3 ms·
Sorry, are you equating needless bureaucratic red tape in a non-profit's application for tax-exempt status to the seizure of a private citizen's phone and lapto
by ajross 9y ago
Sorry, are you equating needless bureaucratic red tape in a non-profit's application for tax-exempt status to the seizure of a private citizen's phone and laptop?
- kbenson 9y agoI think they are equating "this kind of harassment through scrutiny" as stated specifically in the top level comment.
- ajross 9y agoAnd that point falls down when the "scrutiny" isn't equivalent. The grandparent was clearly jumping in to make a partisan point (e.g. to say that there is no partisan lean to the demographics subject to this harrassment). And the evidence simply doesn't back that up. The government harrasses minorities and progressive groups with this kind of tactic far more than it does white middle class folks, and trying to pretend that playing games with a 501(c)(3) application is somehow "the same" is just laughable.
- kbenson 9y ago> The government harrasses minorities and progressive groups with this kind of tactic far more than it does white middle class folks How did progressive/conservative turn into minorities and "middle class white folks"? I'm in no way sure that progressive groups face more scrutiny than conservative groups, especially given some of the really odd and extreme conservative groups out there. I say this as someone that considers themselves a staunch progressive (if moderate liberal).
- mcherm 9y agoSorry, are you equating a private citizen having their phone out of their sight for 10 minutes with over a year of delays in permitting an organization to accept tax-exempt donations from thousands of citizens? Frankly, BOTH are unreasonable and the government should not be engaging in EITHER ONE. I think there is little to be gained by debating which is "worse" -- could we instead agree to cease doing both?
- pm90 9y agoNo. There are degrees of "worseness": we have a priority queue of issues that must be addressed given spare time and resources. In that context: and individual's right to privacy and to be left alone is much much more important than any organization getting tax exempt status.
- gamblor956 9y agoAn organization is allowed to collect donations when it files for tax-exempt status. It's donors are simply not allowed to take deductions for those donations until the exemption is approved. Once approved, the exemption is retroactive to the date of the application. SO, no, the two situations are nothing similar in nature or scope.
- snowwrestler 9y ago"Tax-exempt" status is completely invented by the government, and carries no natural or Constitutional rights. Being secure in your personal effects is a natural right and protected by the 4th Amendment.