26 ms·
Your real tax rate: 40%
- cperciva 16y agoCanada is quite similar: In 2006, from $14k up to $88k the combined Federal+BC income taxes, payroll taxes, and sales tax credits worked out to a flat rate of 26% plus or minus $250. (Above $88k the rate goes up, but mostly due to a cap on the amount which can be "hidden" in retirement funds.) Graduated tax rates plus low-income tax credits equals a flat tax.
- btilly 16y agoReally? Effective US tax rates are about a third higher than Canadian rates? I find that difficult to believe, but I'd be greatly amused if it was true.
- 3pt14159 16y agoWhen I was looking for work after University I was astonished to find that I would be pay much more taxes in Texas than I would in Ontario. I would still have had a better standard of living though because housing is so much cheaper there and the wages are about 15% higher, but still, it was sobering. One point the original poster forgot to include was that you do eventually have to pay taxes on your RRSP contributions, so it is just tax delayed, not really less taxes. One reason I don't contribute to my RRSP is that I think taxes are going to go well north of where they are today due to the baby boomer strain on social services. Better to take it out now than later.
- dminor 16y agoWell we do pay double per capita what Canada pays for healthcare, so it wouldn't surprise me at all.
- einarvollset 16y agoThat surely can't be for premiums? I remember paying $95/month for full coverage ($179 for a family?) with low (no?) deductible when I lived in BC. I wish, WISH, for that kind of coverage here in CA. I've got catastrophic coverage only for like $200/month.
- cperciva 16y agoWell, it depends in part on what you include. The 26% I mentioned is for income taxes, payroll taxes, and (income-based) sales tax credits; but Canadians also have to pay a federal sales tax of 5% and provincial sales taxes (typically around 7-8%) on most purchases. I believe the total tax burden ends up being fairly similar between the US and Canada -- while Canada spends far more (per capita) on social services and health care, the US spends a similarly larger amount on the military.
- patrickgzill 16y agoCanadians also pay much more for gasoline than Americans. Of course, not all of this is in taxes. To check this: find a "gas buddy" site for a place in Canada, then find one for the nearest US city/town close to it (to control for price disparity due to shipping). Multiply cost per liter by 3.6 to get equivalent US Gallon; then adjust it by current exchange rate. Example: lowest for Vancouver, BC: http://www.vancouvergasprices.com/ http://www.vancouvergasprices.com/ is currently 106.9 per liter ($1.069 CAD) , times 3.6 = $3.85 CAD , about $3.66 per US Gallon in USD. Closest city on the US side is Bellingham, WA, lowest price there is $2.82, or about US $ 0.80 difference per gallon. Assuming a fill-up is 12 gallons, that is ~$10 per tank difference.
- cperciva 16y agoCanadians also pay much more for gasoline than Americans. Of course, not all of this is in taxes. I think most of the difference is taxes -- unlike pretty much everything else, advertised gasoline prices include federal and provincial sales taxes. In Vancouver they also include a carbon tax (currently $0.048/L) and an additional fuel tax to fund mass transit (currently $0.12/L).
- tedunangst 16y agoAmerican gas prices include all taxes.
- cperciva 16y ago
- ojbyrne 16y agoI moved from a job in Canada to a job in the USA with a similar salary in the US. The deductions from my paycheck were noticeably higher. Sales tax was slightly lower.
- ebiester 16y agoThe US is less competitive than it likes to believe in the tax wars, when all is included. We just spend an incomparable amount on military instead of social services.
- scottkrager 16y agoI just hope that capital gains taxes stay reasonable. I think they provide a large incentive for small companies to grow and NOT just be lifestyle businesses.
- chime 16y agoI've used 50% as a conservative estimate for all my back-of-the-napkin calculations for years and it has served me well, especially in consulting projects. Sure I can lower that by showing expenses etc. but in the general sense, if I charge $100/hour, what I'm really doing is enabling myself to spend $50/hour in the future. The true benefit of this is that I don't have to feel worried about over/under charging my clients.
- bretthoerner 16y ago> The true benefit of this is that I don't have to feel worried about over/under charging my clients. Why not? If you could (should) be charging $120 then that'd be $60 of future spending.
