3 ms·
As a former chemist, call me suspicious of these findings. Can cleaners be an irritant to the lungs? Of course. Inhaling a lot of things can be an irritant.
by refurb 9y ago
As a former chemist, call me suspicious of these findings.
Can cleaners be an irritant to the lungs? Of course. Inhaling a lot of things can be an irritant.
Most cleaners that consumers use are surfactants sometimes mixed with alkylbenzonium disinfectants (in very low concentration). Even cleaners that are ammonia based aren't harmful.
Now on the professional side, I could believe there is risk. Some of those chemicals are very harsh.
- sizzle 9y agoWhy do you believe ammonia/chemical based cleaners are not harmful when inhaled from normal day to day use? I say that as someone who majored in human bio and can only imagine that inhaling these chemicals will have adverse effects on your health.
- drewbuschhorn 9y agoI'd assume because our bodies have a pretty big buffer store to avoid pH effects, and most ammonia based derivatives would be concentrated in the external mucus membranes not the lungs, at least that's most inhaled acids work, I'm not really a bases guy. I mean if you're inhaling anything with benzene rings on a regular basis, you should really wear a mask and so not do that, but inhaling 2x your daily dose of surfactant once a week is probably fine for the home cleaner. Skip the BBQ that weekend and it probably balances out.
- refurb 9y agoAmmonia is such a strong irritant you'd never be able to inhale enough (willingly) to cause systemic toxicity. We also have a lot of info around the effects of ammonia. The body is very good at eliminating it. Heck, doctor's use ammonium chloride to acidify a patients urine. Could you inhale enough to irritate your lungs? Sure. But it's not going to cancer or something.
- st26 9y agoCould you inhale enough to irritate your lungs? Sure. But it's not going to cancer or something. I think we're assuming here that it's something like asbestos lung cancer. Asbestos is not a poison, just an irritant. Presumably nobody is getting poisoned here; chronic irritation is triggering problems.
- refurb 9y agoAsbestos is more than an irritant. The toxicity and resulting cancer is due to the small particle size and the iron atoms in the asbestos that catalyze the formation of reactive oxygen species that damage the cell and can cause mutations. I guess my point is that there is no mechanism by which ammonia could cause something like this. It's a simple molecule that pretty much causes irritation due to it's alkaline properties.
- st26 9y agoThanks, I hadn't heard they finally figured out why/how asbestos was causing cancer.
- nonbel 9y agoIf you believe cancer is due to the accumulation of mutations, and the ammonia/whatever is killing cells (thus increasing the turnover), then it will increase the chances of cancer simply because there are more divisions in the tissue. This follows pretty simply from the idea that cancer is caused by accumulating mutations (which you seem to believe), so why do you say "no mechanism"?
- refurb 9y agoThe reason is because ammonia has been around a long time, lots of studies of that its effect on biological systems have been done and it naturally occurs in human blood albeit at low concentrations. Your point about higher turnover of cells aligns with the idea of more cell division and thus higher chance of mutation. However, just because a chemical causes irritation doesn't mean it increases cell turnover. Also, turnover alone doesn't necessarily drive mutations and scientists don't really know why. Retinol A, rapidly increase skin cell turnover and is used to treat acne, but I've never heard of a mutation risk associated with it.
- briandear 9y ago“Can only imagine..” Imagine all you want, but imagining isn’t data.
- sizzle 9y agoYes and correlation =/ causation despite how my brain rationalizes things. If we are talking scientific method, then my hypothesis is that inhaling ammonia frequently will result in adverse health effects. Feel free to test this out and prove otherwise.
- drewbuschhorn 9y agoAs another former chemist, I just wanted to agree with this statement. And for industrial cleaners, read the MSDS and act accordingly. It's not that hard to find the correct version of masks and gloves for the task you do everyday.
- DoingIsLearning 9y agoAs someone without a Chemistry background I am just really surprised that they managed to write an entire article about other studies, without ever referencing these studies? Also just about anything is a "chemical", and there is a plethora of cleaning products, what agent exactly in cleaning products do they speculate causes this damage?
- FeepingCreature 9y ago> As a former chemist, call me suspicious of these findings. I've been suspicious since they were posted, for a simple reason: so where's the lung cancers in aging housewives?
- briandear 9y agoAgree! And on that note, where are the lung cancers in non-smokers who work/worked around second hand smoke?
- excalibur 9y agoI'm not a chemist at all, but I know that there are a lot of variables here. A link between particular cleaning products and poor lung function on the basis of anecdotal evidence about how often people clean seems tenuous at best.