5 ms·
"I don't see what claim a copyright holder has against either the user of the mod or developer of the mod." I've examined this problem and been keeping track o
by jerf 9y ago
"I don't see what claim a copyright holder has against either the user of the mod or developer of the mod."
I've examined this problem and been keeping track of it for nearly two decades now, keeping an eye out for legal resolution of it, and to the best of my knowledge there is still bupkis on this front legally. Even before we consider EULAs, it is legally quite clear that they could not take the two copyrighted products Fallout 3 and Fallout 4 and distribute the resulting new work. (And what EULA have you ever seen for a AAA game that would explicitly permit that?) It is completely legally unclear whether it is OK to release a tool that the end-user nominally uses to do the work themselves. On the one hand, there are certain arguments that this should be OK; I'm sure in the next few hours a few dozen of these will pour in. (Though I will say the most obvious error they make in general is to grossly overstate the degree of ownership the end-user has over the content, and, again, that's even before considering EULA clauses.)
On the other hand, if these arguments are accepted, then it allows a clear path to completely circumvent the aforementioned clear legal result that the end product could not be distributed. This is generally frowned on by the common law legal system, cynical comments to the contrary. It is also in a very real sense arguable that the user, who is putatively putting these two works together, can't really be said to be doing so when the sum total of their contribution is "the user clicked a button"; how can they be said to be responsible? It's pretty obvious that button-clicker can't be said to hold any copyright rights over the result, because "clicked a button" certainly doesn't raise to the level of creative input. It can be easily argued that in a legal sense the program is still the responsibility of the original combinind developer, and that the developer is still as responsible for the output as if they were directly distributing the output, what with the end results being (potentially at least) literally bit-for-bit identical.
I remain unaware of even the slightest hint of legal guidance in this area. And please note I'm not in this message trying to advocate either way; I'm simply discussing the situation. (I have opinions, but they are incomprehensible until you first understand that there is a problem at all.)
- taberiand 9y agoSurely because the end user bought both games clears things up a bit? If there's no intention of letting the resulting Franken-game off of the PC it's generated on, what outcome beyond more money for the games company could come from that?
- CWuestefeld 9y agoWhile I don't agree with the argument, perhaps one should look at it the same way as needing to "upgrade" one's license when moving from LP->Cassette->CD, or VHS->DVD->BluRay. In all of these cases, the license to the older media isn't taken as a valid license for the higher-class ones. If you've only paid for a crappy VHS tape, shouldn't there be some additional cost for getting the higher quality and convenience (now without rewinding!) if you want the BluRay? So in this case, the owner of a Fallout 3 game is seeking to have the higher-quality experience from the Fallout 4 engine, but without needing to incur that expense.
- stordoff 9y agoI don't think that's the right comparison. Moving from LP to CD etc. is changing the source format, which loading FO3 assets in FO4 isn't doing. If you bought a better device for playing your media (analogous to the FO4 engine), say a laser turntable or a VHS player that caches the video in memory to facilitate better short-term rewinding/pausing, you wouldn't be expected to re-license the content. (The fact that they are physical products also has _some_ bearing) VHS to DVD etc. is more akin to there being a re-release of FO3 with higher quality textures, and no-one is suggesting that owning the original necessarily entitles you to that.
- yjftsjthsd-h 9y ago> So in this case, the owner of a Fallout 3 game is seeking to have the higher-quality experience from the Fallout 4 engine, but without needing to incur that expense We are discussing the case of buying both, incurring all the expense.
- wmil 9y agoActually format shifting is expressly allowed under US copyright law. So it's entirely legal for you to create a CD from a vinyl record you purchased. Or a DVD from a VHS tape.
- ng12 9y ago> distribute the resulting new work There are several mods of this sort in the Elder Scrolls community that work because they explicitly do not do this. You basically take an open-source engine and point it at an existing install of the game. It knows how to read all the original data files but does not do any modification or redistribution of them. AFAIK Bethesda explicitly gave them a blessing for this approach.
- jcurbo 9y agoIn this case it's the OpenMW reimplementation of the Morrowind engine, which is fantastic and rapidly maturing (and capable of playing the game right now, they just continue to add features). http://openmw.org http://openmw.org The Bethesda thing as far as I know was about Morrowind on non-PC devices and they talk about it here: https://openmw.org/faq/#bethesda_legal https://openmw.org/faq/#bethesda_legal
- jamie_ca 9y agoBut then you've got stuff like Skywind, who are painstakingly recreating Morrowind from scratch in the Skyrim world builder, from terrain to new 3d models to music... Individually, building one thing from scratch should be clear from a copyright perspective. Trying to port the whole game from scratch though (rather than an end-user datafile conversion tool) feels like it's destined to failure.
- belorn 9y agoThere is some legal area around creating modified version of licensed copyrighted work. In US there is an explicit right called Adaptation Right and it has a few prior cases, like the one I recall where a person bought a physical painting and cut it into pieces only to reassemble into a mosaic to be resold. The court judged that case as infringement since the purchaser of the physical painting did not get the Adaptation rights. In EU there is a similar concept in the moral rights of the author where the integrity of work is considered an inalienable right. But the prior cases are not all like that. There are for example cases where a company produced a physical modification to a game console and got sued, and the supreme court siding with the defendant that such use did not modify the original work but rather was interfacing with it. Similar argument was made during the Oracle vs Google API case from 2010. When it comes to GPL, there has also been quite a bit discussion on the subject when a user combine the kernel with non-free modules. Is it the user that do it, is it the company that released the module, or is it the distribution that make the two easily combine-able? This became a rather heated discussion when Ubunutu made the module available and Debian had to decide on what the best approach was. I don't think that legal guidance actually exist since there is prior cases pointing in both directions. I would lean onto the question if the copyrighted work in question is being modified or not. Voice recording itself is very distinct from the rest of the work, so I could easily see that it is permissible for a project like this to pull the intact files from one game to an other, but its a very uncertain what the court would actually decide if it ever went to that. We also have to consider fair use rights, as they did with the Oracle vs Google case.
