4 ms·
> "Unheard of"? People have dropped serious vulnerabilities with _zero_ warning before. Individuals sometimes do this, security companies very rarely - and bot
by GordonS 9y ago
> "Unheard of"? People have dropped serious vulnerabilities with _zero_ warning before.
Individuals sometimes do this, security companies very rarely - and both are shunned by the infosec community at large when they do so, as this is very unethical behaviour.
They registered the domain a couple of weeks ago - why give AMD only 24 hours notice?
In this case it does seem highly likely there is some stock market skullduggery afoot.
- tptacek 9y agoNo, they are not "shunned by the infosec community", no matter how nice that narrative sounds to you.
- GordonS 9y agoNo need for the attitude. Just take a look on twitter at what prominent members of the community are saying - they are not impressed with this behaviour. I'm also a member of that community, and hold the same view. The vast majority of the infosec community promote coordinated disclosure.
- tptacek 9y agoIf you're referring to vulnerability research twitter, and not, I don't know, IT security twitter, then no that's not what's happening. The CTS-Labs people are taking shit from vulnerability research twitter for overhyping the findings (meaning: they released a report on a day ending in "y"). People are noting the connection to the short selling --- but since this will be the 3rd or 4th time someone has very publicly done that, I don't see anybody shocked or outraged by it. But this public ostracism you referred to --- specifically the notion that dropping vulnerabilities with 24 hours notice would reliably generate it --- is fictitious. I'm not sure how you can be a part of the vulnerability research community and believe that there is public shunning attached to dropping zero-days, since many of the best known people in the community have repeatedly done exactly that.
- GordonS 9y agoI somehow sense you have already made up your mind about the ethics of this, have your own - rather fixed - views of what the majority of researchers think of it, and are unwilling to listen to opposing arguments. I'll stop trying.