4 ms·
It's not so much that they're afraid of it, it's that changing syntax imposes a mental tax on them for no reason. Once you've been programming in a language fo
by nostrademons 9y ago
It's not so much that they're afraid of it, it's that changing syntax imposes a mental tax on them for no reason. Once you've been programming in a language for more than a few months, you no longer think in terms of tokens. Rather, your muscle memory now has constructs for "This is what a variable binding looks like. This is what a for-each loop looks like. This is what a method call looks like," and you can just think in terms of the desired semantics rather than how to type that into an editor.
A language with a new and unfamiliar syntax requires that you unlearn all these key-bindings and start thinking on the level of tokens again. It's understandable that given the choice, people who have already graduated from this stage would rather not repeat it.
- rs86 9y agoThat makes them look like glorified cybernetic factory workers
- WingH 9y agoOn the other hand, spending most of your time learning new syntax as opposed to actually solving creative problems makes one more like a glorified factory worker.
- rs86 9y agoLearning syntax is a non problem
- nostrademons 9y ago...that's generally a waste of time. Once people graduate from the "I'm going to learn ALL the things because it's fun and I got surplus brainpower", they usually discover that there are lots and lots of problems out there that require plenty of brainpower and people will actually pay you for solving. It's somewhat silly to allocate your mental effort to things that get you nothing but intellectual gratification when you can allocate it to things that get you intellectual gratification and monetary compensation that will let you do many things you otherwise can't.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoExactly. I can learn syntax if it's going to pay me back for the effort - if it's going to enable me to avoid bugs, or to solve problems I couldn't, or to be more productive, or to get or keep a job. Learning syntax that isn't going to pay me back? I don't have time for that.
- rs86 9y agoIt takes half an hour to learn syntax
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoIt takes a lot longer to learn syntax to the point where I don't have to think about it, so that I can spend my time thinking about the problem instead. Having to think about the syntax is like not being a touch typist. Sure, I can still press the right keys, but I have to think about doing so, which slows me down and takes my thinking off of what I'm trying to say.
- rs86 9y agoBut does coding take more time typing rather than thinking?
- nostrademons 9y agoYou've answered your own question about why programmers don't like new syntax. Because most (interesting) coding takes more time thinking than typing, syntax is only a cost, never a benefit. If your language has familiar syntax, then they don't have to pay that cost. If it makes them learn new syntax, it better provide other benefits like access to a new platform, a job that pays much better, or eliminating a large class of bugs. And if two languages both offer that same benefit (like Erlang vs. Elixir, Matlab vs. Python, even Python/Ruby vs. Node.js) programmers will gravitate toward the one that doesn't make them learn new syntax.
- muzani 9y agoYeah, for example I would be repulsed by a language that uses something like "x = 1" as a comparator instead of "x == 1". It's sort of like one of those keyboards where the semicolon key is elsewhere or the PgDn button is bigger.