3 ms·
Human object recognition has its own common failure modes. Take almost any photo that has dense content, mirror it, and "faces" or "creatures" will appear. We'
by TheOtherHobbes 9y ago
Human object recognition has its own common failure modes.
Take almost any photo that has dense content, mirror it, and "faces" or "creatures" will appear. We're primed to parse curvy symmetric shapes as organic, and if there's any hint at all of eyes we'll probably see a face.
Optical illusions are a catalogue of other failures. We can easily be tricked into misreading colours, shapes, and lengths.
Because the visual cortex works at a higher level of abstraction than naive pixel-reading classifiers, we're not likely to be confused by adversarial pixel flipping. But we're just as likely to misread equivalent abstractions at a higher level.
Things get even worse at higher cognitive levels. The recent study into the spread of fake news shows that we're far more likely to mis-parse "facts" than to be ruthlessly objective.
The underlying problem is that we expect AI to show the same predictability that simple digital logic does. AI won't and can't, because the problems operate on a completely different level and uncertainty is built into the domain. The best solutions will be better than humans, but it's naive to think infallibility is possible.
- roywiggins 9y agoIt's true, we see faces where there aren't any. But we usually know very quickly that it's not a real person- even if we might be confused if we catch it out of the corner of our eye, as soon as we get a chance to look at it for more than a split second we will change our mind and not believe it's a real face. Of course there are more persistent failure modes where we can be tricked for a lot longer, and artificial illusions that persist despite knowing what they are.