4 ms·
I used to work for... A press agency you've all heard of. We had lots of big prints up about the place. Now, some of these were shot on films like Fuji NPZ (ISO
by gaius 16y ago
I used to work for... A press agency you've all heard of. We had lots of big prints up about the place. Now, some of these were shot on films like Fuji NPZ (ISO 800 colour negative) or first-generation photojournalist DSLRs (e.g. Nikon D1H, 2.1MP). At 60x40", they looked great. Nikon knew this; their second generation was "only" 4MP (D2H).
What matters in resolution is lp/mm; that is how many distinct pairs of black and white lines can fit within 1mm. See here: http://www.bobatkins.com/photography/digital/size_matters.html http://www.bobatkins.com/photography/digital/size_matters.ht... The long and the short of it is, unless you are shooting on a tripod with a cable release and a prime lens, there's really not much point worrying about megapixels. I once had a huge row with people on a mailing list about this; try as I might I couldn't make them understand the simple idea that it doesn't matter how many pixels you have if they can't all be assigned distinct values, there's no additional resolution there. They were the kind of people that bought the most expensive DSLR and stuck the cheapest lens on it. Then again if you'd spent 5 grand on a camera and someone did the maths for you you might be upset too... ;-)
Also note that cinema is only 2000 pixels across.
- pedrocr 16y agolp/mm is just a unit of measure for resolution and is directly constrained by the number of pixels. You can't resolve 10 lines with less than 20 pixels and in practice you need more. The article you quoted compares the same resolution in different sized sensors to show that smaller sensors need to resolve more lp/mm in sensor area to achieve the same file in the end. It shows that for the same MP count a larger sensor is better. What we are discussing is the opposite, for the same sensor size MP count is better. And as far as resolution is concerned that tends to be the case, even if the lens is the biggest bottleneck. In DSLRs we're getting to a point where resolution is more constrained by camera movement and lens quality than number of pixels but at the same time both those bottlenecks are being addressed with modern lens design and anti-shake techniques. We've come a long way in actual practical resolution from the 2MP/4MP cameras you mentioned.
- acqq 16y ago> for the same sensor size MP count is better That's very wrong. The number of photons is limited, the effective light-sensitive area drops with more MP, and with small sensors with more MP you then get more noise than a signal. It's hidden by post-processing but that also drops the real information. So less MP is better in a lot of common circumstances.
- pedrocr 16y agoIf you keep reading: >And as far as resolution is concerned that tends to be the case I was only talking about resolution. Lower MP gives you less noise but it won't give you more resolution. In the extreme case where you push the ISO maybe the extra noise can overcome the extra resolution. To make it simple lets say that at base ISO on a sunny day the higher MP will out-resolve the lower MP for a given sensor generation. My point isn't that low MP isn't good for many applications it's that saying that higher MP doesn't lead to higher resolution is just wrong. If you want resolution you need pixels to produce it and current cameras are mostly not wasting the resolution away. The excessive MP problem only really exists in consumer compacts. High-end compacts and DSLRs haven't been stretching the limits too much. The highest MP DSLRs right now have 24MP on a full-frame sensor, which is about the same density as 10MP on an APS sensor. Some of the APS ones have pushed that on to ~16MP with accompanying improvements in the individual pixels. Maybe you're thinking of camera phones with 8MP, those may very well be in the extreme case you mention where noise overcomes the extra resolution.
- acqq 16y agoIf you exclude professionals, nobody buys "full-frame" sensors. Excluding professionals, people don't even know what that means. Nobody brags about sensor size, everybody brags he has "more MP" than before. Also almost nobody wants to make photos only in the direct sunlight. Normal conditions are conditions with less than optimal light. So excluding "full-frame," more MP is actually worse, and people buy simply by believing "bigger number better." Edit: Let me stress once again: I'm not discussing a scenario of a "professional with a slave to carry all his equipment and another guy to set and hold the lights" but a "normal person" carrying not-too-expensive camera or even his phone and expecting "more MP better pictures."
- Retric 16y agoMotion pictures don't require the same resolution as still images. SD TV is only 640 x 480 but I don't think anyone wants a sub 1MP camera now days. PS: I somtimes notice individual pixels on a still shot in 2k theaters, but there is no way I can do that in the middle of an action shot.