3 ms·
The Uber Elevate study from 2016 answers many of these foundational questions. A traditional car achieves about 1 mile/kWh. An electric car achieves 3 miles/kW
by FabHK 9y ago
The Uber Elevate study from 2016 answers many of these foundational questions.
A traditional car achieves about 1 mile/kWh. An electric car achieves 3 miles/kWh, since the electric drivetrain is much more efficient. An electric plane might achieve around 2 mile/kWh. So, worse than an electric car, but better than a conventional car.
Some background: A car has aerodynamic and roll drag. At typical speeds (50 mph), they're of approximately the same magnitude. A plane has aerodynamic (parasitic) drag, similar to a car, but no roll drag, but instead an additional aerodynamic drag, the so-called induced drag, that is concomitant with generating lift. At typical speeds (higher than a car though), they're also approximately the same magnitude.
With lots of simplifications, one can thus say that one basically trades roll drag for induced (=lift generating) drag.
EDIT TO ADD: Link, the economics section starts on page 81 or so: https://www.uber.com/elevate.pdf https://www.uber.com/elevate.pdf
- sigi45 9y agoSo whats the real power consumption? After all, getting that thing up into the air IS the problem and not flying it. "These examples for car and VTOL have only considered the energy required to cruise at a specific speed, and doesn’t include the additional energy required to get the vehicle to cruise for either the car (acceleration) or VTOL (takeoff). " They know exactly why this figures are missing.
- FabHK 9y agohm, I tend to disagree. You might underestimate how much energy is spent on overcoming drag, and how strong the earth acceleration g is: One always needs to overcome it, and overcoming it just a bit more for a while is enough for a climb, basically. If we take the performance section for the Cessna 172 N, for example, we see that it burns 8.4 gallons per hour at a (speedy) 75% power cruise. It takes 10 minutes to climb up to 6000 ft, and burns 1.9 gallons. In cruise, it would burn 1.4 gallons in that time. So, the climb requires about a third more. So, given that PEVA (personal electric VTOL aircraft) would likely cruise at fairly low altitudes, and the climbing constitute only a small part of a flight, say a quarter, the total extra fuel consumption would be a fairly minor increase on top of the quoted numbers. Note also that cars tend to accelerate and brake much more than aircraft tend to climb and descent.