4 ms·
> is there any reason not to consider the deist view No reason not to consider it, but the evidence against it is overwhelming. Specifically, the evidence is
by lisper 9y ago
> is there any reason not to consider the deist view
No reason not to consider it, but the evidence against it is overwhelming. Specifically, the evidence is overwhelming that whatever the ultimate cause is, it is computationally simple, that is, its Kolmogorov complexity is small. That is fundamentally at odds with most people's conception of God.
- hyperpallium 9y agoWhat's the evidence that the first cause had low Kolmogorov complexity?
- lisper 9y agoThe fact that the laws of physics can be written as simple mathematical equations.
- oldandtired 9y agoThese "laws" of physics can be written as simple mathematical equations only because these equations make various simplifying assumptions. Whenever mathematics is applied to the real world, there are always simplifying assumptions made. Otherwise, the problems become intractable. It does not matter what area that you investigate, you will find that assumptions are made to simplify the mathematics. For our purposes, these "simple" equations work, but they are still limited approximations of what we see around us.
- lisper 9y ago> these equations make various simplifying assumptions Not the fundamental equations. Yes, a lot of complexity emerges from those, just like a lot of complexity emerges in the Mandelbrot set. But as far as experiment has been able to determine, the equations of GR and QM are exactly correct.
- projektir 9y agoIsn't the whole problem that current QM equations are not the whole picture, and work on QM scale only?
- lisper 9y agoNo, QM works at every scale, it's just that at large scales the math is too hard to carry through and we have to use approximations. It is true that either QM or GR (or both) as currently formulated will break down near the event horizons of black holes, but there is no reason to believe that once we figure that out the result will be significantly different in character than all the other laws of physics that have been worked out up to now.
- projektir 9y ago> QM works at every scale > either QM or GR (or both) as currently formulated will break down near the event horizons of black holes These seem to be in conflict. Black holes is exactly what I was talking about. From what I've understand there's no unified theory or anything close to a unified theory for certain objects in space, which means the landscape is very open for some weird, weird stuff. Physics is already extremely weird. > there is no reason to believe that once we figure that out the result will be significantly different in character than all the other laws of physics that have been worked out up to now I would consider both general relativity and quantum mechanics to be drastically different things compared to what came before, going from "this is reasonable" to "WTF", so I can't agree with this statement at all.
- lisper 9y ago> the landscape is very open for some weird, weird stuff Yes, that's true. > Physics is already extremely weird. Yes, that's true too. It is weird. But it's not complicated (in the strict computational sense). > I would consider both general relativity and quantum mechanics to be drastically different things compared to what came before In one sense yes, but not in the sense that matters for this discussion. GR and QM are conceptually very different from Newtonian mechanics, but they are similar insofar as they can be written down as simple (in the technical sense) mathematical equations. So there's no reason to expect that the next surprise will be different in that regard.
- hyperpallium 9y agoAlong the lines of The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Mathematics in the Natural Sciences (also, Hamming's one)? One factor is that mathematical notation was shaped to describe natural laws (over many different laws). Though I agree that this doesn't seem to fully explain the simplicity and generality. However, I do want to note that Occam's razor can justify whatever you like, if you're allowed to define the language you use without it counting as entities (like choosing a prior for Bayes').
- lisper 9y ago> I do want to note that Occam's razor can justify whatever you like, if you're allowed to define the language you use without it counting as entities No, that's actually not true. This is one of the cool things about Kolmogorov complexity, it is actually independent of the computational model. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kolmogorov_complexity#Invariance_theorem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kolmogorov_complexity#Invarian...
- EGreg 9y agoBut not independent of the description language. In fact, highly dependent on your choice of it.
- lisper 9y agoNo. That's the whole point of Turing equivalence. The description language doesn't matter at all. It only changes the absolute measure of KC by a constant factor. But we don't care about the absolute measure (because KC is not computable anyway). All we care about is upper bounds (because that's all we can compute) and the relative size of the KC of one system compared to another. No matter how you slice it, the KC of physics is orders of magnitude less than the KC of a person (or a god). That's the reason people can actually do physics.
- maxander 9y agoJust for the sake of asking interesting questions, and not in contradiction of your point about “most people’s conception of God”: Roughly speaking, the “God hypothesis” is simply that the ultimate cause is a person of some sort. What is the Kolmogorov complexity of “personhood”?
- lisper 9y agoWell, no one really knows. But it's almost certainly more than a few hundred bits, which is the KC of GR and the Dirac equation.
- dvt 9y ago> Specifically, the evidence is overwhelming that whatever the ultimate cause is, it is computationally simple, that is, its Kolmogorov complexity is small. That is fundamentally at odds with most people's conception of God. The probability that the first cause (FC) is computable is basically zero, so it most likely won't have a Kolmogorov complexity. For example, not even entropy is computable[1][2], let alone FC. [1] https://arxiv.org/pdf/0808.1678.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/0808.1678.pdf [2] https://www.math.iupui.edu/~mmisiure/open/JM1.pdf https://www.math.iupui.edu/~mmisiure/open/JM1.pdf
- lisper 9y agoI think that when you talk about the "first cause" you mean something different than what I mean when I say "ultimate cause." I'm not talking about what caused the Big Bang, I'm talking about what causes physics now. It is of course possible that whatever caused the big bang was computationally complex. There is no way to eliminate that possibility. But if it was, it left no evidence behind.