4 ms·
If the "hydrogen economy" people ever figure out a way to make the equipment and fuel cells economical, cracking hydrogen from water at times when power is $0.0
by walrus01 9y ago
If the "hydrogen economy" people ever figure out a way to make the equipment and fuel cells economical, cracking hydrogen from water at times when power is $0.00 per kWh could be one method. Takes a massive amount of amperage. Store it in tanks and use as needed through giant fuel cells.
- greglindahl 9y agoEnergy losses from this scenario are high enough that there are probably other usage scenarios that would beat it. It's certainly the case that there are already many peak-storage solutions deployed and none of them involve hydrogen.
- nkurz 9y agothere are already many peak-storage solutions deployed and none of them involve hydrogen That seems like an overstatement. There has definitely been considerable research into using hydrogen as "peak-storage solution", and I think some approaches are actually being deployed. For example, here's an NREL story from last year: https://www.nrel.gov/continuum/energy_integration/hydrogen.html https://www.nrel.gov/continuum/energy_integration/hydrogen.h... The article agrees with you that the current inefficiencies of the round-trip to the grid are large, but claims that generating hydrogen as a vehicular fuel using excess solar and wind power does make sense. So if the parent was envisioning those "giant fuel cells" as being mobile (or located somewhere really remote), then he's not that far off.
- dpark 9y agoThat’s a demonstration project and to the extent that it’s “deployed”, so are tokamaks. Hydrogen may be feasible for peak balancing but it seems correct to say that it is not currently used this way.
- greglindahl 9y agoOK, so what % of peak storage solution is hydrogen?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- usrusr 9y ago> Store it in tanks and use as needed through giant fuel cells. Or just push it into the gas pipeline grid, it provides storage capacity and has the applications already waiting (the amount of hydrogen allowed in the final mix varies between regions, but we are a long shot from displacing natural gas by that fraction, worst case you'd have to add in a slightly lossy methanation step). It works, a well developed gas grid already has all the storage capacity you could ever need and you wouldn't have to scrap your existing gas peakers even after scaling to 100% renewable. Perfect migration paths tend to be disappointingly unspectacular.