4 ms·
>All of the exploits require elevated administrator access, with MasterKey going as far as a BIOS reflash on top of that. CTS-Labs goes on the offensive however
by andrepd 9y ago
>All of the exploits require elevated administrator access, with MasterKey going as far as a BIOS reflash on top of that. CTS-Labs goes on the offensive however, stating that it ‘raises concerning questions regarding security practices, auditing, and quality controls at AMD’, as well as saying that the ‘vulnerabilities amount to complete disregard of fundamental security principles’. This is very strong wording indeed, and one might have expected that they might have waited for an official response.
Extremely fishy. 1-day notice? Such aggressive wording without even the chance for AMD to address the concerns?
- allthenews 9y agoI wonder if this is could be Intel up to its old tricks again.
- turbografx16 9y agoThis is so fishy to me, it's so unprofessional of a security researcher. My tinfoil hat is already rattling...
- tptacek 9y agoHave you done a lot of published security research?
- strictnein 9y agoNice non-sequitur. Somehow the limiting factor on the ability of someone to judge professionalism is the number of papers they've written?
- tptacek 9y agoNo, I'm just noticing again that people who don't don't do a lot of vulnerability research have a lot of interesting opinions about the professional norms of people who do that work. But you never know --- maybe they do a lot of research, in which case, yes, their opinion on security research norms is a lot more interesting to me.
- allthenews 9y agoI am not a security researcher, and I do not speak for the person you are replying to, but I do believe that Intel's documented history of unethical, anticompetitive practices against AMD, for example, deliberate compiler handicapping for non Intel CPUs[1], is enough evidence to establish at least some suspicion regarding these results, especially considering the short warning given to AMD before public disclosure. I also wonder, what is the purpose of such white hat operations if vulnerabilities are disclosed publicly without anywhere near adequate time for a fix? Isn't SOP to give more time before going public? 1.https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_C%2B%2B_Compiler#Criticism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_C%2B%2B_Compiler#Criti...
- tptacek 9y agoI'm not arguing about Intel. If you think this is a giant conspiracy by Intel, more power to you --- I'm not engaging further on that.
- rainieri 9y agoMatasano and you got owned quite frequently back in the day. Should be judge you or your company or your opinions based on that too?
- ilovecars2 9y agoWhat’s the background here?
- tptacek 9y agoSick burn, dude.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- simias 9y agoYeah it's suspicious. The website[1] has many fancy infographics, marketable names and fear mongering but you have to dig into the whitepaper[2] to find any details about the actual vulnerabilities. And even then it starts only on page 8 of 20 and you discover that it's vulnerabilities targeting the secure boot infrastructure and you need local admin to exploit them. It's not good but it's not a new Spectre or Meltdown. If I was the tinfoil hat type I'd guess that Intel is trying to spread FUD but maybe it's just security researchers trying to generate a bit of buzz for their company at the expense of AMD. [1] https://www.amdflaws.com/ https://www.amdflaws.com/ [2] https://safefirmware.com/amdflaws_whitepaper.pdf https://safefirmware.com/amdflaws_whitepaper.pdf
- dnautics 9y agoIt's possibly even more nefarious than that: 1) execute a series of puts on AMD, 2) release exploit 3) profit. If you execute an option with a far time horizon and give the company enough time to mitigate their vulns, then I think this is not an irresponsible thing to do (as it incentivises the company to actually do something), but with 24 hours notice...
- mizzack 9y agoSeeing as CTS-Lab's CFO also founded a hedge fund you're probably on the right track. >Yaron co-founded CTS-Labs in 2017, and previously served as an intelligence analyst in the Israeli Intelligence Corps Unit 8200. He is also the founder and Managing Director of NineWells Capital, a hedge fund that invests in public equities internationally. He holds a B.A. and M.A. from Yale University.
- tptacek 9y agoIndependent researchers don't owe AMD a chance to address anything. They bought the chips on the open market where AMD makes them available, and then used their own time and materials to conduct their own research. Their work product is their own, and AMD has no claim to it. There are, as I see it, two rational, coherent ways to be outraged about this story: 1. The vulnerabilities are fabricated and the report is fraudulent, in which case, by all means, slag the researchers. 2. The vulnerabilities are real, in which case. AMD is an 11 billion dollar company that got outmaneuvered by what appears to be 4 dudes in a basement.
