3 ms·
The problem is that when you show a single example of "a toy" (let's say- a fire engine) to a child, they don't just learn to recognise the unique object you sh
by YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago
The problem is that when you show a single example of "a toy" (let's say- a fire engine) to a child, they don't just learn to recognise the unique object you showed them as a "fire engine"; they learn the concept of "fire engine" that they can subsequently correctly recognise in different objects, with very different characteristics. Having learned what a fire engine is, they can then recognise fire engines of all shapes an sizes as belonging to the same category of "fire engine" as the original; a blue fire engine as a special case with a surprising colour; or a real fire engine as a different class of fire engines that is not a toy; and so on.
Machine vision classifiers can do nothing of the sort, no matter how many examples you give them and for how long they learn to look at them. If you label a fire engine toy as a "fire engine" then either the classifier will only be able to recognise toy fire engines, or it will have to mislabel real fire engines as "toy fire engine".
I agree that the difference between the sampling rate of humans and machine vision classifiers is not well defined, but it is obvious (and far as I can tell there's a strong consensus on this) that machine vision algorithms are many orders of magnitude less sample efficient than humans.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agowhen you show a single example of "a toy" (let's say- a fire engine) to a child, they don't just learn to recognise the unique object you showed them as a "fire engine"; they learn the concept of "fire engine" that they can subsequently correctly recognise in different objects I don't have that same experience at all. In fact if anything it's the opposite. My kids called ambulances "fire trucks" until I - the supervised labeler - corrected them. that machine vision algorithms are many orders of magnitude less sample efficient than humans. I don't think anyone disputes that - but they are at least in the same ballpark in terms of structure, especially if you look at the way RL works.