4 ms·
> The reality is that small piston aircraft are approximately as fuel efficient as the vehicles around you on the highway This is just objectively wrong. Befo
by pc86 9y ago
> The reality is that small piston aircraft are approximately as fuel efficient as the vehicles around you on the highway
This is just objectively wrong.
Before taking wind into account, a Cessna 172 travels 120kts on a good day and at altitude and appropriately leaned can get down to 8 gallons an hour.
120 nautical miles in 140 miles (less, but benefit of the doubt and all). That's 17.5 miles per gallon. At cruise altitude. Leaned appropriately. You can tack on another few gallons for the climb, and you're going mixture rich on descent so you're back up to 10-11 gph for the last 20-30 miles of your trip. You're lucky to get 10mpg overall for a flight, and that's using gas that costs $5 a gallon.
There are a LOT of benefits to GA flight in order to get around. Fuel efficiency is definitely not one of them.
- sixbrx 9y agoWell for the autos you need to consider that they may commonly be in rush hour traffic, too, stopped and idling quite a bit.
- pc86 9y agoIt's a good thing the EPA has highway fuel economy ratings then so we can compare apples to apples.
- DennisP 9y agoHe specified "general aviation aircraft not designed in the 1950's." The Cessna 172 was first flown in 1955: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cessna_172 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cessna_172 Also, it may be worth taking into account that airplanes travel in straighter lines.
- pc86 9y agoI'm talking about overall miles traveled so I'm not sure the straight line thing matters. Yes for the same trip you will travel a shorter distance in a plane. The plane will also be running for 20-30 minutes prior to takeoff and 5-10 minutes after landing. If you exclude GA aircraft not designed in the mid-20th century, you exclude 90% of GA aircraft and 99% of certified GA aircraft. We can make that distinction if you want but it ignores reality.
- DennisP 9y agoI think it's an important distinction in the context of evaluating the likely performance of a brand new aircraft.
- schiffern 9y ago>The plane will also be running for 20-30 minutes prior to takeoff and 5-10 minutes after landing. That's been true up until now, but this vehicle doesn't need to do that. Also, most e-planes have a small motor in the wheel for taxiing. >I'm talking about overall miles traveled so I'm not sure the straight line thing matters. Yes for the same trip you will travel a shorter distance in a plane. I think you just answered your own question.
- godelski 9y agoPlanes are updated, just an FYI. And most GA aircraft are older. That's how most people fly, by buying an aircraft that is the price of a car (<$50k). I fly a Cherokee 140. One of the most common aircraft, as with the Skyhawk. My fuel consumption is 8.4gal/hr at 75% mixture and 5.6gal/hr at 50%. Assuming I'm doing an average ground track of 100mph (for easy math), that's 12-18mpg (not counting that I'm 100% rich at TO and LND). I wouldn't exactly call it fuel efficient, but it isn't burning like an oil refinery on fire either. I also don't pay $5 for gas ($4.09 today, but it isn't uncommon to see it at $3.50). But you do have to consider speed and time to destination if we're going to compare to cars. One thing to also consider is that avgas is still leaded. And for anyone interested, here is the POH for the Skyhawk[1] and Cherokee[2]. Note that fuel consumption will be in hours or gal/hr when discussing aircraft. Mpg doesn't make as much sense. [1] https://www.flyingd.net/documents/N739EF_172N_POH_000.pdf https://www.flyingd.net/documents/N739EF_172N_POH_000.pdf [2] http://wilgroveairport.net/files/Cherokee%20140%20POH.pdf http://wilgroveairport.net/files/Cherokee%20140%20POH.pdf Disclaimer: Use the POH provided with your aircraft.
- DennisP 9y agoBut the whole point of this discussion is to evaluate the likely performance of a new aircraft, not the overall performance of the existing fleet. This particular new aircraft is electric, so leaded avgas won't be an issue.
- pc86 9y agoCherokee 180/181 checking in! $4.09 would be great, $5.12 at my base this morning. $0.35 club discount helps though.
- godelski 9y agoI fly in the south and as long as I'm not at a major airport (in class G) I can get gas pretty cheap. Poking around on some maps I can even find it cheaper. Really all depends where you fly.