8 ms·
Anyone have insight into different tunnel-building technologies? In particular, when is a boring machine a more appropriate solution than drilling-and-blasting?
by Sharlin 9y ago
Anyone have insight into different tunnel-building technologies? In particular, when is a boring machine a more appropriate solution than drilling-and-blasting?
- masklinn 9y agoTBMs are way more expensive up-front but allow little to no disturbance of the surroundings, and can produce smooth walls & line it as they go. TBMs can also bore in soil or sand. Aside from disturbance and raw feasibility (not sure you can D&B underseas) the main split point is going to be the length of the tunnel. TBMs mean large up-front fixed cost but have a lower price per distance and higher time efficiency, so D&B is more suitable for shorter tunnels (how short will also depend on the diameter you need). That aside, TBMs are awesome, I got to visit one as a kid (the operator gave tours of the TBM during the few weeks of work prep' before digging actually started in earnest) and it was a great experience, they're impressive bits of machinery & technology.
- dmurray 9y agoWhy is the upfront cost bigger for TBMs? If the TBM can be used on any length of tunnel, can't you resell it afterwards, or rent it instead of buying?
- CompelTechnic 9y ago(just a guess) even if you are only using it for a small fraction of its lifetime, you are amortizing the cost of a large piece of capital equipment, so the upfront cost must take this into account. Blasting has a smaller investment in capital equipment (even if amortized similarly) There is also the setup- carting in the pieces of the TBM and getting them into place, etc.
- masklinn 9y ago> Why is the upfront cost bigger for TBMs? Because a TBM itself is a large capital investment. A small TBM (~7m diameter) is ~10m€, a large TBM probably reach 100m€. This is money you have to pay upfront before the TBM even reaches the dig. The capital investment of D&B is a (few) jumbos which are cheaper (even large and expensive jumbos are unlikely to breach 2m€ brand new), more flexible (they're also used in mining operations) and less dependent of the manufacturer — thus easier to rent or buy used. > can't you resell it afterwards, or rent it instead of buying? The "back end" (gantries) can be sold back to the builder and refurbished, the "front end" (shield and cutter head) is thrown away (some are used as monuments) or recycled: https://www.herrenknecht.com/en/services/global-services/tbm-refurbishment.html https://www.herrenknecht.com/en/services/global-services/tbm... That's still expensive as hell, and you've still sunk the money in until the builder has examined and bought back the gantries after the project has ended.
- Someone 9y agoTBMs are designed at a specific diameter, for the kind of soil to bore through, wear down quickly, and aren’t easily moved. It often isn’t worth it to take apart a TBM and reconstruct it elsewhere, even if you could find a customer wanting a tunnel of the same width through similar soil. For long tunnels, it isn’t uncommon to have two TBMs that meet in the middle and are abandoned there (they bore a side tunnel long enough to contain the TBM, and the side tunnel is closed behind them) For example, see https://untappedcities.com/2017/02/09/the-200-ton-tunnel-boring-machine-buried-below-park-avenue-used-for-east-side-access/ https://untappedcities.com/2017/02/09/the-200-ton-tunnel-bor...: ”Burial of such a large machine was unprecedented in New York City, but is common practice abroad, reported the New York Times in 2011. The Spanish contracting company working on the project deemed it would be more cost effective to leave Seli in place. It was estimated that removal would cost millions and cause delays in existing construction projects. Dr. Michael Horodniceanu, the president of MTA Capital Construction, estimated at the time it would cost $9 million to remove Seli, which had cost somewhere between $6 to $8 million new.”
- donarb 9y agoIn Seattle's underground tunnel, the TBM was delivered from Japan along the waterfront close to its starting point. It was assembled, then lowered into the pit. At the tunnel exit is a highly congested maze of streets. In order to remove the TBM, the 2000 ton cutter head needed to be cut into pieces that would not weigh more than the city's 20 ton weight limit for streets. With Seattle's design/build contract, the construction company owned the TBM. To them it's just a tool whose cost is part of the construction package.
