5 ms·
You can do much the same thing in the US. Most people (55%) in the US earn more than similarly situated people in Sweden [1]. (If you focus only on Swedish Ame
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
You can do much the same thing in the US.
Most people (55%) in the US earn more than similarly situated people in Sweden [1]. (If you focus only on Swedish Americans, 55% goes up to 85%.) If you want to take paternity leave in the US, you can lower your spending/consumption to that of a comparable Swede and put the money you save in the bank. You can then withdraw it during your paternity leave.
The fact that most Americans choose not to do this suggests that paternity leave is not as blissful as the author suggests. The fact that the Swedish govt had to offer an "equality bonus" and use it or lose it incentives to get men to use more than 6% of the per-couple leave suggests that Swedes don't find it as blissful as the alternatives either.
[1] Income distributions overall: http://super-economy.blogspot.com/2010/03/income-distribution-in-us-and-sweden.html http://super-economy.blogspot.com/2010/03/income-distributio...
Swedes vs Swedish Americans: http://super-economy.blogspot.com/2010/03/super-economy-in-one-picture.html http://super-economy.blogspot.com/2010/03/super-economy-in-o...
[edit: replaced the word "standard of living" with "consumption". "Standard of living" is a poorly defined concept and arguing over definitions is pointless.]
- einarvollset 16y agoYou have clearly not been to Sweden.
- pragmatic 16y agoWould you care to elaborate?
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- einarvollset 16y agoSure; US effective tax levels brings relative tax rates up much higher than you would expect. That coupled with things like free university education, cheap childcare, state pensions, etc means that I'm highly dubious that all the avg American would have to do is to not get paid for 18 months and they'd be in the same boat. Face it; 18 months leave is a huge perk (snarky comments about going crazy not withstanding). Furthermore, why the he'll should only the rich get to spend time with their kids?
- yummyfajitas 16y agoThe costs of the assorted govt benefits is included in the figures I cited. The figures take Swedish income proportions, but scales them upward proportionally to GDP.
- lotusleaf1987 16y agoLook at this though: http://articles.moneycentral.msn.com/Taxes/Advice/YourRealTaxRate40.aspx http://articles.moneycentral.msn.com/Taxes/Advice/YourRealTa...
- norswap 16y agoI thinks he refers to the fact that the above post by yummyfajitas says that Americans have a higher standard of living than Swedes. While they may earn more, they also benefit from much much higher social security (for instance family allowances). Also I don't think the gap between Americans and Swedes is such that just by saving a couple of years you can match the paid leave. You must also consider various expanses that Americans have but not Swedes : a personal pension plan (or at least, a more consequent one), tuition fees for the older child, or saving for that of the child just born. Finally the claim that people don't stop working to take care of their children is a proof it isn't enjoyable is laudable because it doesn't factor in psychological and sociological parameters. tl;dr Swedes don't have a lower standard of living than Americans. Maybe the reverse is even true.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- pragmatic 16y agoSpeaking as a father, sitting home with my child for a year and half would probably have driven the whole family crazy.
- Tyrannosaurs 16y agoFor me the ideal would be part time. I'd love to spend more time with my daughter (15 months old) but I'm not cut out for 7 days a week childcare.
- parbo 16y agoIn Sweden, the employer can not deny a request for part time work (75%) if the child is 8 years or younger.
- m_eiman 16y agoYou've only compensated for the loss of income for a total of 480 days, though. That'll let one parent work 75% for about five years, while earning about 95% of their full time salary.
- dagw 16y agoFirst of all only you're only fully compensated 360 of those 480 days, for the other 120 days you only get the minimum level of compensation. Secondly it depends on what their full time salary is. There is a hard upper limit on how much you can get compensated, and most people with good jobs are quite a bit over that limit. So someone with a higher paying job might only get 40-50% of his salary.
- m_eiman 16y agoThe ceiling is about 58kUSD per year.
- gcheong 16y agoTo what extent does the government check up on how you are spending your paternity leave time?
- davidw 16y ago> The fact that most Americans choose not to do this suggests that paternity leave is not as blissful as the author suggests There are a whole slew of reasons why people might choose not to do it. Same thing with vacations, which is a simpler subject: Americans, who earn more, could, in theory, give away some of those earnings to have longer vacations. In practice, very, very few do. Quite possibly due to some herd effects. No one wants to be the only one gone for that long, just like no one wants to always be the first one out the door. In any case: "it's complicated", and my bet is that we'll see the same old rehashed discussions here.
