3 ms·
What I take from this is not "austerity allows extremists to take over" but you need the middle and upper classes support to take over a country. The austerity
by lifeisstillgood 9y ago
What I take from this is not "austerity allows extremists to take over" but you need the middle and upper classes support to take over a country. The austerity part was just the bit that persuaded the middle classes to put up with all the rest of Hitlers rhetoric.
The spending cut was dramatic in the paper - 25% drop in government spending. In the UK our austerity program at the height of 2010-15 was a reduction in the growth of spending (not a nominal cut). AFAIK only greece has seen such a dramatic reduction in GDP (and I am not sure the government spending cuts have been so deep).
Additionally it's worth noting David Runciman's comments on Greece and Nazi party (#) here - he posits the major difference is one of age - Germany and Europe were young (25 years on average) then but now greece is a muchnolder population- old guys riot less it seems.
This looks like a decent paper on an area of interest but Runcimans presentation above reflects my thoughts - if we do screw up the world again, the threat this time will look different, come from a different angle. We should not just avoid the mistakes of history - we are really good at coming up with whole new mistakes as well.
(#) Talking politics podcast cannot find the right episode.
- crdoconnor 9y ago>In the UK our austerity program at the height of 2010-15 was a reduction in the growth of spending (not a nominal cut). In the UK the cuts were directed - largely at public sector jobs and wages and benefits, foodbanks, etc. You can take £1,000 of money spent on foodbanks or soldier wages and just give it to a military contractor or Carillion and technically public sector spending hasn't been cut by £1000, but the effect is as if it had. Nonetheless, the effect of austerity in the UK was a lot milder than it was in Greece and, as a consequence, we don't have people waving swastika flags around like they do.
- pjc50 9y ago> We don't have people waving swastika flags around like they do. .. yet. We did have an MP shot by a member of a far-right organisation, and we do have an ongoing problem with fascist newspapers. "Crush the saboteurs" and all that. It has now become alarmingly routine to refer to the leader of Her Majesty's Loyal Opposition as a traitor.
- lifeisstillgood 9y agoCorbyn's vilification is not a sign of fascism but a different problem over Brexit - like I said our next challenges will not look like the 1930s - we will invent our own new cballenges
- crdoconnor 9y agoCorbyn's villification by the political establishment does mirror the KPD's villification by Weimar, as well as Sanders' villification by Hillaryites. The KPD was annihilated though, while Corbyn held on. If anything he makes the rise of the far right much less likely by presenting a viable anti-austerian alternative. I don't imagine UKIP will be around much longer.
- pjc50 9y agoUKIP are already dead - kipperism is mainstream cabinet policy now. It was only ever a shell for Farage. The rest of the party was a set of cranks who'd been ejected from mainstream politics and who couldn't get on with each other. Their only ever MP, Douglas Carswell, quit the party. They had no real "ground game" and a very limited council presence. It's a mystery why Farage was and continues to be invited onto BBC Question Time week after week.
- crdoconnor 9y agoThey did really well in the European elections though. That's what spooked the Tories and caused, y'know, "that" referendum. That would probably not have happened if all mainstream parties had not looked like weimaresque mirror images of each other at the time.
- gaius 9y agobut a different problem over Brexit Corbyn, like May, was a lukewarm campaigner for Remain, but unlike her Corbyn has a 40-year track record of voting against everything EU every chance he got. Had he nailed his colours to the mast at the time of the Referendum there is no doubt in my mind he would be PM now.
- markvdb 9y agoOther than Greece, recent examples of brutal govenment spending cuts can be found in Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania. The cuts there were actually worse, both in relative and absolute terms. Latvia for example had a 26% drop in GDP and a 55% drop in housing prices at the peak of the crisis. On many levels, 20-33% of public servants were fired, with the remainers' already low wages reduced by 20-33%.
- lifeisstillgood 9y agoThank you - was not aware. That is stunningly bad any good sources on this ?
- markvdb 9y agoSorry, reading your comment just now, and have to run soon, so... the obvious starting point: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Latvia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Latvia