio of every item in your shopping cart.
- sambe 9y agoIf you can't make basic calculations with ratio and percentages, it seems unlikely that you can compare different costs per unit weight/volume or do the maths to figure out how much food you need without waste. Yes, you can look at a chicken and say "that's enough for 3 people". Yes - in the UK - it's quite likely (legally required?) that all products are labelled per 100g or per kg (although I'd contest people failing these tests are likely not to be understand or care for that labelling). It's a tough argument to make that these skills have no impact on on budgeting at all.
- MaulingMonkey 9y agoNot by counting pennies. Estimate, get a rough order of magnitude - things you can actually keep in your head and get an intuition for instead of math to maybe forget in a checkbook somewhere if you record the calculation at all. Check your balances. Savings going up is good, savings going down is bad. If you need to get detailed, or your estimates don't line up with what your savings account is actually doing, you can also harness the power of online banking records do half the work for you. I semi-recently went over three quarters worth of transactions and aggregated them by category: "Food", "Home Expenses", "Car Expenses", "Food", "Health", "Shopping", "Subscriptions", "Charity", "Unknown". (Not well covered by this exercise alone but easy enough to add to account: taxes.) This already was overkill for me. I did nothing but fact check my gut (which was wrong on some details but right on all the macro points that actually mattered - rent, living expenses, and entertainment - exactly as you'd expect with estimates.) Monitoring total spending already tells me I'm where I need to be - with a good rainy day fund, a good savings fund growing at a good rate. Chicken? Don't know don't care. Food totaled bellow my estimates, which were already low enough I didn't feel them worth the opportunity cost of trying to optimize. That time would be better spent learning how to better negotiate raises and hiring, or learning new career skills. Unknown? Ditto. I happened to subdivide "Food" a little when initially categorizing out of ease and curiosity into "Groceries", "Caffeine", and "Eating Out". Could've saved $633.45 between 1/1/2017 and 8/16/2017 by not buying caffeine, didn't use a lick of manual arithmetic to figure that out. Computers did it for me, and it probably wasn't worth the electrons to even do that.
- smallnamespace 9y ago> If you need to get detailed, or your estimates don't line up with what your savings account is actually doing I think the point is that the ability to count pennies when called upon is part of what keeps your rough intuitions properly calibrated. If one literally cannot do exact arithmetic when necessary (whether mentally, manually, or with a calculator), then how does the gut learn what to pay attention to, and when it might be wrong?
- scarface74 9y agoThis reminds me of the myth of the "Latte Factor". http://www.slate.com/articles/business/the_united_states_of_debt/2016/05/the_latte_is_a_lie_and_buying_coffee_has_nothing_to_do_with_debt_an_excerpt.html http://www.slate.com/articles/business/the_united_states_of_...
- sokoloff 9y agoIt's an exaggeration more than a myth, IMO. It's directionally correct, meaning no re good would be done by people considering it than ignoring it.
- scarface74 9y agoWhat instead of the "Latte Factor", they said... - buy a house that is well below your means or even move some place where your cost of living compared to your money earning potential is favorable. -Get a degree in something that can make money instead of a BS in Ancient Chinese Art History. -Don't go into debt getting a degree from a prestigious college to be a high school teacher. Go to a cheap state school. -Buy a car and keep it for longer. My family spends money on a lot of little things that some people would think was frivolous but we also bought a house in the burbs that had a mortgage that was less than 20% of our monthly net income, we don't drive expensive cars, or try to keep up with the Joneses. My wife still brags about how much money she saves shopping at the thrift store and I'm always looking for a bargain because I don't care about the brand of clothes. On the other hand, I'm very aggressive about my salary and told my (step) kids to pursue careers (or trades) that had income potential. In other words, it's not the little decisions you make that make a difference it's the big ones. You can only by definition, cut spending by so much, but you can make choices to make more money. After we got married about six years ago, my wife and I by working together have increased our income by 33% by her taking a job that has good benefits but low pay (that she enjoys) that gave me the flexibility of aggressively changing jobs for higher salaries without worrying about benefits.
- watwut 9y agoMajority of students go for practical or practically sounding degrees. And those who dont are clustered among students from more rich families. The "students are choosing impractical degrees" is just a way to ignore actual economy problems and blaming result on students.