- coreymull 16y agoIt's not quite as simple as glibly saying that Americans can just lower their standards of living and walk away from stable employment to take paternity leave. Also, people don't just make choices out of the ether - people's range of choices are influenced by the policy environment. It holds in Sweden too - Swedes didn't make the choice to stay at home until they were given the choice, at which point they did. At any rate, even if Americans are violently opposed to taking parental leave, surely a non-zero number of men would take it - what's the harm in guaranteeing that men have more chance to bond with their children?
- yummyfajitas 16y agoYou are confusing marginal cost and total cost. Swedish policy reduces the marginal cost of parental leave to the consumer - they are forced to pay for it whether they want it or not, so the marginal cost of leave is $0.0. This implies Swedes find paternity leave to be worth at least $0.01, and so paternity leave has a positive marginal cost/benefit ratio. That does not mean it has a positive cost/benefit ratio. I'm sure Americans also value paternity leave at something higher than $0.01. However, most Americans seem to feel that 18 months of paternity leave is not worth 18 months of salary. The harm in forcing Americans to pay for it (regardless of whether they want it) is that they find the money more valuable. Forcing people to trade something of higher value for something of lesser value is harmful. I'd similarly be harmed if you forced me to trade my Thinkpad for a netbook or my Nexus 1 for an iPhone.
- coreymull 16y agoI mean, fine, but this is the case with just about any form of social program. I'm not in danger of needing food stamps, so logic dictates I'd rather have the $20 a year or so I contribute to that program. I don't like bombs, but about 5-10% of my income goes to pay for them. You're forced to pay for all kinds of stuff. Might as well get some social value out of it (like more cohesive families)
- yummyfajitas 16y agoIn basically all cases I can think of, forcing people to buy private goods (rivalrous and excludible) is harmful to the people who would not otherwise choose to purchase those goods. Your example of bombs/military spending doesn't fall into that category, since defense is neither rivalrous nor excludible. My enjoyment of Iraqi deaths does not hinder your enjoyment of same, and the military has no way of preventing me from enjoying Iraqi deaths if I don't pay my military bill. Thus everyone has an incentive to freeload and a free market will not allocate enough resources to killing Iraqis.
- Tyrannosaurs 16y agoI think you're confusing income and standard of living. The Swedish have a very high standard of living, from everything I've seen when I've visited it's comparable to the USA. It's described by that famous pro-Swedish anti-American body the CIA as "enviable" in their world factbook and the UN Standard of living survey places them around 5th (the USA is around 10th - both vary year by year but not the order they come in). Even were your suggestion true, it's as much about the legal protection you have in Sweden to go back to your job. Try 18 months out of work in the USA and I'm guessing that you might find getting back into the work place (particularly in IT where your skills are now rusty and dated) harder than you might think.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- Tyrannosaurs 16y agoAll I'm saying is that the original post which talks about standard of living and then backs it up with income figures is incorrect but I don't mention spending at all (though the original poster does seem to imply their interchangeable I don't comment on that). As it goes I'd entirely agree with you that many people could lower their income and / or expenditure without impacting their standard of living and / or happiness.
- ptomato 16y agoThat's an incredibly mature edit. [User was dmm, unsure what original post was but he edited it to read "Reply to this if you're a nazi"]
- yummyfajitas 16y agoIt's true, when I said "standard of living", I simply meant "consumption". "Standard of living" is a fairly nebulous and poorly defined concept. I should have been more specific about what I meant. Thanks for pointing that out. I've edited my post to reflect this.
