4 ms·
>And, indeed, he argues, any form of intelligent life that evolves anywhere will automatically find that it lives somewhere suitable for it. Definitely deserve
by Groxx 16y ago
>And, indeed, he argues, any form of intelligent life that evolves anywhere will automatically find that it lives somewhere suitable for it.
Definitely deserves a "well, duh", but so many people seem averse to this line of thought. I can't count the number of times people have argued in my vicinity for God's existence based on how nicely our planet suits us... while in the same breath demonstrating that they understand nothing about what they're arguing against.
That said, the world is trying to kill us. If we didn't fight back with intelligence and reproduction, we'd die off rather quickly. Maybe it's not so suitable for us.
- wintersFright 16y agoDouglas Adams: Imagine a puddle waking up one morning and thinking, 'This is an interesting world I find myself in, an interesting hole I find myself in, fits me rather neatly, doesn't it? In fact it fits me staggeringly well, must have been made to have me in it!' This is such a powerful idea that as the sun rises in the sky and the air heats up and as, gradually, the puddle gets smaller and smaller, it's still frantically hanging on to the notion that everything's going to be alright, because this world was meant to have him in it, was built to have him in it; so the moment he disappears catches him rather by surprise. I think this may be something we need to be on the watch out for.'
- samstokes 16y agoThe anthropic principle is useful for rationally debunking "... but surely..." arguments, but it's definitely a last resort, because it doesn't tell you anything about how or why. It's a form of proof by reductio ad absurdum. You assume the counterfactual ("what if the universe couldn't support human life?"), derive a contradiction ("the universe can't support human life, yet here we are discussing it"), and conclude the phenomenon you're trying to explain is obviously true ("therefore we shouldn't be surprised that the universe supports human life"). In mathematics, reductio is a valid proof technique, but one of the least interesting, because it doesn't teach you much about the domain, whereas a proof by construction (for example) may suggest related theorems or techniques to explore. You can explain gravity by the anthropic principle (without gravity, we wouldn't have stars or planets, so human life as we know it could never have evolved; yet here we are discussing it), but we much prefer an explanation like "matter curves spacetime so that nearby matter feels an acceleration toward it". It gives us tools to visualise and calculate the phenomenon. It also gives us a narrative, albeit a very limited one (we don't know why matter curves spacetime!), and human understanding is very dependent on narratives.
- wlievens 16y agoThank you for wording it this way. This articulates very well how I've felt about the whole anthropic principle thing ever since I read about it.
- Dove 16y agoI find the anthropic principle unpersuasive. It is entirely irrelevant to the question it tries to answer. Imagine applying it in a different circumstance. Imagine two people coming upon a computer terminal, upon which was typed an elaborate love letter addressed to one of them. "What's this? John has written me a love letter!" "Nonsense, it's just noise. Probably a stack dump or something." "What? The odds are clearly against that." "Ah, but if it hadn't happened, we wouldn't be having this conversation, would we? Since the letter is necessary for the discussion, it requires no explanation." This is clearly wrong. The correct rejoinder is, "Yes, that's just the point. We shouldn't be having this discussion, but we are. Hence the letter still requires explanation, and the simplest is that John wrote it." The fact that our universe suits us does require explanation. If it didn't suit us, we couldn't ask the question, true enough. But that's just the point. We shouldn't be here to ask the question and yet here we are. It still requires explanation. Now, you can say, "Well, the universe is one of many, and we're in the one that suits us because we couldn't live anywhere else." Fine. Count the universes, run the probabilities, that's an explanation. Or you can say, "God created it." That's an explanation, too. What you cannot say is, "If it didn't suit us, we wouldn't be having this conversation, so it requires no explanation." That's a bunch of anti-intellectual sophistry that just annoys the people trying to honestly grapple with the question.
- Dove 16y agoAs a further friendly jab to atheists in present company, I've always found cosmological discussions funny. Here they are, willing to believe in an infinity of infinities of parallel universes, with varying physical laws and constants. They cannot detect them, they cannot describe them, they cannot say anything about them other than that there must exist enough of them for the probabilities to work out. Bazillions upon bazillions of totally barren invisible universes, just so this one can have stars. Meanwhile, I believe in a God who has intervened in history in a recoded and well attested way, who leaves behind lots of witnesses to his activities in the present and the past, whose prophecies come true and whose wisdom on human nature closely matches fact. He claims to have created the universe and I believe him. And the atheists think I'm the one who believes in things without evidence.
- eavc 16y agoWell, that's only the localized version of that argument. The better argument is concerned with the capacity for the universe itself to hold any life whatsoever. The relationship between the fundamental forces (strong, weak, gravity, etc.) and certain other constants in physics that, were they slightly different, would rending the whole of existence something entirely different. This leads to one of three conclusions. 1) It's a staggering coincidence that the one universe is such that it supports such nuance as life and consciousness. 2) The universe is cyclic and that this iteration happened to be the one where that occurred. 3) There are many universes. The problem with 2 is that it seems that our universe is not going to contract. So you'd have to fold in the likelihood that of the infinite cycles needed to get to this arrangement, this one that works for life and intelligence also happens to be the last one. As for 3, it solves many of the problems, but it's no more empirical than 1. It's favored in philosophical circles because it is naturalistic, but when dealing with questions like this, the idea of a prime mover isn't obviously any less natural than the idea of infinitely many bubble universes. The compelling argument against #1 has always been, "Well, making a god or God the first mover does nothing but shift the question to 'Who made God?'" The response to that it is only our universe in particular that is subject to the evidence that there was a beginning and will be an end state. We know matter is not infinite. We know it had a start, a finish, and we know pretty well that the universe is going to wind down at some point to a static end. This means that it had a definite beginning (or that we happen to be in the final cycle of infinite cycles which is a strange, maybe intractable metaphysical problem in and of itself). Anyway, a first-mover outside of our universe doesn't have any of these pressures on it. I assume that Hawking's work here (I'm not a physicist in the slightest) will seek to establish that there is a gravitational background to existence that is independent of our universe. In short, he's made gravity the first-mover. He's made gravity into god, an eternal entity that is unchanging and requires neither beginning nor end based on our understanding of it. I know that's a huge block of text, but this is an old, old idea. Hawking is hardly the first person to explore this territory, and he's almost certainly not the smartest, whatever that means. It's primarily a metaphysics problem, not a physics problem, but if one could discover in physics something that is independent of our universe, that would have major bearing on the metaphysical problem. TL;DR The anthropic argument is much more interesting when applied to the universe as a whole than to us or our planet in particular. It's an open problem in metaphysics. Hawking may shed more light on it through physics, but this isn't just a case of terribly ignorant people vs. civilized educated people. It's a real question. (Edited because I wrote "week force" which, while I could try to play it off as a novel way to refer to time, was clearly a stupid mistake.)