4 ms·
> Chinese labor law dictates a 40-hour workweek and extra pay for overtime, but many companies circumvent those rules by asking employees to sign contracts that
by koolba 9y ago
> Chinese labor law dictates a 40-hour workweek and extra pay for overtime, but many companies circumvent those rules by asking employees to sign contracts that say their jobs require flexible work schedules.
Being able to supersede labor laws by forcing^Wasking employees to sign a contract that nullifies them is suspect at best. I get that office tech workers aren't the factory assembly line workers for which these laws were originally designed but the exclusions need to come from the other direction.
> Huawei Technologies employees work on the last Saturday of each month, and that earns them an extra 12 days by the end of the year that they can take in pay or days off. A year into their jobs, Huawei’s Chinese staff can sign a “dedicated employee agreement,” voluntarily forgoing paid vacation days and overtime.
That quote links to a different article[1] explaining this further:
> A year into their jobs, Chinese staff may sign a “dedicated employee agreement,” voluntarily forgoing paid vacation days and overtime. One Huawei engineer said he signed the agreement four years ago to start receiving shares as part of his compensation. The closely held firm says its shares are owned entirely by its executives and employees.
So the deal is "Work an extra 12 days per year for 12 days of pay/vacation. Then give it up along with all the rest of your vacation days and maybe we'll give you some equity. Also, we can probably claw back the equity. Also, you'll probably never be able to actually cash it out.
[1]: https://www.wsj.com/articles/huaweis-founder-casts-a-long-shadow-over-telecom-giant-1480715055 https://www.wsj.com/articles/huaweis-founder-casts-a-long-sh...
- mtgx 9y ago> that earns them an extra 12 days by the end of the year that they can take in pay or days off That line is hilarious. How exactly are they "earning" anything? They're just getting deferred pay for those days or deferred day offs, which were supposed to be day-offs in the first place, as they were saturdays.
- dis-sys 9y ago> That line is hilarious. How exactly are they "earning" anything? They're just getting deferred pay for those days or deferred day offs, which were supposed to be day-offs in the first place, as they were saturdays. Well done, trying to claim/protect rights for Huawei engineers who just happen to be the best paid tech workers in China getting 20 times of the national average. Have a look at their online discussions which are free to view, just check the sheer number of Groupon style shopping frenzy for investment properties - http://xinsheng.huawei.com/cn/index.php?app=forum&mod=Detail&act=index&id=2920773 http://xinsheng.huawei.com/cn/index.php?app=forum&mod=Detail... http://xinsheng.huawei.com/cn/index.php?app=forum&mod=Detail&act=index&id=1070925 http://xinsheng.huawei.com/cn/index.php?app=forum&mod=Detail... http://xinsheng.huawei.com/cn/index.php?app=forum&mod=Detail&act=index&id=130698 http://xinsheng.huawei.com/cn/index.php?app=forum&mod=Detail... there are hundreds more, if not thousands more. Trust yourself one thing - when their average pay is like 20 times of the national average, they don't need you to jump up and argue for their annual leave related rights.
- pgeorgi 9y ago> argue for their rights. Pointing out such semantic plays isn't fighting for their rights, it's calling a spade a spade. Which can be entirely self-interested, given how such schemes are imitated wherever possible.
- dis-sys 9y agoI put the keywords "Huawei group buy property" (in Chinese) in google and it returned almost 300 results from their company's discussion forum xinsheng.huawei.com. Now you can factor in those organised offline and those using other social media such as WeChat groups. You can paint it whatever you like. The point here is clear - you don't jump up and argue Wall St analysts deserve better pay and more annual leaves, for the exact same reason, when Huawei engineers are getting 20 times of the national average pay, it is not a smart call to point out such stupidities seen in one of Huawei's internal docs.
- pgeorgi 9y ago> The point here is clear - you don't jump up and argue Wall St analysts deserve better pay and more annual leaves Nowhere did the grand-poster do that for the Huawei folks. And Huawei paying "outrageous" money doesn't exempt them from questions and/or ridicule when doing stupid stunts (even if related to the very same money) like promoting deferred vacation as "extra". I'd expect Huawei execs to be able to count.
- ecshafer 9y agoHuman rights are human rights. The scheme is an immoral play to get work out of workers and crush them. The money is inconsequential. you bring up wallstreet, well I think their workers should have guaranteed time off and strict weekly work hours also. Anything over 40 hours should be paid with extra money or extra time off as far as I am concerned.
- bad_good_guy 9y agoYou are immediately combative to a comment that merely points of the ridiculousness of the marketed "benefit" of working extras days for these employees. Which horse do you have in this race?
- sevensor 9y ago> I get that office tech workers aren't the factory assembly line workers for which these laws were originally designed but the exclusions need to come from the other direction. Maybe they're not operating the machines, but even in the U.S., white-collar engineers at a fab will often find themselves working north of 60h every week. Because you're salaried, there's no overtime pay. Also, you'll carry a pager and be responsible for answering it 24 hours a day, every day. And since the fab doesn't stop on weekends, you either work a shift or rotate weekends with your team. PTO is usually approved, but using a substantial fraction of it will result in a bad review. A capped portion of the remainder gets cashed out at the end of the year, and the rest evaporates. And that's the United States. I'm sure China takes this to a whole other level. (Source: recovering semiconductor process engineer.)
- anoonmoose 9y agoAlso, you'll make 2-3x the average salary in the US. TANSTAAFL
- sevensor 9y agoTrue that. It's still a backup plan if I'm ever really desperate for money. It's brutal if you have a family though.
- avs733 9y agoHonestly its not worth it. I know that is a privileged position, but the quality of life was so bad that I just ended up with a ton of savings that I used to take 6 months off and travel and decompress/deal with all the mental health stuff resulting from the job after I quit.
- macNchz 9y agoThere are quite many routes to making 2-3x the national average salary that don’t require 24/7 pager duty. I’ve done on-call rotations, but being ‘on’ nonstop sounds like torture and a recipe for burnout.
- 9y ago
- justinhj 9y agoI’ve worked in three Western countries and all of them found a way to make me work more than 40 hours for free... UK brought in laws to protect workers from unpaid excessive overtime but employees were asked to sign waivers. Those who didn’t sign or didn’t work OT would not progress. Canada. Tech employees are exempt from normal overtime laws whether they like it or not. Tech employees being applied very broadly. USA. Company requires straight up rejection of employment law in the form of At Will Employment. That’s not to condone or justify the 9 9 6 thing in China and the culture in many asian countries in general of long hours at the office. I hope they move away from that in time