2 ms·
If coincidences are just coincidences why do they feel so contrived?
by paulcole 9y ago
If coincidences are just coincidences why do they feel so contrived?
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoBecause in the same way we're primed to understand certain shape patterns as faces, we're primed to parse our world as a story. A lot of "reason" is really just narrative logic. It's much more weakly predictive and less rational than scientific logic, but it's far more persuasive.
- TipVFL 9y agoA good rule of thumb in storytelling is that coincidences that help your protagonists will feel like the writer just cheated to get out of a corner they wrote themselves into, whereas coincidences that hurt your protagonist are more easily accepted. If you feel you really need this lucky coincidence to save your character, you can fix that by going back earlier in the story and earning it. Your hero getting shot, and the bullet being stopped by a lighter in his pocket we've never seen before, will feel like a cheat. But if he helped a homeless guy earlier, and the homeless guy insists he take his lucky Zippo, and then the lighter saves his life, most people won't complain. Just a little justification goes a long way, and helps make your world and story feel real and complex.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoExactly. You can have pretty much anything happen, if you put in the antecedents so that it is reasonable for it to happen.