8 ms·
Potent malware that hid for six years spread through routers
- kevindqc 9y ago>despite infecting at least 100 computers worldwide. Really? Then why is it so surprising lol
- vuln 9y agoArs needs to generate ad revenue.
- an4rchy 9y agoNot being sarcastic but sometimes it's about quality, not quantity. Usually something this sophisticated is used to target specific individuals/organizations as they aren't generic botnet/bitcoin mining operations. They might be after specific info and after they get it, they might even wipe their tracks as it's better to have a tool that nobody knows to look for than one that can get on as many computers as possible.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoYeah, that bugs me a bit about this story. The (known) targets seem unimpressive for an attack tool this sophisticated. (Unless the targeted individuals were not just "individuals", but individuals who were prominent in certain organizations...)
- sbarre 9y ago> Unless the targeted individuals were not just "individuals", but individuals who were prominent in certain organizations... I have to assume that's absolutely the case here. I didn't read this as "100 random individuals" being infected.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoI didn't either. I read it as "activists", and on re-reading, I can't see where I got that. The actual targets could be a lot more important than that...
- sbarre 9y agoYeah this kind of APT work seems like it would be targeted at high-value individuals, for either political or economic espionage.. So leaders of industry or government, etc..
- vtange 9y agoIf no known target thus far is high-profile, it could very well be that the current targets are guinea-pig-targets that test the malware for future applications.
- petervm 9y agoReminded me of this book I very much enjoyed about Stuxnet - "Countdown to Zero Day: Stuxnet and the Launch of the World's First Digital Weapon". Stuxnet was a targeted attack directed at Iran's nuclear program. Quality, not quantity indeed. Super interesting to learn about these things!
- ghrifter 9y agoWasnt this attack triggered by scattering payloaded USBs around the facility, and someone plugged it in? lol
- wand3r 9y agoStuxnet was highly targeted malware and certainly extremely sogisticated. That said, it infected probably >200,000 computer systems. To the parents point, it makes it easy to get a sample due to the volume of breaches. 100 targets with a highly covert mission objective is a different type of threat model compared to stux
- pixl97 9y agoAt the same time many MikroTik models are for ISP/micro-ISP setups, that have hundreds of people behind a router. An administrator machine being compromised could potentially expose many other network devices and allow tens of thousands of people to be compromised. Of all infections, this is the type an administrator should be most worried about. Its rare, but exceptionally damaging. Most A/V tools aren't going to catch it, so unless you are monitoring all IP activity from your computer and doing offline filesystem checks, a virus like this could compromise your systems for years.
- sp332 9y agoThere's a big difference between an indiscriminate worm and a targeted attack. Those 100 computers are high-value targets and would have been carefully guarded. Hiding in an environment like that is pretty impressive.
- ryanlol 9y agoCome on, we're not talking about countries with any impressive capabilities here. https://s3-eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/khub-media/wp-content/uploads/sites/43/2018/03/09110235/180309-slingshot-faq-3.png https://s3-eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/khub-media/wp-content/upl... There's nothing impressive about hiding on these governments networks for years.
- John_KZ 9y agoAt this point is there a way for small organizations and individuals to protect themselves from data theft? IP and trade secrets are hard to develop in a closed network without internet access at all points.
- bsamuels 9y agoyou can never 100% eliminate the risk of data theft. all you can do is implement controls that manage that risk based on how valuable the data is. certain controls like mandatory 2FA give a very good bang-for-buck, highly recommend it for an organization of any size
- jacquesm 9y agoHow do you plan on keeping the employees from being able to access the data? Even the NSA has a slight problem on this front.
- indigochill 9y agoI believe L. Bob Rife had some thoughts on that.
- lifeisstillgood 9y agoAt some point are we going to think signing each IP packet is a good idea? I struggle to see how we can ever clean the internet without something on the order of "I expect packets from this list of servers certificate" (ok I know some malware would alter that list but that's a much smaller target area to defend) I am just wondering if this level of unstoppable infection is just going to be it, or are we at the pre-cellular structure of life point in the internet?
- bhouston 9y agoDoes QUIC do this in a way?
- acqq 9y ago> without something on the order of "I expect packets from this list of servers certificate" Even now as it is it's worse than it should be: I can't control which pairs of (address,certificate) will be allowed to be accepted for specific sites. Instead, every browser vendor allows any "man in the middle" with the access to any CA (and CA's are known to be very bad(1)) to insert itself between my own server and my own client. 1) Read and weep: https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2018/03/23000-https-certificates-axed-after-ceo-e-mails-private-keys/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2018/03/23000...
- __jal 9y agoIf you want secure browser access to some resource (for values of 'secure' where it matters more than your bank account but less than situations in which you wouldn't trust _any_ browser), you really need to remove certs from any commercial CA and install only the CA you need.
- acqq 9y agoI know that it is possible to somehow achieve that, the thing is, it should be possible by default, so that I can simply say to e.g. my not-too-technical friend "this is my server, this is my cert, click there in your browser to compare the cert for my site before you connect and the browser will provably also not trust anybody else but your check." This should be a basically available scenario for the secure connection, just like what we have in SSH. Don't believe "the users are too stupid" excuse. It's just an excuse: https://golem.ph.utexas.edu/category/2014/10/new_evidence_of_nsa_weakening.html https://golem.ph.utexas.edu/category/2014/10/new_evidence_of... We simply shouldn't have to have the "trust in every crooked CA" when we connect to the servers we directly know.