- chime 16y agoI charge $100 because I really feel the effort is worth $50 to me and the client won't pay more than $100. Think of it this way: The lower bound is set by how much I feel the effort is worth after taxes. The upper bound is set by how much I think/know the client will pay. If half of the upper bound is less than my lower bound, I don't do it. This way I don't under-charge. By over-charge, I meant to say that even though I feel my effort is truly worth $50 after taxes, I don't have to worry about charging $100, because I'm not really over-charging the client since half of $100 is going to taxes. Without taking 50% taxes into account (which is what a lot of people do), asking $100 for something I truly feel is worth only $50 feels like overcharging. Over-charging new clients is never a personal issue because they can always say no and walk away. But over-charging existing clients can cause you to lose a steady stream of income, especially after you've invested time and effort to establish a relationship and understanding of their needs.
- lsc 16y agoeh, it always seemed to me that consulting was really only a win if you were consulting to support another business... e.g. if I can earn $100/hr and turn around and plow that money into my hosting business the same year, that seems huge in terms of net-worth growth. Yeah, I still gotta pay the piper when the money comes out, but meanwhile I can use it to grow more money. (and really, once I'm rich, I like to think that losing a bunch to the tax man will hurt less.) The problem with this approach is, of course, that if you screw up your accounting and get audited, you can come away with some silly high tax bills that can't be discharged by bankruptcy.
- cullenking 16y agoAs a person who wants to pay as little tax as possible (until of course, they start spending the tax money in ways that I see fit, which don't include blowing things up), I have always been against the concept of a single national sales tax, or a flat tax. However, more and more I am realizing that the benefits of axing most of the IRS (wow, talk about administrative overhead) would actually effectively lower everyones tax burden by several percentage points. You can't dodge a sales tax aside from buying used (great incentive to curb our plastic consumer culture), but the good might outweigh my original objections. Let the states decide if they want to makeup the rest with property or sales tax, and the simplified tax system results in huge benefits.
- Retric 16y agowow, talk about administrative overhead) would actually effectively lower everyones tax burden by several percentage points. ??? Where is the savings? The IRS is a tiny fraction of US government spending. Edit: IRS $12.15 billion in 2010, total federal expenditures $3.552 trillion. So it's 1/3 of 1% of the federal budget.
- gte910h 16y agoI believe he's talking about compliance with income tax regulations on the non-governmental side. Accountants, tax prep, etc.
- Retric 16y agoI pay 120$ a year for someone else to do my taxes, I make ~80k per year. So add 1/6 of 1% so we are now up to 1/2 of 1%. Anyway, there is going to be a cost to administering any tax so while simplifying things may save money it's never going to zero. PS: I could see a simplified tax code saving people 20 billion a year, but good luck implementing that. Edit: For example, CC transaction fees cost more than current transition costs, so a sales tax would have higher compliance costs.
- gte910h 16y ago
- dschobel 16y agoSomeone enlighten me, how can the author talk about a marginal tax rate for the entirety of ones income? Isn't a marginal rate by definition the rate which applies to earnings above a specific benchmark (thereby providing no disincentive to cross it)?
- btilly 16y agoThe author didn't do that. Instead he reported on research that found that the effective marginal tax rate across a broad range of incomes and life situations was generally close to 40%. So no matter what your income, your marginal tax rate is probably close to 40%.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- houseabsolute 16y agoTo put it simply: if you earn a dollar more of income, about forty percent of that dollar will end up going to the government.
- brc 16y agoOr, in other words, in a 5 day week, Monday and Tuesday you work for the government. Wednesday through Friday is for yourself.
- houseabsolute 16y agoNo, that's not right, because the dollars you are already earning might not be taxed at the marginal rate.
- tbrownaw 16y agoIf your marginal tax rate is approximately constant, then it will also approximately equal your overall ratio of tax/income. So even though the article doesn't seem to be particularly careful with the difference, it doesn't really matter in this case.
- tomwalker 16y agoThat is so low compared to the UK.
- tome 16y agoI'd be interested in a "true marginal tax rate" article relevant to the UK, if you know one.
- MC27 16y agoWhich in turn is so low compared to many other countries in Northern Europe.
- teamonkey 16y agoIt's not. We British like to complain about being ripped off but we're better off than we think. Having moved to Canada much more leaves my paycheck than it would in the UK and, according to an online calculator, the same would be true if I moved to the States. The things that really hurt in the UK are things like power and fuel costs, council taxes, and various other mortgage-related taxes. That's where I'm really seeing the difference.
- aasarava 16y agoAnyone know why there's such a big dip for 30yrs at $50K?
- tibbon 16y agoI'm guessing they assume a 30-year old couple has purchased a house recently (large mortgage interest deduction), and has student loans still (student loan interest deduction up to 6K/year I think, which goes away after 80K or so. IANAA). Between those two things, plus the general tax benefits of being married (and 50K not being that much for two people imho) give them a low tax rate.
