3 ms·
It's funny how the word Piracy is used. One has to wonder what kind of pirates we are talking about. The "Pirates of the Caribbean" type of pirates did loot sh
by ThomPete 16y ago
It's funny how the word Piracy is used. One has to wonder what kind of pirates we are talking about.
The "Pirates of the Caribbean" type of pirates did loot ships, but what they stole where often goods produced by slavery and itself stolen from the colonies.
Piracy or as I prefer to call it – copying is the result of a disconnect between price and cost.
When you steal you take something away from others so it's not there anymore, but copying isn't stealing it's copying by using an internet connection you pay for yourself, onto a computer you have paid for yourself. In other words the only one who have any real cost is the one who copies.
There is absolutely nothing that states that it's fair for musicians or other artist to make millions by mass producing and distributing at almost zero cost.
And now that we are on the subject of newspeak anyway. If you produce an album with the purpose of selling it, you aren't really an artist anymore, you are a businessman and your product is a commodity.
Deal!
- kscaldef 16y agoThere is absolutely nothing that states that it's fair for musicians or other artist to make millions by mass producing and distributing at almost zero cost. Is it fair for software developers to make money by mass producing and distributing at almost zero cost?
- bediger 16y ago> Is it fair for software developers to make money by mass producing and distributing at almost zero cost? Well, what about simple Econ 101? In a competitive market, prices tend towards the marginal cost of production. Wow! Someone just invented a technology that allows the duplication and distribution of recorded music to happen at almost zero cost! Is it fair for the people whose livelihoods are changed by this new tech to lobby/pay for laws to maintain the price of their good at pre-new-tech levels? Is if fair for that new technology to be legally limited by highly unpopular, and un-democratically-created laws? Is it fair for me to be deprived of the use of that new technology for un-infringing uses? And yes, I've taken advantage of the new technology to mass produce and distribute some of my own software are near zero-cost: http://www.stratigery.com/acl.html http://www.stratigery.com/acl.html Have a copy, for free!
- ThomPete 16y agoIt's neither fair nor unfair. My point is simply that it's not a right, it's a possibility.
- jcl 16y agoFor the record, the use of the word "pirate" as "one who takes another's work without permission" dates back to the 1700s, when Daniel Defoe wrote of one of his novels: "Its being Printed again and again, by Pyrates"... hardly newspeak. http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=pirate http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=pirate