- userbinator 9y agoWhen it comes to GPL, there has also been quite a bit discussion on the subject when a user combine the kernel with non-free modules. Is it the user that do it, is it the company that released the module, or is it the distribution that make the two easily combine-able? This became a rather heated discussion when Ubunutu made the module available and Debian had to decide on what the best approach was. Essentially since the user-side is basically unenforceable. AFAIK GPL only applies to distribution, and even if it didn't, who's to know if someone privately combines all sorts of incompatibly-licensed software? We can do all sorts of technically illegal things, if we don't disseminate anything. Or as the old saying goes, "it's only illegal if you get caught." ;-)
- derefr 9y agoHere’s a precedent: a MIDI file doesn’t break copyright just because it could be used with a soundfont you don’t have rights to, to generate an audio file you don’t have rights to (because it’s a derivative work of the soundfont). Or, even simpler, a text file doesn’t break copyright just because you could print it using a copyrighted font you don’t have rights to. A game-modding program is exactly the same thing, here, as a MIDI sequencer or a printer; and the mod itself is exactly the same thing as the MIDI file or the text file. In both cases, you’ve got 1. a high-level description of a thing you’d like to make, and 2. a program that renders that high-level description using a supplied asset library. Presumably, there’s nothing stopping you from using an entirely public-domain asset library. Some unscrupulous people just happen to want to use a copyrighted one. (Just like some unscrupulous people happen to feed BitTorrent clients torrents that point to copyrighted material!) In both cases, there’s nothing inherent in the software that leads to it being used in that manner. It’s the user’s choice to point the software at an asset library—or a torrent—which contains content they don’t own. Of course, by this line of argument, a page with instructions for how to use the software in combination with the game’s copyrighted asset library, would be breaking copyright in about the same way The Pirate Bay is. The site hosting the software itself would best refrain from doing such. (And better yet if it comes with such an open asset library, such that it can’t be argued that breaking copyright is its only purpose in practice.)
- stonemetal 9y agoI disagree. In the case of MIDI, or a printer it has significant non infringing uses, and they weren't implemented solely, and with great detailed knowledge of the work in question. If you had a printer that was designed specifically to print Steven King's It and wouldn't work with any other novel then you would have something parallel to what they have built. Their project isn't general, you couldn't use it to target a couple of open source games, or a couple of games you wrote yourself.
- michaelmrose 9y agoIt seems like a poorly constructed argument to suppose that creativity is a required element to be the party responsible for creating a copy. Its very nearly the opposite of real. It is 100% unambiguously the customer who is creating the copy. Else bic and xerox will be sued out of existence shortly. Essentially the act of copying is totally without creative merit however the buyer of the game arguably has a fair use right to make use of the work in a different context not terribly dissimilar from format shifting. The only argument that could be made in this universe is that the customer is responsible for copyright infringement and that the modder is acting to enable copyright infringement. While its clear that say exist only to facilitate obvious piracy could be found to be enabling piracy its not obvious or even reasonable in this case. EULA's are of questionable utility not because they are legally invalid although I think they are trash but mostly because people don't care and its difficult to persecute your customers without losing them.
- Semaphor 9y ago> EULA's are of questionable utility not because they are legally invalid Most EULA's are invalid in Germany (and possibly in other parts of the EU) as you need to accept them before buying, which usually isn't the case, and they count as AGB (more or less Terms of Service) which are heavily regulated in what is allowed to appear in them (including no surprising clauses).
- jerf 9y ago"It seems like a poorly constructed argument to suppose that creativity is a required element to be the party responsible for creating a copy." It was. I elided, either deliberately or otherwise (I'm honestly not sure myself), a discussion on the idea that creativity is the standard in the ability to have copyright on something, and thus if you use that as a sort of guideline by choice, then you can make an argument that somebody who isn't bringing any creativity to the party can't be said to be the one who has produced any useful work. Therefore, the question is, if the end-user can't be said to have had any hand in creating the work, who did? Well, the only people left are the developers of the merging code. If it's not legal for said developers to simply distribute the result of the merge, how can it be legal for the result of the merge to appear on someone else's desktop anyhow, if the user didn't really do anything to produce it? Basically, this asks the question "What is distribution in a world of computing devices, anyhow?" And I reiterate I'm not trying to take a position here per se, but simply pointing out that there is a question here. The ideas of distribution were created before we were all equipped with multiple powerful media engines of our own. So the copy machine metaphor is not relevant, because copy machines fit into the old paradigm handily. We're not talking about simple copying or we'd already know the answer as to whether or not it is legal, give or take a bit of EULA. Fair use is unlikely to be even slightly relevant here, for all kinds of reasons. The internet conception of "fair use" does not legally exist, and the legal one seems irrelevant anyhow, since we're stipulating that the end-user has a license to at least the original manifestation of the copyrighted work anyhow. This is the sort of thing I was referring to when I said that step one is understanding there is a problem at all; in my experience most people grappling with these questions get so hung up on the things they want to be able to do that they can't see past those to the underlying issues. The simple truth is that just like pretty much everything else in life, a fair, equitable, and coherent legal answer to these questions may result in you being told you can't do something you want to do, but you can take some comfort in the fact that you won't be the only one, and the result is fair and equitable. (Of course the odds of us getting a fair and equitable legal answer approach zero, especially in light of the fact that virtually nobody has even thought about these issues coherently in the first place.)