5 ms·
A devil's advocate argument, for people to have something explicit to rebut here: One of the guises state police operate under in America is the "highway patro
by derefr 9y ago
A devil's advocate argument, for people to have something explicit to rebut here:
One of the guises state police operate under in America is the "highway patrol"—a force that searches for terrorists and drug trafficking and the like.
And presumably, air travel is a privilege, not a right, just like driving a car is. (Or is it? Taking public transit is a right that can't be denied to someone unless they explicitly break a rule of the system. But airports are private companies...)
So, given that, is there a legal reason that there is no "airway patrol"?
I'm not suggesting they have the powers of random search & seizure that the TSA seems to have, mind you. But should there be state police that are stationed at airports, who search people when they have probable cause?
- anthonybsd 9y agoThat seems reaching to me. After all, highway patrol cannot simply start going through your belongings without probable cause which has a potential to be tested in court. Same rights are clearly not afforded to the air travelers in TSA interactions which seem to exist in a legal limbo right now.
- solotronics 9y agoactually they can and do every day! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_forfeiture_in_the_United_States#Traffic_stops https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_forfeiture_in_the_United... "In May 2010 a couple was driving from New York to Florida and they were stopped by police because of a cracked windshield. During questioning, the officer decided that $32,000 cash in the van was "probably involved in criminal or drug-related activity", seized it, shared it with federal authorities under equitable sharing. The victim hired a lawyer to get back the seized money who urged settling for half of the seized amount, and after the lawyer's fees, the victim got back only $7,000."
- alehul 9y agoAs a followup to this (and response to preceding comment), a quick Google search shows that all airports aside from one in the US are owned by the government, which I believe must meet certain standards that we don't require of private entities in terms of rights of access.
- dawnerd 9y agothat quick google search brings up a site that cites no sources for that claim... Digging around found a source but I highly doubt its the one that site used. https://www.faa.gov/airports/airport_compliance/privatization/ https://www.faa.gov/airports/airport_compliance/privatizatio...
- jMyles 9y ago> Presumably, air travel is a privilege, not a right, just like driving a car is. Freedom of movement is a privilege, not a right? What can you possibly be talking about? Did I miss a memo? The United States (and other common law societies) have a long history of enshrining freedom of movement as a fundamental right. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_movement_under_United_States_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_movement_under_Unit... Also, be reminded that the USA voted in favor of the UDHR, which reads in part: * a citizen of a state in which that citizen is present has the liberty to travel, reside in, and/or work in any part of the state where one pleases within the limits of respect for the liberty and rights of others and * and that a citizen also has the right to leave any country, including his or her own, and to return to his or her country at any time.
- brokensegue 9y agofreedom of movement \neq freedom to fly though
- my123 9y agoIn a modern society, disallowing to fly doesn't give full movement rights for a person. You are much less likely to travel to Europe if you have to use a transaltlantic boat for example. :p
- brokensegue 9y agoyes but you could say that of cars too (and courts have ruled mandatory DUI tests legal)
- acct1771 9y agoJust because courts have ruled something legal doesn't make it Constitutional. See: 100 mile border zones that are "exempt" from the 4th Amendment. Not to mention, just because something is legal doesn't make it right.
- ctrl-j 9y ago> It occurs to me that America has, in every state, a state-run "highway patrol" that searches for terrorists and drug trafficking and the like. The state-run highway patrol is still subject to the 4th amendment (search and seizure.) If you get pulled over by a LEO - they need consent, probable cause, or a warrant in order to rifle through your belongings.
- cryoshon 9y ago> they need consent, probable cause, or a warrant in order to rifle through your belongings. which they can invent with no problem if they feel like it. nobody who declines to a search gets away with it; they just call a drug dog to alert and then they can search anyway.
- pdkl95 9y agoNot consenting to a search isn't really about preventing the search. The police are, by definition, they application of force; if they want to search you, they will. However, not consenting forces them to make up some sort of justification for their actions and gives your lawyer a much better chance of getting the fruits of the search thrown out.
- maxerickson 9y agoHow come that thing that is a thing isn't a thing? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Air_Marshal_Service https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Air_Marshal_Service 4,000 law enforcement officers. But that is separate from what powers we as a society should allow them.
- derefr 9y agoThe Air Marshals are literal peace officers—there to stop crime that happens in the air. Completely separate from the idea of a highway patrol, which is there—in essence—to be a permanent dragnet for BOLOs, and to (probabilistically) be witness to statutory crimes/regulatory violations (e.g. dumping of industrial waste) where no individual victim is going to report them.
- robotresearcher 9y agoSo the Highway Patrol is there to stop crime that happens on highways, and that's totally different?
- testvox 9y agoMy city Boston will tresspass you from the subway and bus system if you refuse to submit to a search of your bags at the checkpoints they set up at certain stations. So I don't think you are correct about public transportation.