3 ms·
I also don't understand how this is even an issue. The companies can make him go away simply by complying with the GPL, no? While what McHardy is doing may no
by bsder 9y ago
I also don't understand how this is even an issue.
The companies can make him go away simply by complying with the GPL, no?
While what McHardy is doing may not be the most diplomatic stunt, it's kind of hard for me to sympathize when the companies wouldn't have to pay anything if they would just comply with the GPL license.
If you don't want to comply with the GPL, use BSD or something.
Am I missing something or could these companies sidestep all the legal BS with a minimal amount of effort.
- nordsieck 9y ago> The companies can make him go away simply by complying with the GPL, no? That's not clear. If you copy someone's work and don't have a license to use it then you've violated the copyright holder's rights. Just because you come into compliance with a license to copy the work doesn't absolve the violating party of the original liability. Additionally, there is some disagreement specifically around the GPLv2 and license re-instatement; specifically, it's not clear that license re-instatement is possible in the face of unwilling copyright holders.
- tinus_hn 9y agoIf that were true you could resolve a file sharing lawsuit by stopping your torrent client. It doesn’t work like that.
- bsder 9y agoIn the case of a torrent, the media companies generally are citing theft (rightly or wrongly) and damages. You can't just resolve theft legally by returning the thing stolen. I don't see anybody citing theft. And, quite often, license compliance IS legally resolved by coming into compliance. However, I still find it hard to sympathize. Don't want this problem--comply with the GPL or don't use GPL software. The GPL is functioning as written and intended. There is a reason so many companies consider GPL-licensed software to be radioactive.
- tinus_hn 9y ago> I don't see anybody citing theft That's because it is a concept that doesn't exist. Creating a copy in violation of copyright is not theft. Copyright is the right to limit others ability to create copies. That limitation doesn't involve things that can be stolen.
- rst 9y agoPer text of the article, McHardy was asking for restitution involving not just future compliance, but also direct cash payments to him, of more than a million euros per violation, which had apparently already resulted in settlements which got him "at least a few million euros".