- nck4222 16y agoMan, those percentages in the chart at the end are really whacky. Someone making $75,000/year pays a higher % tax their entire life than someone making $200,000/year? Someone making $20,000/year (at 30) pays almost twice the % as someone making $50,000/year (at 30)? That doesn't seem right.
- Retric 16y agoSS is 12.4% and it stops at ~120k / year.
- nck4222 16y agoAh, that makes sense. Is that 120k/year for couples or just singles?
- Retric 16y agoThe cap is per person. However, payouts increase by 50% for married couples where only one person worked. This is then cut in half if the spouse who worked dies. If the non working spouse dies then the worker is left with their normal benefit. Edit: Each benefit is considered independently, so if you both made the same amount then there is no increase in maximum payout, however you can take the spouses lower benefit early (62) and put off using your benefit till (67) which would increase your total payout assuming you lived to 85. PS: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Security_Wage_Base http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Security_Wage_Base Ops, looks like they did not raise the cap so it's $106,800 in 2010.
- ojbyrne 16y agoSS and FICA are very regressive. It's interesting that the lowest rates roughly correspond with the median income - as if the rates were tailored to get the lowest rates to the majority of the voters, while screwing (relatively) much smaller groups at the ends of the scale.
- mattmcknight 16y ago
- run4yourlives 16y agoThe main issue is that we're still taxing income, instead of taxing consumption. We (no matter the country) could save billions in administrative costs simply by moving all tax to point of sale style VATs. (As a sidenote this does not mean that something like the FairTax proposal is a good example of this concept.)
- pragmatic 16y agoCan you explain how this is different from the FairTax and why a sales tax style VAT would be better?
- run4yourlives 16y agoIn all forms of sales tax, the devil is in the details. The differences are not in the concept but how one chooses to administer the particulars. Where and if you choose to credit low income, what "sales" you choose to tax or not, and the overall tax rates themselves. FairTax, in my personal opinion isn't the best example of where to draw these lines. It is rightly criticized for that, but that says nothing about the fact that overall, taxing consumption is a better idea than taxing income - a move that was largely bred from the need to fund a massive increase in government spending. A tax that allows for funding of government programs, encourages the creation of wealth and the growth of personal income and discourages rampant consumerism (as in buying things you can't afford - and having prices bubble accordingly) is a much "fairer" system in my books. I discount a lot of the notions of this type of system being inherently regressive because that argument insinuates that the current system is not. I believe Mr. Buffet quite aptly supported this assertion with real numbers a few years back.
- kgroll 16y agoI'd be really interested in seeing the numbers from Buffet's assertion. Could you provide a link please? (Thanks!)
- run4yourlives 16y ago
- mcknz 16y agoIt's not like the entire tax goes into a black hole -- it would be interesting to see what the return is on the average tax rate: how much benefit is derived from state, federal, and city services (roads, water, security, libraries, parks) and benefits (unemployment, social security, disability).
- randallsquared 16y agoIt's not like the entire tax goes into a black hole It's arguable that we'd be better off were that so... part of the tax burden is all the people employed by those taxes who don't actually contribute anything to society on net (that is, whose jobs wouldn't be done at all on the free market)... in this way, taxes can have something like double their cost in harm, potentially.
- gchpaco 16y agoCitation, please.
- randallsquared 16y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_federal_agencies http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_federal_a... If you can find even a single agency on that list which performs a function you wouldn't be willing to pay for, the rest of my comment follows for you, specifically: that agency is a net cost to you comprising both the taxes you pay to fund it (proportionately) and the decrease in wealth caused by keeping those people from contributing to the economy by doing something productive. This isn't specific to the US government, of course; that's just the easiest example.
- gchpaco 16y agoNot beneficial to me personally does not mean "people ... who don't actually contribute anything to society on net", and it would take more research than I have time for to completely dismiss any US federal agency (except perhaps the DOD).
- akikuchi 16y agoThis is one of the least enlightening articles I've seen in a long time. I understand that it's a challenge to succinctly summarize a 73 page paper in 300 words, but here the author seems to be happy to use the paper's "findings" to support a extremely simplified "fact" about the current tax system. The numbers cited in the article are based on a wide collection of parameters/assumptions, but that is ignored in the summary. Interestingly, the paper on which the article is based was directly supported by fairtax.org- an organization solely dedicated to a drastic restructuring of the tax system. The all in tax burden at different levels of income is a very interesting concept to explore. But here it seems like both the journalist and the paper's authors have addressed the issue with a bias which takes away from what could otherwise be a very interesting subject.
