4 ms·
(elsewhere in the thread) Why do people jump to the conclusion that "specifically recruiting women" = "lowering standards". It is actually a logical fallacy.
by titzer 9y ago
(elsewhere in the thread)
Why do people jump to the conclusion that "specifically recruiting women" = "lowering standards". It is actually a logical fallacy.
Suppose you wanted turkeys at least 10kg in weight. Suppose that there are only wild turkeys, either white or gray, with a 90/10 population white/gray.
Well, since you need to find and catch turkeys, it turns out that catching white turkeys is easier just because they are easier to see! So you end up with 10 big fat white turkeys and no gray turkeys at all. Are gray turkeys slimmer on average? Worse? Different distribution? No. They are just harder to find.
After a while, all the big fat white turkeys are gone, because everyone is grabbing them up.
But hey there's whole population of big fat gray turkeys that you _can't even see_.
This is why it is rational to specifically recruit women.
Even from a purely self-interested point of view, it's an untapped market. It'd be stupid not to recruit women. In fact, not hiring women would mean that you eventually have to lower your standards _for men_.
- sparkie 9y agoYou're introducing a logical fallacy here too, by arguing that "all white turkeys are gone," which is absolutely not the case for hiring male developers. If your hiring pipeline is working, and you're successfully hiring qualified, capable candidates who all happen to be male, there would be absolutely no reason for you to change your practices which may result in you not finding the competent developers you need. It is lowering standards if you have to transition from a working recruitment process to one which may not work, but ticks a diversity box. On the other hand, there's the possibility that by trying to recruit women specifically, that their hiring process could improve. But who is going to take such a risk when they've already got a working process, and no solid argument that changing it will bring in better workers.
- titzer 9y ago> You're introducing a logical fallacy here too, by arguing that "all white turkeys are gone," which is absolutely not the case for hiring male developers. I'm not arguing that either, but even if I was, it wouldn't be a logical fallacy as much as it would be an empirically testable fact, and if I was wrong it would be a factual error, not a logical fallacy. > It is lowering standards if you have to transition from a working recruitment process to one which may not work, but ticks a diversity box. I don't see how that lowers standards, it might just be ineffective. The salient point being that lowering standards is about standards (i.e. "fatness of turkeys"), not how many people you hire (number of turkeys). Now if you want to argue about whether specifically recruiting women would be _effective_, that's a different conversation, but my OP stands on logical grounds.
- manfredo 9y agoThe issue is that a lot of companies are setting diversity targets that are considerably above the share of said diverse groups in tech. How does my company (on the order of thousands of employees) manage to constantly hire women at 1.5-2x proportional representation in tech? A: we structure our hiring policies such that it's easier for women to get through the interview pipeline. I'd point out that we don't try to hire unqualified women, but we do make it such that a lot of qualified men don't make it. It's more about raising the bar for men - though plenty argue that this is still unfair. I can understand tech companies' frustration. They're getting flak for not hiring many women, but people and news outlets rarely compare companies' diversity results with the diversity of tech as a whole. So it kicks off a competitive race where all companies are trying to have 40-60% higher than average representation of women. This is, by definition, impossible so companies end up resorting to changing the hiring pipeline.
- enord 9y agoAll other things being equal, yes. But therein lies the rub (or the stuffing, if you will). >Are gray turkeys slimmer on average? Worse? Different distribution? No. They are just harder to find. Who knows? Anyone who tries to find out are hung out to dry. Now I value my precious bodily fluids so I'll refrain from commenting, but I've heard there's been some science done somewhere, once or twice.
- Rapzid 9y agoTwo problems: 1.) You're not catching all the white turkeys. You are catching 9 white to 1 grey because that's the distribution of the population the turkeys wandering into your feed trap come from. Often your traps(small startup) will contain 10 white turkeys and zero grey turkeys when you check them. 2.) Women are not an untapped market.
- titzer 9y agoInternal hiring data from $big_corp disagrees with both 1) and 2).