4 ms·
All of those things could be true and coops still be preferable to the alternatives.
by wahern 9y ago
All of those things could be true and coops still be preferable to the alternatives.
- kiliantics 9y agoI think so too. In principle, the workers still have democratic decision-making power in the operation of the co-operative. So a functioning co-op is still better than any hierarchical corporations, which usually suffer from the same problems anyway.
- hueving 9y agoWhy do you think democratic decision making in a corporation is a good thing?
- andrepd 9y agoPrevents the grave unequal power balance between workers and owners, by doing away with the concept of "owner" entirely.
- hueving 9y agoBut that has nothing to do with optimal outcomes for a business or the optimal utility for society. Also, it doesn't dispose of the concept of owner. It's exactly like a publicly traded company with shareholders. The only difference is that the shareholders are restricted.
- kiliantics 9y agoif "optimal" outcome for a business comes at the expense of conditions for workers, then I wouldn't consider it optimal
- skookumchuck 9y agoIn America, at least, any group of workers are free to form a coop. It's perfectly legal. Why not give it a try, and report back to us how it worked out?
- wahern 9y agoTo be clear, I didn't say that I believe a coop was the better system. But as an American, in my experience every one of fbn79's criticisms could equally be applied to private corporations. What matters is the relative difference and the overall economic context. And if he grew up steeped in a system that was heavily oriented toward the coop, I couldn't give him the benefit of the doubt, either, in the sense that it may not have been obvious to him that a more traditional private enterprise system could have outcomes that were even worse--like greater unemployment with at least as much political corruption and wealth skimming. Also, I spent half my childhood growing up in the heavily unionized Chicago area, and half in the vehemently anti-union Deep South. In both regions adults always complained about the corruption and inefficiency of unions. Which always perplexed me because as a naive (though arguably objective observer), both private and public works projects in the Deep South were immensely more inefficient than in the Chicago land area. They took longer and seemed of lesser quality even though often less ambitious. And while as an adult I understand the truth in the complaints about unions--there often is corruption and especially inefficiency and back-scratching--the outcomes aren't necessarily worse than in non-union systems, and sometimes much better. It depends on the larger context. That said, there are plenty of worker-owned coops in the U.S. I recently discovered that Litehouse Foods is one such business. I wanted to know if Costco would keep selling Litehouse's awesome and reasonably priced freeze-dried herbs, so spent an evening Googling everything Litehouse related. I've been buying Litehouse freeze-dried herbs at Safeway when on sale for a couple of years. The grocery retail prices (sale or not) are competitive with online and mail-order freeze-dried manufacturers, but the Costco prices were so incredibly low-priced that I was curious how sustainable it could be. I never could figure out if Costco will continue selling those herbs, so last time I was at Costco I bought enough freeze-dried garlic, basil, parsley, oregano, thyme, dill, green onion and red onion to fill up two entire shelves in the kitchen.
- vertex-four 9y agoSo the main problem that co-ops have is that they don’t have access to traditional forms of capital. You can’t get VC funding as you can’t give out equity, obviously, and banks won’t lend to you. The co-ops that I’ve seen in recent years have been started on Kickstarter funding based on support for e.g. pop-up stalls that the co-ops ran in early days, and that only goes so far and only works for certain types of companies.
- hueving 9y agoAny particular reason you think that?
- wahern 9y agoBecause private, investor-owned corporations can also be * Anti-meritocratic * Abused as vehicles for tax avoidance * Harm competition (indeed, avoiding, minimizing, or killing competition arguably encompasses the majority of sales and business strategies) * Pay low wages, especially relative to management, and particularly relative to upper management. * Rely heavily on political connections, sometimes to the point of classic quid pro quo corruption. My point was merely that all of those characterizations not only could be made of private corporations, in some economic markets private industry can be even more abusive than other forms of organization. You can't compare actual coops to the imaginary, Platonic ideal of free market capitalist enterprise. You have to compare it to what capitalist enterprise would actually look like in that region if it displaced the coops. The dynamics that breed corruption won't disappear. A more heavily capitalist, investor-owned system could result in any number of possible outcomes, some worse and some better, and it's not at all obvious which would be more likely. The first thought that entered my mind when I read his criticism was that maybe he should ask migrant Mexican farmworkers in California if they'd like to swap places with the Italian coop members. I suspect that California agriculture produces more output at a lower price than in the Emilia-Romagna region, but recent political trends the world over should make it clear that maximizing short-term economic efficiency isn't politically viable, regardless of whether it objectively maximizes overall social wealth. And regardless of whether it maximizes long-term wealth equality--we'll never see those fruits if the social and political fabric disintegrate.
- hueving 9y agoAll of those things apply to coops. Coops reward politically inclined members who can rally crowds. They are not meritocracies at all. Coops compete with others in the same way any other corporation would. In fact, employees who are members are more motivated to play dirty (a.k.a. cheat) than regular employees in a corporation. Coops are just as subject to corruption. Just look at the coop connections with the mafia in Italy.