3 ms·
TLDR from the preprint: The hypothesis was that if publishers did anything meaningful there would be a significant difference between the preprint and published
by olliej 9y ago
TLDR from the preprint: The hypothesis was that if publishers did anything meaningful there would be a significant difference between the preprint and published versions of a paper.
There were not.
- gmiller123456 9y ago"anything meaningful" isn't quite what they analyzed, they just analyzed the claim that they "contribute and enhance text" during publication. The fact that they didn't can't be used to jump to the conclusion that they didn't do anything meaningful. E.g. by determining a paper meets certain standards of accuracy, transparency and relevance would be some meaningful things that could still be done.