3 ms·
We built a rail system that spanned the country once and the highway system doesn't just maintain itself.
by emodendroket 9y ago
We built a rail system that spanned the country once and the highway system doesn't just maintain itself.
- bobthepanda 9y agoThat rail system still exists. Asking for a national high-speed rail system is like giving everyone a Rolls Royce.
- emodendroket 9y agoImagine if the response to the invention of rail were "well we just built all those canals."
- bobthepanda 9y agoThe original rail network was on par with airplanes in terms of relative improvement of speed of travel. The highway network did the same for travel to areas unlikely to ever get a rail connection. (There aren't that many sparsely populated countries with a rail connection to every town; even fairly dense countries don't manage this.) In today's world, HSR fills a very specific market niche; planes are much faster for long distances due to higher speed and small requirements for land acquisition, and cars are just as competitive for short distances due to the last-mile problem. So I don't think it's reasonable to connect every possible city pair in the US with HSR, but rather it's much better to just build strong regional networks of HSR that work on their own. There's no reason to build a continent-spanning HSR network.
- voidlogic 9y agoWe un-deregaulte rail and force them to offer the passenger service they used to do an excellent job at delivering.