6 ms·
I don't care about your problems as a developer. As a consumer I expect a watch to last 5-10 years. As a developer working in the consumer space you need to get
by taylodl 9y ago
I don't care about your problems as a developer. As a consumer I expect a watch to last 5-10 years. As a developer working in the consumer space you need to get out of the mindset that everyone is replacing everything every 2-3 years. That's neither reasonable nor sustainable.
- gman83 9y agoI've had my Citizen watch for 20 years. Works fine.
- simonh 9y agoThere are sundials out there that have been working for hundreds of years. Honestly, if you can't leave a timepiece out in all weather for centuries without any maintenance or winding, what's the point?
- ubermonkey 9y agoI have my dad's Rolex. It's 40 years old. Works fine. But it also ONLY tells the time and the date, and the date will be wrong if you don't stay on top of it because it doesn't know which months have 31 days and which are shorter. It's super cool, though, that this object still works just as well as when it was new in 1978. But I stopped wearing it (and my other mechanicals) all the time precisely because of their limited featureset vs. a good and attractive smartwatch.
- guelo 9y agoSorry, there's not enough revenue or developers to support 5-10 year old hardware. As a consumer you should have realized by now that when you buy these appliance computers they will only be supported for a few years. But nothing stops you from continuing to use your hardware with the old software.
- acdha 9y agoThat’s only true if you need to make all of your money off of the original hardware sale, which is why Android phones tend to fall out of support much sooner than iOS since Apple still benefits from iCloud, iTunes, App Store, etc. sales but Samsung, et al. don’t have an equivalent revenue stream. Your last sentence isn’t often correct either: I have a 2012 Toshiba TV. The hardware is in great shape but of all of the apps it shipped with only the Netflix and Vudu apps still work because everything else broke when Google, Yahoo!, etc. stopped SHA-1 support. I agree that no new features is a reasonable policy but at a minimum you need basic security & compatibility support for 5-10 years.
- yoz-y 9y agoNot all developers can or want to have alternative revenue streams. It is completely unreasonable to expect a developer to support software for 10 years if you are not paying for this service. Sadly, on Apple platforms there is no way of doing paid upgrades so there goes that.
- acdha 9y ago> Not all developers can or want to have alternative revenue streams. It is completely unreasonable to expect a developer to support software for 10 years if you are not paying for this service 1. We’re talking about hardware vendors 2. Why is the tech industry magically different from everything else? I get safety recalls on things which are 5-10 years old but e.g. Lenovo can’t seem to ship Android security updates which Google gave them more than 1-2 years after release. > Sadly, on Apple platforms there is no way of doing paid upgrades so there goes that. This is why developers use advertising, in-app purchases and subscriptions, or releasing major versions as new apps. The point wasn’t that the status quo is perfect but that it’s extremely wasteful and needs to change. The tech industry has a lot of people who thought that cycle of rapid growth was innate but are starting to realize that things are saturating in most segments. Buying a new device every 2 years only works if they’re very cheap or dramatically better.
- yoz-y 9y ago
- threeseed 9y agoYour expectations are arbitrary though. I expect my Rolex to last a hundred years and my Apple Watch to last as long as my phone. Especially since technically that is what it largely is. A small phone on your wrist.
- scarface74 9y agoI use a 10 year old Dell Core 2 Duo 2.66Ghz laptop with 4GB of RAM, a 1920x1200 display as a Plex Server running Windows 10 and it only feels when I run too many things at once but that could be alleviated by putting in another 4GB of RAM. It's a 10 year old computer that can take full advantage of my gigabit home internet connection (940Mbps up and down) - something only dreamed about 10 years ago - can run the latest OS and can be upgraded to have the same amount of RAM as most computers that are sold today. In 2008, a 10 year old computer would have probably had these specs and be unusable as a modern computer. http://www.tomshardware.com/forum/266641-28-average-1998-computer-specs http://www.tomshardware.com/forum/266641-28-average-1998-com... To sum it up, a decent compy around 1998/early 1999 could look likte this: 400Mhz P2 64mb sdram running at 100 mhz one or two voodoo 2 cards (90mhz core, 8 or 12 mb EDO VRAM) a 2D card (voodoo 2 was a 3d accelerator only) ATA-2 HD In 1998 a 10 year old computer would have been less usable. How fast improvements come to the smart watch will slow down in time but it's a brand new product.
