4 ms·
Can you provide a hypothetical example? I'm curious to know what type of corruption you have in mind, e.g. government corruption, or breach of fiduciary duty, o
by rahimnathwani 9y ago
Can you provide a hypothetical example? I'm curious to know what type of corruption you have in mind, e.g. government corruption, or breach of fiduciary duty, or helping clients' employees defraud their employers through bespoke structured products.
- osrec 9y agoLet's take structured products as an example. Example: A UCITS fund is not allowed to invest in commodities directly, but it wants exposure to gold. The head of structuring knows the fund manager, so offers him a structured index for an under the table fee. The index contains only one item: a gold future! The fund gets the ability to speculate on commodities, the head of structuring gets a nice little payoff, and everyone's happy. When compliance asks why are you in commodities, the guys say "it's only an index" - and compliance goes away satisfied. Silly, but true story.
- mynameishere 9y agoI'm not sure where the illegality in your story lies. You perhaps intentionally left that out to make it seem more complex. I don't know. But if someone wants exposure to gold (for whatever reason) why wouldn't they just buy GLD or futures directly?
- osrec 9y agoUCITS regulation prevents direct exposure to commodities. It's mentioned near the start of my example.
- mynameishere 9y agoOkay. I guess my confusion is with respect to the word "direct" and whether an index containing futures is "direct" or not. I guess it is. To me, "direct exposure" would be actually owning the commodities rather than two levels of indirection that an index containing futures would imply. But whatever. So I guess it's incumbent upon the person who understands such things to report them to the appropriate regulatory authorities rather than downvoting random people just hearing about them for the first time.
- osrec 9y agoThat is precisely the point of my argument. You as a non experienced finance professional can see the fallacy in their methods (ie, they may as well have bought the gold in the first place, which is illegal), but they found a little loop hole to circumvent the rules and do whatever the hell they want with their fund, all while marketing it as UCITS compliant.
- amygdyl 9y agoFor practical examples open the Companies Act, and flick through noting how many summary criminal penalties for infractions exist therein. Summary criminal justice is a judge without jury trial and the description is highly pertinent to anyone expecting a pedantic and thorough hearing. Unlikely will you benefit from one. But for the millions of company directors who rely on the sagacity of a accountant's counsel, it is not lawful to so recuse oneself from the direct responsibility. Which should be obvious. But how many company directors have you heard casually quip how they leave so much to their accountant or consulting firm?