- geebee 16y agoThere's actually one major additional factor here: health insurance. I actually had a lot of money saved up with I had my first kid, enough liquid to pay the rent for four years. I could probably have gotten private health insurance. However, it's very expensive once you no longer get it through a large institution with bargaining power, and I know many people who were denied due to existing health problems. Plus, if your baby has health problems, you're in a very risky situation if you're an individual buyer. Your original point still stands - it's essentially the same equation, but I think that health insurance changes the values of some of the variables. The pediatrician, rather than the rent/mortgage, was what kept me pinned to a job I actually kind of hated.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI could probably have gotten private health insurance. However, it's very expensive once you no longer get it through a large institution with bargaining power,... It's only 2% more expensive for you than for your former employer (for 18 months). http://www.dol.gov/ebsa/faqs/faq_consumer_cobra.HTML http://www.dol.gov/ebsa/faqs/faq_consumer_cobra.HTML
- geebee 16y agonot bad... though that's the total cost, not the amount you pay, right? It's a big bill, almost the equivalent of rent. But if this is the case, then yeah, it's just money, so the equation doesn't change, just the parameters. I have a buddy who was denied health insurance repeatedly until he got hired, so there's definitely a subgroup that has no choice but to keep the corporate job. I suppose you could also just buy insurance for the baby rather than get a family plan if you're denied but the child is healthy, though I've never heard of this.
- sounddust 16y agoAs someone who has a lot of Swedish friends and has spent a lot of time there, I can't imagine that this could possibly be true. First of all, every Swedish person I know seems to already have a higher standard of living than the American with an equivalent job in almost all aspects. Add to this the fact that the entirety of Sweden itself is maintained to a higher standard; consistently pure/clean water, well-maintained roads, clean parks, well-maintained public services, etc. I wonder how well the textbook definition of "standard of living" corresponds with real life. I think that einarvollset's point about actually having to spend time in Sweden to understand the quality of life is valid here. Also, you're missing much of the point of the reasons that Swedish men choose not to initially take the leave. Your claim assumes that it's all economic, whereas the article cites that it is more likely a cultural aspect related to traditional thoughts about masculinity that discouraged them to take the leave. It's yet to be seen, but I'm pretty confident that if you gradually take away the bonus after 25 years, the numbers are likely to remain the same.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoYour claim assumes that it's all economic,... No, all my claim really assumes is that people have a better idea about what is good for them than I (or some enlightened bureaucrat) do. Suppose men do prefer working because they enjoy feeling masculine, or that women prefer maternity leave because they enjoy feeling feminine. I generally accept people's desires as they are, rather than treating them as defective when they prefer things different from me and penalizing them if they don't make choices that conform to my desires.
- sounddust 16y agoI generally accept people's desires as they are So does Sweden; they are drawing the line at a slightly different point than yourself. I'm assuming that you believe that society's needs trump the rights of individuals at some point, otherwise you wouldn't believe in society at all. Personally, I don't see a problem with encouraging fathers to spend more time with their children; it's likely those children will grow to be better adjusted as a result, and the overall impact on society (including economic factors such as productivity) will be worth it in the long run. To give a similar example: I think that it has been detrimental to the US that parents aren't required to immunize their children; it's obvious that if it continues it will be an overall detriment to the health of American children despite the parents' "desires." I think that framing the issue as "enlightened bureaucrats considering others defective" is sensationalist and incorrect; The bureaucracy reflects the society, and Sweden is known for their investment and research on gender issues with the aim of resolving societal problems; this policy wasn't some random bureaucratic afterthought.
- pkulak 16y agoEarning 55% more, with no health care, no pre-school child care, and without whatever other benefits are afforded the Swedes, is at best a wash.
- AlisdairO 16y agoYour first sentence requires an 'if you happen to be at least middle class' at the end. Your linked blog assumes that money spent on healthcare in Sweden and the US offer the same outcomes. This is plainly not the case - the swedish government spends dramatically less than individuals/companies do in the US to provide the same level of care. If, for example, the author subtracted healthcare benefits from US workers, and subtracted them from swedish workers as well, sweden would compare substantially better. One might find similar issues with respect to university spending.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoDo you have evidence that Sweden provides the same level of care? Note that comparing health outcomes is nowhere near convincing. Lots of factors (ethnicity, lifestyle, genetics) affect health outcomes far more than health care quality. The health care gap between Asian and African Americans is 13 years, for instance.
- AlisdairO 16y agoI will certainly admit to having no stats - although your blog post, a more informed source than myself, states that poor americans will experience significantly worse care than in sweden. My other experience is anecdotal - I've known a fair number of swedes, and they've all been satisfied with their healthcare, while people in the US have serious issues with being underinsured and having legitimate claims denied on technicalities. Finally, there's the simple fact that the system in the US obviously encourages high prices. In the insurance-based model, there's little disincentive to performing as much work, necessary or not, as possible.