4 ms·
>Why a vote in Kansas needs to be tallied differently from a vote in New York in the 2020 elections is beyond me. population of Kansas (state): 2.9 millio
by krapp 9y ago
>Why a vote in Kansas needs to be tallied differently from a vote in New York in the 2020 elections is beyond me.
population of Kansas (state): 2.9 million
population of New York (city): 8.5 million
Without some sort of balancing mechanism, you wind up with a single populous city's votes mattering more than the votes from every city in a less populous state.
- shouldgowork 9y agoWithout some sort of rebalancing mechanism, you wind up with a singe empty state's votes mattering more than every voter in a city.
- rukittenme 9y agoThe mechanism you're talking about is the federal government.
- mikeash 9y agoWhat is wrong with that, exactly? If the city is substantially larger than the state, it seems reasonable to me that its votes would matter more.
- krapp 9y agoI can see an argument either way. More populated areas to legitimately represent commercial and cultural centers, but also, the needs of the entire system have to be considered.
- mikeash 9y agoWhat is it about rural voters that make them more important to the entire system?
- rukittenme 9y agoResources.
- barsonme 9y agoThis is something our founders debated. It's never good to let the whims of the majority trample on the minority. It's why we have both the house of representatives (based on population) and the senate (flat number per state). If little states have no say in our government, what point is there for them to remain? It's a pity some folks devalue others simply because they don't wish to live in NYC or LA.
- s2g 9y ago> It's never good to let the whims of the majority trample on the minority You are arguing for the minority to trample on the majority.
- barsonme 9y agoThat’s not what I’m arguing. It needs to be competitive. The majority shouldn’t be able to have its way without the help of the minority.
- mikeash 9y agoWhy is the rural minority so special? We don’t give other minorities this sort of treatment. For example, the percentage of rural Americans is similar to the percentage of black Americans. Yet somehow nobody ever argues that black Americans need power disproportionate to their numbers to avoid being trampled.
- bzbarsky 9y ago> Why is the rural minority so special? It's not about rural vs urban. It's about the assumption that the US is a union of separate _states_ with separate legal structures, cultures, etc, etc. So it's not the "rural minority" that's special; it's states that are special. Now you may disagree with the premises there, of course. But if one accepts the premises, then one needs a way to prevent "big" states from just imposing their will on "small" ones. (There are in fact people who argue that black Americans need disproportionate power, and some voting districts are set up to effectively produce that, but that has nothing to do with the setup of the US constitution per se.)
- s2g 9y agoYes, which is how it should be. States have senators to prevent tyranny of the majority. NYC should be worth more house seats than all of Kansas.