- jpatokal 9y agoIt's complicated and I'm not an expert, but I understand the main risk with TBMs is running into a type of rock it can't handle and suddenly having a multi-million dollar paperweight wedged in a very awkward location. They're also not well suited to really hard rock, which requires frequent cutter replacements. In this case, the tunnel is very long and deep, magnifying the unknown territory risk. Also, the bedrock in most of Scandinavia (and, I presume, Stockholm) is both very shallow and mostly granite, which is extremely hard and thus not a good fit for a TBM. Source: My childhood in Helsinki was punctuated by the periodic sound of blasting rock as they cut out what was supposed to be the new central station. Overall, Helsinki is basically granite Swiss cheese due to parking garages, pedestrian tunnels, basements, bomb shelters, military tunnels, the metro etc and AFAIK all of it has been drilled and blasted, not TBM'd.
- Sharlin 9y agoYep, I'm Finnish myself and figured it has something to do with rock hardness. All the long tunnels in Finland I know of appear to be drilled and blasted, including very recently built ones like the Tampere Rantatunneli.
- varjag 9y agoMost tunnels in Norway are bored through, and I doubt we have any softer rock here.
- digi_owl 9y ago
- rmm 9y agoMining guy here. It 95% cost. TBM is great if you have money and are going through residential type areas, can get through most rock, not as nimble though. Drill and blast are the most common by far, especially in mining industry where they are lots of twists and turns, and no-one cares about noise etc.
- cm2187 9y agoBut wasn’t the channel tunnel bored? Surelery they weren’t worried about noise.
- WhompingWindows 9y agoThe article in question answers both your concerns. 1) They used detonations 2) They installed noise-insulating windows on local buildings.
- pjc50 9y agoChannel tunnel was extremely soft and in places wet ground, mostly chalk. Comparatively quick to bore through. Blasting would have either wrecked the ground structure in too large an area or gone "splat" instead of "bang".
- kerryfalk 9y agoAlso, Sandvik, Copco or Volvo don't produce a TBM.
- rmm 9y agoThis x 10.
- mrmanner 9y agoOn the topic of Swedish tunnels there's the one through Hallandsås, where three (?) different construction companies tried. Several tunnel boring machines got stuck in the soft rock, cows died from water poisoning, and the whole thing was delayed more than 100% of the estimated project time. Fascinating story. > Additionally, the original drill, which was said to drill 100 meters per week, broke down after drilling only 18 m (59 ft). The rock was too soft, so the machine could not use it to pull itself forward. The contractor tried to drill traditionally, but had to spend a lot of effort on sealing the water leaks. The contractor went bankrupt and a new contractor, Skanska, was contracted. The new contractor had similar trouble but a better contract that gave compensation for troublesome rock conditions. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hallands%C3%A5s_Tunnel https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hallands%C3%A5s_Tunnel
- jaclaz 9y ago(mostly ex-) construction technician here. There is also a "form factor". TBM's dig "round" holes. The cross section of those Stockholm tunnels (I know, I actually worked on a few tenders for them) is very wide and flat. Generically speaking for a TBM to be competitive you need to have a "minimal" length of tunnel, a TBM has huge - really huge - mounting/assembling (and later disassembling) costs and quite a lot of space at both ends of the tunnel. Specifically, both (they are two tenders, E302 and E308) tunnels have not a "direct access", there are two "service tunnels" (of a much smaller cross section, rather "steep" and non-linear) that allow access to the main tunnels from the outside, and the outside area available is anyway small, so a TBM could not have been used anyway, even if the cross section wasn't so "flat". Back to generically speaking, the rules of thumb (approximate, only to give you an idea) for choosing NOT a TBM are: 1) anything shorter than 5-7 Km 2) anything larger than diameter 12 m or not round or simil-round 3) anything in terrains that are too "hard" or too "soft" [1] To give you a rough approximation, a (single bore) tunnel made with traditional excavation can have a production of 100-120 m/month, a TBM can usually dig around 400 m/month, so it is much faster. There are also "mixed mode" approaches, where you (quickly) bore a smaller "pilot hole" in the center of the tunnel by means of a small TBM, usually 3.8 or 4 meters in diameter, so you have a 1:1 representations of the terrains and can (from the small bore) perform any kind of consolidation/impermeabilization etc., then you enlarge the hole by traditional blast and drill. The much reduced amount of explosives needed for enlarging the hole and a great semplification in the ventilation plant , besides the possibility to always work on "known" terrain make this a very good approach in my experience, and the blast and drill enlargement of the pilot hole is much faster than "full face" excavation, the same rough estimate is around 150-180 m/month. [1] or more generally where large variations in the nature of terrain is expected, a TBM for "soft" is different from one for "hard" and viceversa
- Sharlin 9y agoThanks, much appreciated!