6 ms·
There is some legal area around creating modified version of licensed copyrighted work. In US there is an explicit right called Adaptation Right and it has a fe
by belorn 9y ago
There is some legal area around creating modified version of licensed copyrighted work. In US there is an explicit right called Adaptation Right and it has a few prior cases, like the one I recall where a person bought a physical painting and cut it into pieces only to reassemble into a mosaic to be resold. The court judged that case as infringement since the purchaser of the physical painting did not get the Adaptation rights. In EU there is a similar concept in the moral rights of the author where the integrity of work is considered an inalienable right.
But the prior cases are not all like that. There are for example cases where a company produced a physical modification to a game console and got sued, and the supreme court siding with the defendant that such use did not modify the original work but rather was interfacing with it. Similar argument was made during the Oracle vs Google API case from 2010.
When it comes to GPL, there has also been quite a bit discussion on the subject when a user combine the kernel with non-free modules. Is it the user that do it, is it the company that released the module, or is it the distribution that make the two easily combine-able? This became a rather heated discussion when Ubunutu made the module available and Debian had to decide on what the best approach was.
I don't think that legal guidance actually exist since there is prior cases pointing in both directions. I would lean onto the question if the copyrighted work in question is being modified or not. Voice recording itself is very distinct from the rest of the work, so I could easily see that it is permissible for a project like this to pull the intact files from one game to an other, but its a very uncertain what the court would actually decide if it ever went to that. We also have to consider fair use rights, as they did with the Oracle vs Google case.
- userbinator 9y agoWhen it comes to GPL, there has also been quite a bit discussion on the subject when a user combine the kernel with non-free modules. Is it the user that do it, is it the company that released the module, or is it the distribution that make the two easily combine-able? This became a rather heated discussion when Ubunutu made the module available and Debian had to decide on what the best approach was. Essentially since the user-side is basically unenforceable. AFAIK GPL only applies to distribution, and even if it didn't, who's to know if someone privately combines all sorts of incompatibly-licensed software? We can do all sorts of technically illegal things, if we don't disseminate anything. Or as the old saying goes, "it's only illegal if you get caught." ;-)
- averagemodder 9y agoIn practice, Bethesda does not permit mods with assets from a different Bethesda game. Everything else is negotiable, there are kid toys trains turned into Skyrim dragons, but mods with assets from another Bethesda game (or even from a DLC of the same game, but without making the mod dependent on that DLC) are taken down. So, modding projects which plan to accomplish that with some installers extracting those assets tend to operate a bit under the radar, legal gray area or not.