9 ms·
I'm so disappointed that California doesn't have something like Mexico's Seismic Alert System, which has historically given 60 seconds of warning before an eart
by pmoriarty 9y ago
I'm so disappointed that California doesn't have something like Mexico's Seismic Alert System, which has historically given 60 seconds of warning before an earthquake.[1] Something like that could save so many lives.
"CIRES transmits earthquake early warning alerts through a network of VHF stations similar to the NOAA Weather Radio service in the United States, including use of Specific Area Message Encoding, but with faster lead times in order to issue more timely warnings within two seconds or less. CIRES offers alert systems for buildings and personal use, which also come pre-installed with the official warning sound used for earthquake alerts in Mexico. On its network of transmitters, CIRES issues required weekly tests every three hours to ensure receivers are connected to its network, as well as earthquake warnings when necessary. More than 90,000 users in Mexico City, including almost all public schools, have receivers. The Mexico City Metro additionally receives SASMEX alerts, although not for public dissemination but instead to stop trains or delay departures as necessary."
[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SASMEX https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SASMEX
- thatswrong0 9y agoIf they can text everyone about an Amber Alert dozens of miles away, they can text everyone about an incoming earthquake. No sense how this doesn't exist yet.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Piskvorrr 9y agoLatency. With Amber alerts, a latency of tens of seconds (not unusual for mass text message) is irrelevant; with earthquake, the seismic waves can overtake the messaging queue. (Computation itself might be happening near speed of light, high-level communication protocols in general pas through thousands of buffers)
- Osmium 9y agoAny alert is better than no alert, but if you're sitting right on top of a fault it won't give you much time to act. I'd be surprised if it's even enough time to get under a desk. Would any expert reading this like to comment?
- timClicks 9y agoIn countries with decent engineering standards, broken glass and items falling from above such as light fittings and ceiling panels cause the worst injuries. Giving people a minute or so warning could be very helpful to prevent these sorts of injuries.
- knz 9y ago> Any alert is better than no alert For large earthquakes, absolutely. But if you get a situation like the Canterbury earthquakes (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2010_Canterbury_earthquake https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2010_Canterbury_earthquake - 17,000+ over the span of several years) the warning system becomes useless unless it can rapidly detect magnitude and mercalli intensity. My family lived through the Canterbury earthquakes. If you live somewhere with this hazard PLEASE prepare accordingly.
- DoubleCribble 9y agoDepending on your proximity to the epicenter, sometimes you can hear a big earthquake before it hits. It won't help much if it hits in the middle of the night when you're asleep, but a second or two is enough to drop under your desk and avoid the most frequent danger, falling objects.
- dv_dt 9y agoThe USGS has been working on one, the funding for rollout has been short with Trump zeroing out the line item in his budget requests. http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-earthquake-early-warning-20180220-htmlstory.html http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-earthquake-early...
- Thrymr 9y agoHere's the website for the project: https://www.shakealert.org/ https://www.shakealert.org/
- mertd 9y agoShouldn't the insurance companies have a huge incentive to see this built?
- sdhgaiojfsa 9y agoI imagine that most of the losses in an earthquake are property losses. These don't seem like they'll be significantly mitigated by a one minute warning.
- clvcooke 9y agoPerhaps life/health insurance? I'm not sure the average costs of injury associated with earthquakes but it could be substantial
- sdhgaiojfsa 9y agoI guess the average person doesn't have very much life insurance (<$100k on average per person). Looks like about 100 people have died from earthquakes in the last 30 years in CA, so maybe that gives you $10M in life insurance expenditures. Health-wise, let's say every injury has cost $30k on average (IMO a very generous estimate). Looks like there have been about ten thousand injuries or so over the last thirty years. So that's $300M. Let's say for the sake of argument that an early warning system reduces losses by 50%. So that gives us $150M in value over thirty years. Or about $7.5M per year in value. (Less, really, because value saved in the future has to be discounted.) That doesn't really go very far even toward maintaining an existing system, to say nothing of developing a new one. (Assuming the last thirty years is representative, that my napkin math is good, etc.)
- maxxxxx 9y agoWhat would you do with 60 seconds warning? Crawl under a table? I am not facetious. It's probably not enough time to run out of a building.
- saagarjha 9y ago> Crawl under a table? That's better than nothing. > It's probably not enough time to run out of a building. It could be, if the building is less than 3-4 stories tall.
- maxxxxx 9y agoAt my workplace you wouldn't get anywhere within 60 seconds especially with everybody else rushing out at the same time.
- ovao 9y agoI think sixty seconds would be more than ample to evacuate most of the buildings I find myself in. In fact, the only building I don't think I could get out of within sixty seconds would be a Walmart or a big box home improvement store. If you can't escape the building, the usual advice is to find a doorway.
- ggg9990 9y agoAre you assuming nobody else is trying to exit at the same time? I can get out of my sixth floor apartment in 60 seconds but not if everyone in the building is trying the same thing.
