7 ms·
A spiral/disk galaxy's mass is proportional to the square of the radius: Mg = C1 * Rg * Rg where C1 depends only on shape and is basically the same across all
by trhway 9y ago
A spiral/disk galaxy's mass is proportional to the square of the radius:
Mg = C1 * Rg * Rg
where C1 depends only on shape and is basically the same across all the spiral/disk galaxies.
Orbital speed of stars in the disk is proportional to the square root of the galaxy's mass (the observed absence of the other otherwise must-have orbital velocity equation component - ie. 1/SQRT(r) - is what causes crack pot theories like dark matter) :
Vdisk = C2 * SQRT(Mg) = C2 * SQRT(C1) * Rg
where C2 also dependents only on shape and is basically the same across all the spiral/disk galaxies.
Thus Vdisk = C * Rg where the C is pretty close to being the same across all the spiral/disk galaxies.
Angular speed of a star in the disk at the distance "r" from center is
Vdisk / (2pi * r) = (C * Rg) / (2pi * r)
which at the edge of the galaxy, ie. where r = Rg, becomes
(C * Rg) / (2pi * Rg) = C / 2pi
ie. the same constant across all the spiral/disk galaxies.
The end.
- xr4ti 9y agoPossibly naive question from a non-physicist... does this not follow from relativity as a natural a consequence of the effect gravity/mass has on spacetime? By that I mean that the edges of galaxies experience a "reference" spacetime (e.g. constant period), while the interiors experience a stretched out version spacetime (i.e. inverse time dilation and length constriction)?
- trhway 9y agoAlso not a physicist. At the galactic scale gravity forces are too weak to take into account any non-Newtonian considerations. At least for myself, most things observed so far at galactic scale, like flat disk star orbital speed for example, can be easily explained by straight 6th grade Newtonian physics.
- phkahler 9y agoAnother fun experiment is to write script to cover a disk with points, then do a full calculation of all N gravitational forces at a point along the radius. Calculate the acceleration of a mass at that point and back-calculate the velocity that would orbit with that inward force. Repeat this for many points along the radius and plot the rotation curve without doing any dynamic simulation. There can be some interesting numerical issues with this but a random set of points to "measure" the curve will still show it.
- titzer 9y agosigh I wouldn't have replied to this if you hadn't posted half a dozen comments. When I was 16 I thought special relativity was a hoax and I tried to demonstrate this with triangular diagrams scribbled in pencil in my notebooks. I ended up just rediscovering the Doppler effect. I never showed it to anyone, but when I think back, I still cringe a little. Relativity and time dilation are real things with real theory and real experiments. You'd do well to do a little more research on the topic before posting so many comments on HN. There is a ton of evidence for dark matter. We still don't know exactly what it is, but we do know lots about it (e.g. it is not baryonic matter because observation differs from theoretical models of how it would interact with ordinary baryonic matter). As for all that other evidence, the first hit on Google is for laymen: https://medium.com/starts-with-a-bang/five-reasons-we-think-dark-matter-exists-a122bd606ba8 https://medium.com/starts-with-a-bang/five-reasons-we-think-... TLDR: gravitational lensing, missing mass, and three other really good reasons that dark matter is a serious subject of study. Disclaimer: I am not a physicist. And I'm trying not to represent myself as one on HN. Talking about this stuff is fun, sure. It's great to learn! But please don't spread ignorance with such high confidence. As for "just" Newtonian physics, there's a whole research field called "Modified Newtonian Dynamics" (MOND). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modified_Newtonian_dynamics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modified_Newtonian_dynamics TLDR; there are lots of problems with MOND, and it doesn't explain gravitational lensing and other effects of dark matter that we see.
- dnautics 9y agono, the point is that it follows from basic algebra, and high-school physics defitions of velocity.
- zaarn 9y agoHighschool definitions of velocity don't really apply once the distances involved grow beyond a couple light years. Atleast not without corrections for stuff like relativity (which has been measured and confirmed to exist by simply observing curvature of light over the sun. Or did the entire community of astrophysics simply ignore high school physics in favor or something vastly more complicated because reasons?
- dnautics 9y agoEven at galactic scales the correction is not that great. I don't thing the OP's claim is that they are exact to say 3 sig figs but more like exact to within an order of magnitude
- zaarn 9y agoBut how does the proposed model compare to the accuracy of the dark matter model? In physics, how well your model can predict past and future states from the current state is rather important. Though future states more than past state but any model should be able to also somewhat agree with it's the past it generates.
- dnautics 9y agodark matter is irrelevant. The speed law is empirical (whether or not you explain it with dark matter) and the first poster points out that the constant edge rotational rate falls out from that, and geometry.
- zaarn 9y agoIt is relevant when you compare models. All I asked is how accurate both models are. If Dark Matter is more accurate in predicting how galaxies move and shape then it is obviously the better model even if a simpler one also exists but it's predictions are worse. You can't simply say "this model also predicts that" without giving on how accurate it does predict and comparing to existing models. Otherwise we'd be using flat earth models for building bridges and planning ship routes.
- notfed 9y ago> "...crack pot theories like dark matter" Out of genuine interest, do you have any citations from reputable physicists who agree dark matter is a "crack pot theory"?
- dnautics 9y agoI think he was being sarcastic. The point is the basic law of gravitation is being violated here, and it's like, zero point energy or something.
- trhway 9y agonot really. All the works postulating dark matter from the flat speed curve that i've seen so far are using basic orbital speed formula (sqrt(M/R)) which is only applicable to either spherically-simmetric masses and/or large (compare to the mass containing radius) distances between the interacting masses. Such simplification is just not valid for disk star orbital speed calculation because 1. disk galaxies are far from being spherically symmetric and 2. distance between a star and the galaxy center is of the same scale as the galaxy's radius. Very detailed Newton based calculation of those orbital speeds taking into account the shape of the galaxy mass distribution produces much flatter curve and, for example, for Milky Way to get a flat curve matching observations i needed to speculate only additional 20%-30% of galaxy mass to be present in the galaxy halo (like gas and dark dwarfs of all kinds which some works suggest there are and even that may be unnecessary - need to find and check some additional observational data for that) instead of additional 900% of dark matter that typical "dark matter" works speculate for.
- libeclipse 9y agoWhat are your credentials, if you don't mind my asking?
- phkahler 9y agoHe can do the math himself.
- michaelrccurtis 9y agoFor anyone interested in why there's a lot more to it than this argument, the first equation: Mg = C1 * Rg * Rg Is not a good assumption for the discs we observe in the universe, because they do not have a constant surface density. The picture is further complicated by the fact the many disc galaxies also contain a central bulge, large enough to effect the potential (to say nothing of Dark Matter).