- webbles 9y agoGo fuck yourself. There are plenty of ways to be outraged by the actions of these "independent reseachers." How about 1. Irresponsible disclosure affecting end users. 2. Shady trading practices of their hedge fund CFO. Just to name 2. You are a fucking retard, and your obvious anti-AMD bias is showing.
- sctb 9y agoWe've banned this account. If you would like to post civilly and substantively you're welcome to email us at hn@ycombinator.com and we'll unban it if we believe you will. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- travmatt 9y agoI wonder if the unusually short disclosure process was related to their disclosure of related financial interests. If it was, it’d seem that this research was in support of a financial play similar to how Muddy Waters shorted St. Jude Medical on the basis of insecure medical devices. That would appear to be a legitimate strategy, but if the market didn’t punish Intel for their processor vulnerabilities it seems likely they’d react similarly here and the research would fail to move the stock price in any significant way.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- 9y ago
- Digital-Citizen 9y ago> 1-day notice? Such aggressive wording without even the chance for AMD to address the concerns? Are the reporting parties under any obligation to give AMD notice? Behaving according to AMD's wishes is not an obligation. Businesses will be the first to tell you that agreements and laws form obligations, not what someone perceives as a nice thing to do. If not, then you're reacting to a distraction, a detail that doesn't matter: how the corporate-friendly tech press is trying to shift blame away from the party that either sold CPUs with bugs in them (mistakes happen, and this is unfortunate) or distributed nonfree (proprietary, user-subjugating) software which also happens to contain insecurities (a malicious and unjust way to distribute software).
- jaxtellerSoA 9y agoYou mean to tell me my machine can be exploited if I let someone do one of the following. 1. Flash the BIOS 2. Have admin access Holy shit, this calls for a full fledged panic! I am very disappointed anandtech.com even bothered to give this smear campaign the time of day. If someone can flash your BIOS or has admin access then you already have way bigger problems.
- kbenson 9y agoCTS-Labs is very forthright with its statement, having seemingly pre-briefed some press at the same time it was notifying AMD, and directs questions to its PR firm. The full whitepaper can be seen here, at safefirmware.com, a website registered on 6/9 with no home page and seemingly no link to CTS-Labs. Something doesn't quite add up here. Anandtech is reporting on the situation more than the flaws. That does require covering what the flaws are though. Not covering it at all isn't exactly performing good journalism either.
- volgo 9y agoPeople here seems to be mentioning short sellers being connected to this research as if there's some sinister collusion going on. This is the entire point of short selling, and SEC encourages this type of activism. It allows people who can provide expert knowledge to profit off a trade if it can reveal damaging and legitimate information about a company For example, a short seller last year revealed (through extensive research), that Valeant Pharmaceuticals was stuffing its channels and faking its finances. He placed a huge sort sell and went public with the damaging info - tanking the stock from $270 to $12 and made a ton of profit off of it: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/08/magazine/the-bounty-hunte.. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/08/magazine/the-bounty-hunte.... Without this incentive, why would anyone bother to reveal damaging info? You're placing your self as a target with no reward. The payment is the natural balance of the market. So yes, this research firm is connected w a hedge fund, and they have a very vested interest. But that doesn't make their claim untrue
- jadedhacker 9y agoI'm not saying it was them, but I wouldn't be surprised if Intel was trying to recover its reputational damage by hiring ppl to heavily research breaks in AMD chips to even the reputational playing field. They're the ones that stand to gain the most from this legal but shady tactic and have been reportedly scared of losing their long held market dominance in desktops and servers. Iirc AMD wasn't vulnerable to Meltdown which I speculate changed the market calculus in ways detrimental to Intel that both companies would be well aware of. Interestingly, you'll note that the researchers claim public interest as their reason for non-standard practices, but then later it is revealed you need admin privileges to exploit them. The rhetoric the researchers use is inflammatory and staged in a media savvy way like a PR campaign. This is a totally evidence free assertion and I'm not an infosec person (and am therefore happy to be set straight by experts) but I'll be happy to crack open the popcorn if something interesting is revealed a few years down the line.