- mixmax 16y agoIf you think that's high you should be happy you don't live in Denmark. "The large public sector (30% of the entire workforce on a full-time basis) is financed by the world's highest taxes. A value added tax of 25% is levied on the sale of most goods and services (including groceries). The income tax in Denmark ranges from 42.9% to 63% progressively, levied on 4 out of 10 full-time employees. Such high rates mean that 1,010,000 Danes before the end of 2008 (44% of all full-time employees) will be paying a marginal income tax of 63% and a combined marginal tax of 70.9% resulting warnings from organisations such as the OECD" Oh and if you want to buy a car you'll be hit with a 180% taxation of your new car on top of the 25% valueadded tax. source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Denmark#Tax_Burden_and_employment http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Denmark#Tax_Burden_a...
- _delirium 16y agoThe people who do live in Denmark seem pretty happy about doing so, though (http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2006/11/061113093726.htm http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2006/11/061113093726.ht...). One reason might be that they're fairly wealthy to begin with, so it's taking a large percentage out of a large pie (Denmark's per-capita GDP is ~DKK 375,000 = ~$62,000). The social safety net is also rather strong as a result of the government's large amount of income, and it's popular, partly because nearly everyone uses parts of it--- free education, free adult education, free health care, free child-care, pensions, job retraining, etc.
- alexyim 16y agoWhat does the US have?
- FrankBlack 16y agoBombs. Lots and lots of bombs. And, apparently, we love to use them. Prisons. We're good at those. Oh, and flags. We like to wave those a lot, too. Especially about the fact that we are "free" compared to those "socialist" menaces around the world. So, we pay an average of 40% in taxes, but does that pay for your higher education or your kid's higher education? Not likely. Does it pay for your health care? Probably not all of it (in some cases, none at all). Does it pay for daycare? Good retirement? So, when you factor that and a lot more into the equation, some countries don't have it so bad. The sad thing is, we could be doing SO well here if we just tweaked things a bit. Tweaking, apparently, is out of the question,
- leelin 16y agoVery cool, it seems the researchers took into account all sorts of things like state sales tax, state income tax, corporate tax, welfare / handout type programs, and spending + savings habits. From what I can tell the key inflection points in the graph come from four issues. 1.) How much can one contribute to retirement accounts to avoid paying income tax that year? 2.) Where are the key discontinuous cutoff points in the tax system? (social security maxes out, certain payments to the needy disappear, etc) 3.) What is the typical marginal propensity to consume? 4.) How much wealth has one accumulated by a certain age in life, which can be invested, which is only taxed at lower capital gains / dividend rates? My thoughts on the first are mixed. Yes, we don't pay taxes this year on money we stash into a non-roth 401k, but I hope they aren't doing the bad accounting of treating that as 0% tax... we will eventually pay SOME tax when we withdraw on it, just not this year. The second point is very valid... there is a magic range around $110-$160K income right now where your marginal tax rate from paying social security is almost 12% lower than the guys making $80K-$110K. In the US, you and your employer each pay 6.2% of your earned income to social security, but it caps at $110K (the rationale being you won't get credit for more than that at retirement, so they won't take more). The final points are a bit bogus in terms of providing us guidance, but they are more of the author's observations from the data they studied. Poor people consume more as a percentage of their income and hence pay more sales tax each year. Wealthier people buy more, but less as a percentage of their income, so they pay less sales tax, and save more over time which can be turned into investment income. http://people.bu.edu/kotlikoff/Does%20It%20Pay%20to%20Work%20and%20Save,%20December%209,2006.pdf http://people.bu.edu/kotlikoff/Does%20It%20Pay%20to%20Work%2...
- JoeAltmaier 16y agoReally rich people have little or no income. The dodge comes in taking your jet, car, residence, living expenses etc as work expenses. While you OWN billions, your income may be thousands.
- byrneseyeview 16y agoIf you own "billions," you presumably own equity or debt (maybe some commodities, but it's not likely). If you own debt, you're paying taxes on the interest. If you own equity, the value of that equity is the net present value of future cash flows--meaning it's 'taxed' at the rate at which corporations are taxed. In addition, spending a lot of money and then making it a 'work expense' still requires lots of income. You can't effectively write off your limo charges unless your income at least equals them. And I don't know how common it is to treat a residence as a work expense. There's a home office tax deduction, but that is a common audit flag.
