5 ms·
What would you do with 60 seconds warning? Crawl under a table? I am not facetious. It's probably not enough time to run out of a building.
by maxxxxx 9y ago
What would you do with 60 seconds warning? Crawl under a table? I am not facetious. It's probably not enough time to run out of a building.
- saagarjha 9y ago> Crawl under a table? That's better than nothing. > It's probably not enough time to run out of a building. It could be, if the building is less than 3-4 stories tall.
- maxxxxx 9y agoAt my workplace you wouldn't get anywhere within 60 seconds especially with everybody else rushing out at the same time.
- ovao 9y agoI think sixty seconds would be more than ample to evacuate most of the buildings I find myself in. In fact, the only building I don't think I could get out of within sixty seconds would be a Walmart or a big box home improvement store. If you can't escape the building, the usual advice is to find a doorway.
- ggg9990 9y agoAre you assuming nobody else is trying to exit at the same time? I can get out of my sixth floor apartment in 60 seconds but not if everyone in the building is trying the same thing.
- ovao 9y agoThe crowd factor is primarily why I don’t think I could get out of a large store within sixty seconds, yes.
- KingPrad 9y agoThe tricks discussed in CERT classes (which are well worth taking - very interesting material) is to go to back of store because few people think to. Same with concerts and other events - people instinctively run to the entrance in which they entered, rather than the nearest. Secondly, if you're in the midst of huge shelves with no escape (like a home depot) get under the first shelf. the shelving won't collapse downwards, but if a neighboring shelf falls sideways you'll be protected. Harder to do in a real emergency, but good ideas, and thinking them through can be enough to execute them when needed. Anyway - I highly encourage taking a local CERT class if you're in the US, or finding the equivalent wherever you live.
- in_cahoots 9y agoYou won’t know exactly how much time you have once you hear the warning. You might be better off finding shelter in the immediate vicinity rather than being caught in a potentially dangerous area 15sec into your 60sec evacuation route.
- newnewpdro 9y agoMaybe when you're the only person leaving the building.
- cwkoss 9y agoOh geez, the aisles with shelves of heavy objects stacked 20 feet high at home improvement stores would be terrifying during a big earthquake. Had never considered that.
- maxxxxx 9y agoThat's definitely one of the worst places to be :-)
- ivanhoe 9y agoWell, if nothing else it's a minute more to decide what to do...
- asclepi 9y agoIt saves more time. Warned humans will also skip the costly "what's going on"-realization phase of the human brain.
- jccooper 9y agoThat's ample time to exit homes and small buildings, which are are the structures likely to be most dangerous in a quake.
- matthewaveryusa 9y agoAre you sure that's good advice? It makes common sense but technically the advice is to stay indoors afaik
- astrodust 9y agoDepends how rickety your house is, and where it's located.
- maxxxxx 9y agoIf you can get out easily I don't see a reason to stay indoors. Maybe stay away from trees though.
- godelski 9y agoWould you rather be in an open field of a place with things above you? The reason to stay indoors is if you're in a city or next to buildings where glass and shrapnel could fall on you. If you have open space outside, then that is a much better place to be.
- deleted 9y ago
- dawnerd 9y ago60 seconds is better than nothing. Similar to japan, that 60 seconds could mean stopping trains and anything else sensitive to the ground moving. Elevators could be stopped and people directed out. Gas and water shut off. Quite a bit more too, really.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- maxxxxx 9y agoThat actually makes sense for things like utilities and trains systems. Power plants also probably could use that kind of warning. I hope it won't rain during an earthquake or landslides may happen.
- mikeyouse 9y agoPartial list of things that can happen with even 10 seconds of warning: * Elevators stop at closest floor and doors open, preventing people from being stuck between floors. * Critical garage doors & gates at fire stations / hospitals will open, allowing emergency vehicles to quickly exit. * Other critical doors & gates will close to prevent people from entering tunnels or other areas that could be blocked off. * Trains will slow or stop to prevent derailments. * Oil/Gas pipeline pressures will be reduced and valves will close to lessen impact if line is compromised. * Hospitals alert to prevent mishaps in surgery or other dangerous areas (like MRIs). * Airports alert to stop takeoffs/landings in case there are buckles in the runway. In short, there are a ton of things that you can do to prevent really bad outcomes (many of which are prefaced on doing something before the power cuts out) that are much more difficult and expensive after the shaking has started.
- nostrademons 9y agoCould also post electronic signs on freeways that warn motorists to stop and pull over immediately, particularly before hazardous areas like bridges, tunnels, viaducts, and onramps. IIRC most of the civilian casualties of the 1989 Loma Prieta & 1994 Northridge earthquakes were from viaduct or bridge collapses that pinned cars underneath. With a minute's warning, you can prevent any more cars from entering the bridge and get most of the existing traffic out.
- rticesterp 9y agoSurgeons can stop cutting on someone during a surgery. An earthquake is bad timing if a scalpel is close to a major artery.
- xoa 9y ago>Crawl under a table? I am not facetious. Yes actually (or go into a doorway or similar). I don't understand the derision extremely simple and basic response strategies (like the well designed and effective "duck and cover" for nuclear strikes) get when they can be absolutely enormous lifesavers. A huge amount of the human injury potential from a lot of major classes of disaster is from simple stuff like flying/falling glass and falling dense materials, all of which can do terrible things to an unprotected human body but are also absolutely trivial to deflect with another inert object. Shattered non-safety glass will cause tremendous damage to soft tissues, and someone can certainly be badly injured or killed by even a small weight like a brick or other dense objects that fall from just ceiling or high shelf height. But none of those is going to go through heavy steel or wood. Typical work desks and tables (and of course institutional use furniture in general) are quite sturdy. Door frames tend to exhibit significant structural reinforcement as well and be away from many short range dangers. Putting an inch or two (4-6 cm) equivalent of hardwood, dense composite wood, or metal between a person and debris can be the work of seconds, and the difference between a brick landing on the table vs on someone's skull is not nothing, as is getting into a position protecting the face and vulnerable extremities and organs as much as feasible and being braced. It's true that better architectural and infrastructure design matters tremendously and is worth continuing to work on, that if a heavy building pancakes then anyone inside is in trouble/toast, etc. But on a population survival/mass casualty reduction basis a little executed well can make a bigger difference then a lot of people give credit. The difference between death/grievous injury in many mass disasters can come down to relatively small differences in where someone is and what actions they take right before, and how practiced they are in taking the best actions promptly. Don't underestimate it.
- noonespecial 9y agoGet down off a ladder. Stop your car. Pull boiling water off a stove. I can go all day....
- northwest66 9y agoI had to duck a few LCDs and drop ceiling tiles in the 2011 Christchurch earthquake, 60 seconds would've been handy to hide under my desk.
- antod 9y agoBased on the location of the epicentre, there was no way of getting a 60 sec (or any) warning if you were in Christchurch that day. It would've been useful in the 2016 Kaikoura quake though - watching the models* of how that fault unzipped up the east coast of the South Island should've given Marlborough and Wellington some warning. * Here's an example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z1HWet9j070 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z1HWet9j070