3 ms·
There's a lot of constitutional theory that basically falls under the category of "it's never mattered, so we've got no idea how to interpret what-if scenarios.
by jcranmer 9y ago
There's a lot of constitutional theory that basically falls under the category of "it's never mattered, so we've got no idea how to interpret what-if scenarios." The Corwin Amendment falls under that in several different ways:
* Does an amendment to the Constitution have the power to prevent amendments to the Constitution? If so, do later amendments have the ability to overturn this limitation of power?
* Would the amendment actually have any effect, since the 13th amendment was enacted before the Corwin Amendment? That is, is the amendment implicitly retroactive?
* Is it possible for states to rescind their ratification? For that matter, can Congress rescind its ratification?
* For bonus points, try to figure out what the rules are for the Article V convention to amend the Constitution, in particular in deciding whether or not we are supposed to be having one right now.
- bdhe 9y agoAlso, beyond a certain point, there isn't anything sacred about the Constitution or its Amendment process in so far as a majority of the collective populace agrees to it and there are powerful bodies enforcing it. Ultimately, as we have seen countless times including now, in China, and 2 years back in Turkey, might is right and any constitution can be amended arbitrarily under the right circumstances by the right people with the right power and control over armies.
- Feniks 9y agoWell most countries have living constitutions. I think its only natural to update the constitution every once in a while, a document from 1848 predates gay rights for instance.
- uiri 9y agoI am neither American nor a lawyer, but I have looked at the US Constitution a bit so I'll take a stab at these. Of course, an actual scholar of the US constitution would have more correct answers: 1. Article Five of the US Constitution specifies the manner in which the constitution can be amended. It expressly prohibits any amendment that would deprives a state of its equal suffrage in the Senate. Therefore, the Constitution itself prevents certain amendments to the Constitution. It stands to reason that, should you wish to change the Senate away from an equal number of Senators per state, you would need two amendments. One to allow such an amendment and then a second which would itself be that amendment. That the Constitution provides a process for amendment is proof that its framers intended for it to be amended. That they specifically laid out certain things which could not be amended indicate that they intended for it to be possible to amend anything and everything else. That the amendment procedure was itself not included in the list of unamendable things includes it in the list of amendable things. Therefore the list of unamendable things is in the scope of amendments as something which may be amended. Of course, later amendments may repeal earlier amendments. 2. If a state ratified two conflicting amendments - A and B - I would say that the latter of the two ratifications would take precedence. Now, if Congress passed A first and then B, and B was ratified by enough states first and then A was ratified by enough states, I would say that you would have a nice little Constitutional crisis on your hands. I think the rational solution would be to follow the Convention process for amendments as laid out in Article 5. That way the states can sort it out definitively, federal Congress be damned. 3. No. 4. Since I mention it earlier as a way to solve the conflicts between the 13th and Corwin amendments, the plain reading of the text suggests that each state legislature applies to hold a constitutional convention. The natural body to collect and manage these applications is Congress itself. When Congress has 2/3 of the States applying for such a convention they will determine the process for the convention.
- vageli 9y ago> That the Constitution provides a process for amendment is proof that its framers intended for it to be amended. That they specifically laid out certain things which could not be amended indicate that they intended for it to be possible to amend anything and everything else. That the amendment procedure was itself not included in the list of unamendable things includes it in the list of amendable things. Therefore the list of unamendable things is in the scope of amendments as something which may be amended This makes no sense to me but is pretty common thinking. It's crazy that we expect the original authors of the Constitution to have considered every possibility exhaustively. To put the idea in a different context, if I fail to blacklist a particular string in my webapp, does that mean I intended to let it through? Or could it be possible that, through negligence, a lack of research, or some other reason, that the string was omitted in error?
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoIf you didn't blacklist a particular string in your webapp, you did let it through, whether you intended to or not. What's your alternative? Do you want some container that you're running in deciding what your intent was, and what strings you should have blacklisted? So, back to the real issue: The Constitution specifies the process that we have. "They didn't think of this" != "we don't have to follow what it says".