- VladRussian 16y agothe true tax rate = total government spending divided by GDP. This is why Republicans, who've historically increased government spending, thus have increased real tax rate (while of course giving narrowly targeted breaks to themselves)
- rada 16y agoThe actual paper is here: http://www.kotlikoff.net/sites/default/files/Does%20It%20Pay,%20at%20the%20Margin,%20to%20Work%20and%20Save.pdf http://www.kotlikoff.net/sites/default/files/Does%20It%20Pay... and perhaps the most practical bit is here: The paper provides four main takeaways. First, thanks to the incredible complexity of the U.S. fiscal system, it's essentially impossible for anyone to understand her incentive to work, save, or contribute to retirement acounts absent highly advanced computer technology and software. Second, the U.S. fiscal system provides most households with very strong reasons to limit their labor supply and saving. Third, the system offers very high-income young and middle aged households as well as most older households tremendous opportunities to arbitrage the tax system by contributing to retirement accounts. Fourth, the patterns by age and income of marginal net tax rates on earnings, marginal net tax rates on saving, and tax-arbitrage opportunities can be summarized with one word - bizarre.
- kenjackson 16y agoI don't get the arbitrage takeaway? I thought that income tax was only a part of the puzzle. Maybe half. The other taxes you pay aren't affected by what you put in retirement accounts.
- rada 16y agoTax arbitrage means using the difference in tax rates to make extra money. If the tax rate when you contribute to a tax-deferred investment account is higher than the tax rate when you pull the money out, voila, you've profited from tax arbitrage. So I am not sure why you are thinking of income vs. other taxes. The authors are simply saying, if you are a high earner in a top federal tax bracket, it really pays to put money into tax-deferred investments.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- kenjackson 16y agoOK, I thought the takeaways were implying that you were finding some inefficiency in the system. Rather they were simply saying that retirement accounts work as advertised. Just an odd takeaway, since that's the expressly stated purpose of most retirement accounts. But fair enough.
- jeromec 16y agoSemi-related: Can someone explain to me California CRV on recyclable containers? My understanding is that this is meant to encourage recycling, but the deposit amount you pay at the store doesn't equal what you get when you recycle your containers. I checked out the Wikipedia page, and it explains how the "Redemption Value" has changed over the years. If you take one of those large 2.5 Gallon containers of Arrowhead Water you are charged an additional $.50 each! There is no way you get that much to recycle it. How many bottles are sold annually in California? That looks like clear additional tax revenue. To add insult to injury, you are charged sales tax on the CRV deposit! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Redemption_Value http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Redemption_Value
- _delirium 16y agoI believe the private recycling companies that operate the redemption centers do get the full CRV, rather than the state keeping it (though the state keeps the sales tax on the CRV). If you go as an individual to a recycling company to return containers for a refund, they pay you less than the CRV, the difference going to their costs and profit. Since it seems to not be a very competitive market (recycling centers aren't really competing for your business by offering higher redemption values), almost all of them pay the minimum redemption value that CA law requires them to pay.
- jeromec 16y agoThanks for the explanation, but I don't think I feel better about it. If the recycling center gets my deposit I'm wondering why they need it. I thought the point of a recycling center was that the material they collect (aluminum, plastic, paper etc.) is profitable to collect. The CRV is labeled as a "deposit". To me that should be like a bank term, i.e., you can reclaim what you leave initially. I'm at a loss to understand why this deposit is not fully refunded (which would further encourage recycling!), or at least something reasonable like say 75%.
- graywh 16y agoSounds like they could use to increase the deposit and minimum refund amounts.
- alok-g 16y agoIf I buy something for $100, I would pay sales tax on it. But is that really it for purchases? Isn't the government collecting taxes at several other points as the good is being made and brought to market? Taxes on raw materials, on components making the product, taxes on shipping, etc. All in all, if I buy something for $100, how much is the tax collected by the government (in addition to what is taken from my income leaving me this $100 to spend)? Is all of that taken into account in this report?
- Elite 16y agoSounds like an excellent thesis for an economics grad student. I'd love to see this data in an easy to read format for a variety of goods and industries
- dotBen 16y agoIn UK the income tax for high-rate earners (anyone earning about $70k) is 40%. As in, that's what is reflected in your pay check. Then you add on council tax (equiv of state tax although it's calculated based on value of house), VAT (sales tax, 17.5% moving to 20% next year), property tax (only at sale and if you own more than one), and all the sin taxes (cigarettes and gas is WAY higher cos it's mostly tax). I like living in California and America... the taxes are so low here! (caveat: yes we get health care paid for in UK which I have to pay for here)
- jcgregorio 16y agoSeriously, a 2007 news article based on a 2006 unrefereed paper is on the front page today?