- laumars 9y agoI get your point but none of your comparisons fit: o Your Plex system is a home server, which have always typically been lower powered desktops even 10 year ago (I know because I was building home servers back then. In fact 10 years ago I was running ZFS off an old desktop PC with some really budget consumer RAID controllers) o and you're comparing that to a gaming machine which are systems which are typically at the higher end of spectrum). To put things into perspective, in 1999 I most certainly did not have a 3D accelerator. Yet I was still using my computer for software development and web development (including, by the way, 3D markup via VRML). In fact I don't think I even had a P2 considering my upgrade a few years later was to Celeron. I have a feeling my '98 PC was a Cyrix. o It was really common even in the 90s to run old PCs. Even in 1995 I was still seeing 386s and even the occasional 286 in use running Windows 3.x. o Lastly you cannot really compare a watch to a PC. Sure, smart watches are basically just computers these days; but the point the OP was making was peoples expectations are different for watches. I mean we have digital watches from the 80s that still work as well today as they ever have done, yet smart watches made 2 years ago are already junk. Before people comment on the difference in tech, yes I already know. But that's not the point. The point is people's expectations - which frankly I think are more than reasonable. If there's anything we have learned in the last 20 years it's how to futureproof our products.
- janekm 9y agoWhen you're buying the very first version of a new consumer electronics category (first iPhone, first Apple Watch, first Android phone), you can expect it to become fully outdated in 2-3 years, given current rates of hardware development, that's the cost of being an early adopter. I would expect the Apple Watch 3 to be viable for 4-5 years, much like an iPhone 6S will still work well today.
- Shivetya 9y agoI think the term outdated is a bit strong, does it still perform its intended function at the same acceptable level? Then it is hardly outdated. this applies to first generation items as well as those that follows. there are cases where first generation is so badly implemented that only the following can make a product deliver on its promises but that is really a different issue. For me the term seems to be one of those which got twisted by marketing types to mean something wholly different to encourage this buy the new model mentality.
- reacweb 9y agoReplacing everything every 2-3 years is the "normal" mindset for young people (< 20 years old). As a "grown-up", I expect stuff to wear out if I use it a lot, but to last long if I take care of it. My expectations are higher when it is expensive. I still have a palm III XE and I use it (twice a year).
- coldtea 9y agoI'm not sure is a young people vs grown ups thing. There are gadget lovers who get the latest at all ages, and tons of them are at the 'dad' age (30-40+), not younger.
- reacweb 9y agoPerception of time varies a lot with age. When you are 10 years old, 2 years is enormous. When you are 40, it is yesterday.
- ac2u 9y agoAmen to that. I certainly sympathise with the dev, but more power to Apple for supporting hardware for 5 years. Nothing's more annoying that spending lots of money on a device like a phone only for security updates to stop rolling out less than two years later. I want to be able to use the core features for a few years without my phone being a walking security exploit. This applies even more for watches.
- qzervaas 9y agoHaving better apps and a stronger ecosystem makes the platform better for everybody. As an indie dev* making a living from Apple Watch, I concur with the difficulty of having to debug these things. For example, some arbitrary resource limit may have transparently been applied, leading to some unexpected behaviour in your app. Now, make a minor change to code to diagnose this issue and deploy to device - could take 2-3 minutes to copy to device, and another 30 seconds to run the binary. Series 3 still has its issues but it is 1000x better than the original. * https://outcastapp.com https://outcastapp.com, plus various others
- oneeyedpigeon 9y agoUnless I'm misunderstanding something, no-one is suggesting the original watches should stop working all of a sudden, they just shouldn't receive the newest revisions of software beyond a certain point. They'll continue to work for, presumably, many years to come. That seems totally reasonable to me.
- graeme 9y agoYeah. My original iphone still runs just fine. It is ten years old. But I don't use it! It gets no security patches. If I wanted it for alarms, notes, etc it would be fine
- ubermonkey 9y agoWouldn't it be challenging to create any interesting wearable tech that would actually last 10 years? I may be an outlier here because I came to the Apple Watch from the world of higher-end watches. My usual daily wear piece before was an Omega, e.g. I started wearing the Apple Watch when I was training for a half marathon, because it worked really well for that purpose (when paired with Strava) -- and I discovered it was also so USEFUL for me that I wore it almost all the time. After about 18 months, I realized I was really only taking it off when I felt I needed to wear something that looked a bit fancier -- but I didn't want to give up the Apple functionality. Then the series 3 was introduced, with actual water-resistance and the in-built cell capability, and that was that. I sold my initial one (a Sport model) and bought the next nicer model in steel with the sapphire crystal on the Milanese loop. I swap in a composite band if I'm being active, and wear the loop if I'm going to dinner. I don't expect this watch -- about $750US -- to last 10 years, but I will be happy if I get 3 out of it before I want to upgrade. I also expect it'll still WORK at that point, and the driver for me will be new features or functions and not failure. I'm okay with that, because of the relatively modest cost vs. definitively high usability/duty cycle. If I were the sort of person who would wear a sport model all the time, it'd be an even easier choice ($359 w/o cell; $429 with).
- laumars 9y ago> Wouldn't it be challenging to create any interesting wearable tech that would actually last 10 years? Wearable tech has already been around for more than 10 years. Whether it's raincoats with speakers built into the collar, or the digital watches from the 80s. The problem isn't so much wearable tech but rather current tech trends (eg the IoT revolution). To that end, I'd wager something like Pebble (baring hardware failure) would still work in 10 years since the only dependency that has is bluetooth.
