2 ms·
TLS doesn't prevent you from intercepting your end of the connection on a device you control. If you don't control your own device then the problem is with your
by modeless 9y ago
TLS doesn't prevent you from intercepting your end of the connection on a device you control. If you don't control your own device then the problem is with your device, not TLS. We shouldn't weaken TLS just because you chose to hand control of your device to someone else.
- mhils 9y agoWell I agree. My main concern is that we're loosing that control in the name of security, in particular on mobile devices. Take Android as an example, which doesn't respect user-added CAs anymore for application traffic [1]. It's even worse with cert-pinned iOS apps where you cannot root easily, although Apple is at least trying to fix this with App Transport Security (which does respect user-added CAs). I definitely do not want to see a weaker TLS - 1.3 is great. At the same time, I do not want to have 'security improvements' that make it impossible for average developers to see their own device's traffic. That will ultimately enable insecure APIs and gross privacy violations behind TLS. [1] https://github.com/mitmproxy/mitmproxy/issues/2054 https://github.com/mitmproxy/mitmproxy/issues/2054
- modeless 9y ago> My main concern is that we're loosing [sic] that control in the name of security If you've lost that control you have nobody to blame but yourself. There are devices and operating systems on the market that do not require you to give up that control. If you choose to buy a device you can't root and an OS you can't modify, that's all on you.