2 ms·
Hi and Thanks for replying! I did warn I was going to be "bitching" about that bit :) I read your paper- I agree that you didn't make any claims that you're t
by YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago
Hi and Thanks for replying!
I did warn I was going to be "bitching" about that bit :)
I read your paper- I agree that you didn't make any claims that you're the first to notice the effect of strong priors on sample efficiency. Like I say above, I think your paper is really interesting and that your experiments are a great idea- it's a little disappointing to see it did not get as much interest on hacker news as other recent work on deep reinforcement learning posted on here (but then, this is a popular forum, not a scholarly journal :).
One thing I felt was missing (unless I'm the one who missed it) is some examples of what happens when a human player has played the original game once, before attempting the ones with the various ablations. I tried that- I played the un-masked game once, then tried the "hard mode" game, the one with visual similarities masked, and I was able to finish it without dying, although I kept falling off platforms (I guess I got lucky and missed the fire pit). I even managed to kill the blobs. This was all done from memory, of course, but that's memory of object affordances, identities and semantics, not specific keypresses. I think that's an interesting thing to note.
But, you know- just a minor detail :)
Thanks for writing the paper and making it available on arxiv.