3 ms·
What's your interest in the subject? There's lots of good information, but you need some basic background information for context. It is hard to establish that
by DoreenMichele 9y ago
What's your interest in the subject?
There's lots of good information, but you need some basic background information for context. It is hard to establish that because so much communication is rooted in weird attempts at signalling "I'm a good person who isn't guilty of what you are accusing me of!"
The reality is that sociopaths have very high IQs and serial killers are typically small business owners, in part because it allows them freedom and control over their schedule that a full time employee typically lacks.
But when I have tried to comment on that on HN in the past, it tends to not go over well because people feel I am saying "Businessmen are evil asshats inclined to be serial killers" which isn't what I am saying at all.
Serial killers tend to have certain traits. But that doesn't mean having certain traits is some one way non refundable ticket to serial killer land.
It's interesting to me how those traits predispose individuals towards certain paths, some positive and some not. But traits are not some Greek Tragedy style inescapable destiny. And that's a really hard thing to talk about.
- openasocket 9y agoIt should be noted that sociopath is not a formally defined psychological term currently in use. The modern terms closest to the term are conditions like Antisocial personality disorder and Conduct disorder. And those conditions are associated with lower, not higher, IQs. The same is the case for serial killers (http://maamodt.asp.radford.edu/Serial%20Killer%20Information%20Center/Serial%20Killer%20IQ.htm http://maamodt.asp.radford.edu/Serial%20Killer%20Information... and https://www.fbi.gov/stats-services/publications/serial-murder https://www.fbi.gov/stats-services/publications/serial-murde...). One of the primary symptoms of those conditions is poor impulse control and planning ability. I've never seen the claim that serial killers tend to be small business owners, do you have a source for that?
- DoreenMichele 9y agoI used to watch shows like Cold Case Files. It was mentioned by an expert in such things as part of the profiling process for one of the suspects.
- wahern 9y agoEverything I've read has said that sociopathy is uncorrelated with IQ. You can have genius sociopaths and dumb sociopaths. Genius sociopath is the stereotype. Dumb sociopath might be the jerk next door who calls the cops when your newborn cries in the middle of the night. Nobody thinks he might be a sociopath, even though the whole neighborhood thinks he's an insensitive, insufferable, but harmless jerk--typical sociopath behavior, even though not exclusive to sociopaths.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoSociopath is not actually a defined clinical term. It is one of the reasons I use it. It helps convey something people will tend to colloquially understand, but there is no formal definition, so its meaning is flexible. But my understanding from an Intro to Psych class that I had years ago is that serial killers typically have six traits, including high IQ, plus other traits we would consider sociopathic, like lack of empathy. Generally speaking, if someone has a low IQ, I just consider them to be mentally retarded and not pathological. I don't know why anyone would call someone sociopathic who lacks the mental faculty to comprehend the consequences of their actions.
- openasocket 9y agoBeing unable to comprehend the consequences of your actions is actually related to the defining symptoms: poor planning and impulse control. And serial killers do NOT tend to have high IQ, the average IQ of a serial killer is within normal.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoYour assertions are inconsistent. In another comment, you admit that you know that sociopath is not a defined clinical term. Now you assert that there are "defining symptoms." So, I think you need to back up a step and figure out what your point is. When I use the term sociopath, I generally am talking about people who: 1. Lack empathy 2. Are narcissistic 3. Are manipulative 4. Do not have some innate sense of morality 5. Are very intelligent. This fits with traits listed in the article under discussion. It fits with what I learned in a college class, Intro to Psychology, about traits typical of serial killers. It fits with what I have heard in true crime shows profiling serial killers. So you and I are not on the same page, which is okay because it isn't a clinically defined term. But you and you are also not on the same page, and that makes it really hard to meaningfully engage you in discussion.
- psyc 9y agoI have a general interest in psychology, that I suppose is rooted in my own psychological struggles. A long time ago I was hospitalized for severe PTSD with psychotic features. I'd been in a state of unmitigated terror for a couple of days, when I felt a surge of activity and a sensation of chilliness in my head. In an instant, I felt at peace, but my most basic drives had flipped 180 degrees. Destruction and violence were very good and rewarding. The person talking to you now was reduced to a small monitor process who was witnessing this in horror. That monitor process managed to find a nurse and communicate enough to get me into isolation for the night. It passed after 10 minutes, and nothing like that ever happened again. But I'll never forget what it was like. It made me ask the question: what if killers aren't consciously transgressing at all? What if they're oblivious, because their reward pathways are telling them their behavior is fine, maybe even important? But I've never been able to find any literature about this. Most articles about "the mind of the psychopath" seem to project a lot, as if they assume the subject is "like them, but they don't care about hurting people." I suppose that Sadistic Personality Disorder might be closer to what I'm talking about? Haven't found much of interest about that either though. Haven't found anything at all about the possibility that some people have a mindset so alien, that no healthy person could come close to understanding it, without an exceptionally astute metaphor.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoFor a time, I ran a small private email list to discuss research related to brain wiring through the lens of the personal experiences of youth who were not neurotypical. This included my two sons. The list was set up to serve the emotional, social and psychological needs of my oldest son. I think he was about 15 or 16 at the time. When he lost interest, the list died and I ultimately disbanded it. You might find it helpful to look into brain research rather than psychological research. A lot of psychological research is really poorly done. But brain research has a lot of interesting tidbits based on some very solid experiments. You might also look for historical case files about individuals, plus read biographies and fiction with an eye towards getting insight into individuals and how they experience the world. Yes, people who are not neurotypical simply operate differently, so differently that a lot of what is written on the subject is biased to the point of uselessness. You might find the writings of Temple Grandin of interest. You might find it useful to join online parent support groups and lurk. You might get good book recommendations out of that, plus useful anecdotal information. Best.
- JamesBarney 9y agoWhat psychopathy test did your son take?