4 ms·
The team's findings are yet to be verified. Sigh. Nine years, no independent verification. For reproducible incredibly unique behavior like that? Verification
by DanielBMarkham 16y ago
The team's findings are yet to be verified.
Sigh. Nine years, no independent verification. For reproducible incredibly unique behavior like that? Verification of a real phenomenon would be massive and immediate.
- marze 16y ago"Verification of a real phenomenon would be massive and immediate" Incorrect. Something involving alien life, comets, etc? Scientists run the other way. In a sense, this publication is verification by scientists in the UK of a previous paper by Dr. Louis that described the cells/particles/whatever reproducing at high temperature. If the cells are of extraterrestrial origin and are not DNA-based, this will be the scientific discovery of the century. One would hope that other labs will step forward and attempt to reproduce the work.
- DanielBMarkham 16y agoYou've misunderstood me. Take any of the phenomenon described, say "organisms that reproduce at 121 degrees" Send samples out, samples are reheated, other independent scientists verify this cause and effect. Sure, the entire set of wild claims would take a heckuva lot of verification. But any one of the claims? Dead simple. Why don't we have independent verification of dead simple things? Probably because there is no verification to be had, sadly.
- marze 16y agoI wouldn't be surprised if the Cardiff group spent six months on the research and three years getting the paper accepted. Agreed, it would have been nice if the Dr. Louis had sent samples to any lab that would take them, but instead he sent them to just one lab. Besides a possible lack of labs volunteering, perhaps he was motivated to retain as much credit for what he felt would be an important discovery. In any case, I still would like to see some other facilities step forward and attempt to verify the work.
- anigbrowl 16y agoArxiv is not a peer-reviewed journal where papers need to be accepted or not; it's more like HN for scientists, where anyone can present a result for consideration. Without digging into the history in detail, it's worth noting that one of the co-authors on this paper is at the University of Sheffield, and was vocally critical of an earlier paper on the same subject; his co-authorship may be a signal to other labs.
- anigbrowl 16y agoThe paper making these claims was only presented (not published) this week, presumably with the intention of allowing other labs to try reproducing the results. Quite a few places should have samples of the liquid already; this research team has no monopoly on them, and the rainfalls excited a fair amount of scientific curiosity. The analytical methodology presented is not especially complex or exotic, so if their observations are founded in fact then I would expect multiple independent verifications. You seem to think that the normal practice is to get widespread experimental confirmation before publication of any kind. It isn't. The point of scientific publishing is to make a result available for verification or invalidation by people who have no connection with the original experimenter. In peer-reviewed journals the referees serve this purpose, but there is nothing wrong with offering up the result for testing by others, especially since the required equipment is available in just about any biology lab. Your original comment complaining about 'nine years with no verification' suggests you thought the scientists in question had been making these claims since the red rain fell back in 2001. this is not the case either.
- carbocation 16y ago"In a sense, this publication is verification..." I don't think that Dr. Louis gets to verify his own work.
- jacquesm 16y ago> Something involving alien life If you find it on earth there is a bit of problem with right away drawing the conclusion that it is alien in nature. You could say the same thing about any other life on earth, or at least the initial life forms that gave rise to all the others. Just because it 'rained down' doesn't make it alien right away (rain contains tons of bacteria, in fact bacteria play a large role in the formation of rain! http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/99093.php http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/99093.php). There exists such a thing as an http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extremophile http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extremophile , an organism that lives in conditions not normally associated with life. These are quite fascinating, but still use 'our' DNA, it would not be too farfetched to suggest that an even earlier branch of life, split off before DNA was nailed down managed to live in some forgotten corner of our biosphere. Most - but not all - geneticists agree that before we had the current 4 base DNA there may have been one using only 2 bases, so the evolutionary machinery itself is evolving as well. It could be that if you go another step backwards, that you end up with cell like structures that have no DNA but that can still replicate. Certain clays have this capability, as Richard Dawkins noted in 'the blind watchmaker', and there are other variations on this theme: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abiogenesis http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abiogenesis
- troymc 16y agoHow hard can it be to verify? If these things actually reproduce, couldn't they give some to someone else? That someone else could then check to see if the things behave as reported. The "came from space" claim is more difficult to verify, but the other things (e.g. no DNA and no RNA) should be easy to check, and are interesting in their own right.
- ujal 16y ago"Today Louis, Wickramasinghe and others publish some extraordinary claims about these red cells. They say that the cells clearly reproduce at a temperature of 121 degrees C." They published it on 1 Sep. 2010. Give them some time. http://www.technologyreview.com/blog/arxiv/25699/ http://www.technologyreview.com/blog/arxiv/25699/
- jacquesm 16y agoExtraordinary claims require bullet proof evidence, I don't see that here, just a bunch of pretty pictures that could be a whole pile of other things than 'reproducing particles'. And if they do, they might simply be extremophiles, see above. Something isn't 'normal earth life' because you say so, something isn't earth life because you show it to reproduce (not because you say so) and because you prove that after you've conclusively proven that it indeed does reproduce does not contain any of our normal DNA, which should be fairly trivial. Then you make samples available for each and every lab in the world that wants a slice of they pie by reproducing your results. Research in isolation tends to produce un-reproducible results, the guy that did the original research is heavily involved in this effort so it does not count as any confirmation of the earlier claims. Remember: Pons, Fleischmann, Percival Lowell, Hwang Woo-suk and many many others.
- ujal 16y agoDont understand me wrong, I am skeptical too. Just wanted to clarify that its still early days as many here believed the opposite.
- metamemetics 16y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_rain_in_Kerala#Criticism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_rain_in_Kerala#Criticism
- Marticus 16y agoTo be fair, they published a paper in 2006. While slow, I can see how something like this would need heavily evidence-supported data to be even remotely non-laughable in even scientific communities. Now I'm not disagreeing in saying that proving something "simple" like, say, the ability for the cells to reproduce at 121C could be somewhat easily verified, but usually with things like this just verifying something like that isn't grounds for publication by any means. It's not that it's not interesting, but we're trying to prove that these are extraterrestrial life forms here. They're going to definitely want to prove, independently, the whole (likely) bundle of proposed theories, such as the fluorescence possibly linking them to (in the article) the Red Rectangle, plus verification that they do not have any type of DNA or RNA (harder than you'd think), plus other behaviorial/evolutionary traits not yet discovered before they consider it "proven" or otherwise. To say that since one cannot be verified, thus it is all irrelevant or false is just impatience. Work with a grad student sometime who is pursuing their dissertation, haha.