- jsjohnst 9y ago> I'd wager something like Pebble (baring hardware failure) would still work in 10 years since the only dependency that has is bluetooth. I doubt it. The watch will still work, but the app needed to sync to the watch won’t. I’ve been really frustrated with old “utility” apps not working anymore on iOS (due to not being updated to 64bit). I’m all for upgrades and new stuff, but it sucks when a simple app that did exactly what you needed is no longer able to run.
- pohl 9y agoDo you expect your watch to get new major-version system software upgrades throughout those 5 to 10 years?
- laumars 9y agoNot the OP but I'll answer based on my own opinions: I wouldn't expect new features but I would expect vulnerabilities to be patched and any cloud dependencies to remain switched on.
- taylodl 9y agoI think we should be striving for a 5+5 plan: you should expect feature updates for five years and security updates for ten years. More would be better - certainly for security updates, but these are the minimums we should be expecting.
- FidelCashflow 9y agoAnd I, as an informed consumer, acknowledge that the my electronic devices are not going to last more than a few years due to either mechanical failure and/or processing limitations. To counter this, I don't buy the latest and greatest anything. My $60 (USD) Samsung J3 does everything that I ask of it and it feels light-years ahead of the HTC 626s that I bought ~2 years ago for $80. It finally died of mechanical failure and it didn't make me feel anything at all to drop sixty dollars and change on a new model. I'll never understand the consumer dynamic that allows there to be a never-ending lineup of $800+ phones at every store that sells electronics. Congratulations, your [electronic device] was expensive and in about two years, you're going to need a new one, just the same.
- daveFNbuck 9y agoI used to feel the same way about having a data plan. There's WiFi pretty much everywhere, so why spend hundreds of dollars a year for that small bit of extra connectivity? Once I got a smartphone with a data plan, it turned out to have a fairly high value in my life. $2/day roughly covers my data plan and buying a new $800 phone every two years. The consumer dynamic is that having the latest phone is worth $2/day. Dropping $800 recently on a new phone did make me feel something, but it was a positive feeling.
- berberous 9y agoI agree with you generally, but the Series 0 is borderline unusable for third party apps. I had one and returned it. It honestly should probably not even have allowed third party apps given how painfully slow it was. I also suspect that most folks who still use one don't even use third party apps. Support for it should be dropped, but now that the watch is at a decent level of performance, support timelines should increase.
- calvinbhai 9y agoNot providing a new WatchOS update doesn’t mean the watch stops working. Non Smart Watches stop getting updates the moment they are manufactured. Apple Watches getting updates for 3 years, is good enough. I’m saying this as someone who uses Watch Series 0 everyday. Any more updates to this old watch and it’ll only get slower. From a developer perspective also, there’s no point supporting such an old device when it wasn’t built for anything more than the current functionality. For the price of a Rolex or an Omega, you can ‘probably’ buy a new Apple Watch every 3 years, for the rest of your life. It’s a personal choice.
- awinder 9y agoWasn't there a huge leap in capabilities between series 0 and even series 1? Surely we can be reasonable about how timelines work with breakout technology. Getting 5-10 years out of a watch seems like an admirable goal, but expecting that to happen with tech in it's infancy doesn't seem reasonable, nor conducive to actually accomplishing that goal. I also don't completely understand the tone, this dev is measuring the installed base of different models. If their users are suddenly < 5% on the seminal model of the watch, then screw halting progress for 95% of your users just to hold on to that 5%. Expectations shouldn't be measured in years, it should be measured in adoption base, and optimizing for where your users are. And that number is going to wildly swing based on maturity of the tech, and that's going to change over time, so trying to throw out a year range as table stakes to apply forever is just a little crazy.
- osteele 9y agoAs a series 0 owner, I'll be fine if Apple drops support from new watchOS releases, new apps don't support it, and existing apps never get another release that runs on it. In fact, I'll probably be fine if third-party apps stop working on the series 0 entirely. Third-party apps run so poorly on the series 0 that they're not really worth using. I'd rather developers invest in the work that will make later-generation Apple Watches worth the upgrade, than pour those resources into low-value results on a hamstrung platform. My current watch won't be any worse off than the day I bought it, and I'll have the option of a more compelling upgrade if I want one. As a consumer, I don't expect a first-generation smartwatch, especially from 2015 when this was still a very new product category, to last 5-10 years. If it does last, I don't expect it to acquire new features every year. Other watches don't. Appliances that last that long tend to get worse over their lifetime.
- jbigelow76 9y agoAs a consumer I expect a watch to last 5-10 years. As a developer working in the consumer space you need to get out of the mindset that everyone is replacing everything every 2-3 years. The Apple Watch is only a watch incidentally, all indications seem to be that it's mostly a fitness tracker with a bit of notification monitoring thrown in. Yes, it does happen to tell time as well. I expect there to significant enhancements to the fitness/health tracking capabilities in the next 2-3 years (and then the 2-3 after that as well), some of us are fine with upgrading a fitness tracker every few years.