- Jerry2 9y agoHere's a much better link: https://securelist.com/apt-slingshot/84312/ https://securelist.com/apt-slingshot/84312/ and PDF: https://s3-eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/khub-media/wp-content/uploads/sites/43/2018/03/09133534/The-Slingshot-APT_report_ENG_final.pdf https://s3-eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/khub-media/wp-content/upl...
- dang 9y agoThanks, we changed to the first link from https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2018/03/potent-malware-that-hid-for-six-years-spread-through-routers/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2018/03/poten..., which cribs content from it.
- jack6e 9y agoInteresting that the story references this malware's similarities to Project Sauron, and that the two main modules here are named GollumApp and Cahnadr, which looks not entirely dissimilar from how one might play with the Russian version of "Gandalf" if one were to convert the Cyrillic letters into approximate English look-a-likes.
- bhouston 9y agoWould Kaspersky Labs report on Russian malware?
- jack6e 9y agoThe meta-game at this point is open to just about any type of psychological trick. We know/suspect Kaspersky helping FSB/GRU, but we also know that CIA/NSA store and use fingerprints from other nation states and can assume Russia does the same. So if something looks Russian but Kaspersky reports on it, does that mean it is NSA trying to false flag Russia? Or is it Kaspersky deflecting Russian suspicions and pointing to the US by bringing it to light...6 years later? The abilities and willingness of certain nation states to wage cyber warfare and make it appear like someone else are so great at this point, that only solid forensic evidence, and usually not even that, can be indicative.
- Dolores12 9y ago>So if something looks Russian but Kaspersky reports on it, does that mean it is NSA trying to false flag Russia? It could be Russian, it could be not. What is really important that only the Kaspersky reported it.
- __jal 9y agoThe way to understand this sort of thing is to try to think like someone in their shoes. First, you're innocent. What would you do over time to try to survive the accusations and suspicion? Next, you're implicated in past bad acts. Maybe you were forced to stick malicious code in a past version, or maybe you had a rogue employee. What would you do to try to move on? Finally, you're an active part of the state intelligence apparatus. What would you do to try to appear like one of the other hypotheticals? There are other possibilities; people get themselves in all sorts of weird situations, but most of them are some shade of the above.
- an4rchy 9y agoIt has been very interesting to see a lot of hardware/firmware based vulnerabilities coming out recently, although they have been around for a while. Different vectors have different advantages but I wonder if there will be a push towards more hardware based anti-malware/vulnerability detection devices.
- thomastjeffery 9y agoThis is one of the reasons it's frustrating to have so many routers with proprietary firmware that can't be replaced. These routers essentially never get updated.
- Arnt 9y agoMikrotik's good about this, though. I have several Mikrotiks at home (difficult WLAN due to walls etc), purchased by a company that later upgraded to 802.11n-capable APs. Some of what I have is >10 years old. Mikrotik still makes new OS images for them, and they answer support mail without asking me for a customer number, registration or anything.
- wmf 9y agoEven if the firmware can be replaced, 99% of the time it won't be. And while it's nice that volunteer hackers are producing third-party firmware, we can't rely on that as the solution for Internet security.
- thomastjeffery 9y ago> we can't rely on that as the solution for Internet security. We could if updating router firmware were an easy and prolific practice. The reason that it isn't is that it can't be done on most routers, especially the cheaper or ISP-provided ones that most people use. What we really can't rely on is "security by obscurity". Let's drop the notion that software is more secure simply because you don't release the source.
- wmf 9y agoPeople maintaining their own cars used to be a prolific practice, but I think we're better off now with cars that require dramatically less maintenance. Unfortunately the IOT market is in a bad situation because products are advertised as not requiring any maintenance but they aren't reliable enough to live up to that.
- 9y ago
- iforgotpassword 9y ago> When the target user runs Winbox Loader software (a utility used for Mikrotik router configuration), this connects to the router and downloads some DLLs (dynamic link libraries) from the router’s file system. Wait, am I getting this right? The router isn't simply configured via web, telnet, ssh, or a simple proprietary tool that talks its own protocol with the router, but actually a proprietary tool that downloads and executes code from the router that you're trying to configure? If so, why on earth would you design anything like this? What were they thinking? I mean, apparently those DLLs aren't even signed or anything.
- X-Cubed 9y agoYou can use any of those methods to configure a Mikrotik router, you don't have to use Winbox. Winbox has a couple of nice features over the web interface: - the ability to connect over raw ethernet (rather than IP) which is useful if you've misconfigured the firewall or routing tables - the ability to broadcast packets to discover new, unconfigured Mikrotik devices Winbox has previously downloaded components from the router to enable the UI to update the available options based on the firmware on the device. These components are part of the firmware update provided by Mikrotik, which is itself signed and verified before the firmware update is applied. But yes, they were missing a follow up check between Winbox and the router itself, to ensure the router itself was not tampered with.
- trisimix 9y ago100?