- ovao 9y agoThe crowd factor is primarily why I don’t think I could get out of a large store within sixty seconds, yes.
- KingPrad 9y agoThe tricks discussed in CERT classes (which are well worth taking - very interesting material) is to go to back of store because few people think to. Same with concerts and other events - people instinctively run to the entrance in which they entered, rather than the nearest. Secondly, if you're in the midst of huge shelves with no escape (like a home depot) get under the first shelf. the shelving won't collapse downwards, but if a neighboring shelf falls sideways you'll be protected. Harder to do in a real emergency, but good ideas, and thinking them through can be enough to execute them when needed. Anyway - I highly encourage taking a local CERT class if you're in the US, or finding the equivalent wherever you live.
- garmaine 9y ago60s seems unreasonable. Earthquakes move at around 5km/s. 60s warning would be for someone 300km away, who is probably not at risk. You could get 2-10s warning to those nearer the epicenter, which is still enough warning to be valuable. Especially if machinery and self driving cars and such could be auto-safetied.
- ggg9990 9y agoYou’re assuming that an impending earthquake can’t be detected before it’s at full force.
- craftyguy 9y agoYou're assuming that an impending major earthquake can be detected before it happens. I don't think that is possible. All 'early warning' systems rely on having sensors close to the epicenter that detect the waves before they propagate out to populations further away, but by that time the earthquake is already happening.
- dllthomas 9y agoParent seems to be assuming, rather, that earthquakes take time to reach "full force". I weakly suspect that's not the case, but it's a different question than "before it happens".
- jcranmer 9y agoFrom the videos I've seen of the 2011 Japan earthquake, the general reaction generally follows a pattern of "meh, just an earthquake... okay, this is a strong earthquake... HOLY SHIT THIS IS A STRONG EARTHQUAKE." I don't know how much of that is particular to the earthquake, though, and it's hard to tell why that kind of reaction seems to occur.
- level3 9y agoSmall earthquakes are common enough in Japan that many people will just brush them off. My personal reaction to anything 4 or less on the intensity scale is just to stand/sit still. Basically, if it’s not strong enough to trigger the early warning system, I don’t really worry. Even with the early warning, sometimes the earthquake will still be on the weaker end of the spectrum, so you brace yourself but not necessarily panic. The 2011 earthquake started off moderately, so no one in my office ducked for cover until it really started to shake, which was already about half a minute in.
- tostitos1979 9y agoI didn't know we had the tech to detect earthquakes with high prob (say >99%) something like 60 seconds in advance. Can someone comment? If we can detect, you are right that it is shocking we don't do population wide drills with messaging infrastructure.
- jcranmer 9y agoThe tech here is P-wave detection. P-waves are somewhere around twice as fast as S-waves, so if you're 100-200km away from the hypocenter, it gives you that much advanced warning. Powerful earthquakes are still destructive at that range.
- Terribledactyl 9y agoThe other advantage is that once the seismic wave is detected, you can transmit that info at lightspeed vs the 10s of km/h that seismic waves propagate.
- cjensen 9y agoIt works well for Mexico, but would not be as useful in California. Earthquake P-waves travel at 5km/s. To get 60 seconds of warning, you must be 300km (186 miles) downstream of the detector. Mexico has a very unique situation [1]: the filled lake basins that Mexico City sits on have the same resonance frequency as buildings of a certain height. Earthquakes generate that frequency. So a serious earthquake 300km away can get the lake basin rocking, and that will knock down buildings of a certain height. A detector is nowhere near as useful in California. Consider the Loma Prieta Earthquake. It occurred 90km from the damaged sections of San Francisco. Assuming there is a detector within 10km of Loma Prieta, that is only 16 seconds of warning. Give a few seconds for the alert to get out, and it's barely 10 seconds. That's not enough time to do anything other than hide under a desk -- which you can already do after the earthquake starts. Such a system would be excellent for bringing trains to a halt, but that's pretty much it. [1] See preface of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1985_Mexico_City_earthquake https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1985_Mexico_City_earthquake
- dllthomas 9y agoGiven the opportunity, I know I'd rather be ten seconds further from a nearby stack of bricks or possibly-unsecured bookcase when an earthquake hits...
- rripken 9y agoIsn't that enough time to start to slow BART trains?
- jdavis703 9y agoThis is enough time for automated systems to have an orderly shutdown. Trains come to a stop so they don't derail. Toll both gates on bridges go down. Fire station doors open up. Elavators stop on the nearest floor and open their doors.
- Taniwha 9y agoDuring Loma Prieta I got maybe 15 secs of warning ... driving in Berkeley I heard the announcer on KQED (NPR affiliate in SF) say something like "shit earthquake" followed by dead air ... time to stop the car and see it ripple up the street (normally on that day of the week I would have been on the lower part of the freeway that collapsed, went into work a day early that week because of the possible World Series traffic)