4 ms·
You mistakenly compare a failure to act ("save someone from malaria") with a clear purposeful action ("extorted sick poor people"). And there's no particular "
by wpietri 9y ago
You mistakenly compare a failure to act ("save someone from malaria") with a clear purposeful action ("extorted sick poor people").
And there's no particular "higher purpose" of the law here that prevents us from making Shkreli's behavior illegal. Price gouging is illegal under other circumstances [1]; as far as I can tell his actions were legal just because nobody thought someone would be this awful.
If you'd like to defend this sociopath, please at least try to make your argument relate to the actual situation.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_gouging https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_gouging
- harryh 9y agoMalaria person: please wpietri, help me. wpietri: No Sick person: please shkreli, help me. shkreli: Sure, for $500 At least in the second scenario the person is being offered an option under which they get help. It sounds a lot better than the first scenario for the afflicted.
- robrenaud 9y agoSick person: please moderately profitable pharma company, help me. moderately profitable pharma company: Sure, for $50 Sick person: please insanely profitable pharma company post shrekli, help me. insanely profitable pharma company post shrekli: Sure, for $5000
- harryh 9y agoExactly. Same thing. Both voluntary business transactions subject to the same rules as any other voluntarily exchange. No one is obligated to sell any particular good or service for any particular price. I know a lot of people see this differently but I don't think they have an ethical leg to stand on. When it gets down to it they have no particular rule for fair pricing other than "that feels too high to me."
- draugadrotten 9y ago> No one is obligated to sell any particular good or service for any particular price. Well, nobody was forcing him to sell goods or services for any particular price. He set the price and now he has to face the consequences.
- notdonspaulding 9y ago"Nobody will force you to sell your goods for a particular price, but if you pick the wrong price, there will be consequences." Do you have some special definition of "force" that you are using which doesn't involve you deciding for someone else which course of action they will take and then making them take it at risk of "consequences"?
- theobon 9y agoThere are multiple cases where someone can be obligated to sell for a particular price. Eminent domain is the most obvious example but Reasonable and Non-Discriminatory Licensing [1] is more applicable. Patent laws creates a temporary monopoly. This monopoly needs to be regulated to prevent abuse. Avoiding extortionist pricing of patented medications seems like a reasonable area for regulation. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reasonable_and_non-discriminatory_licensing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reasonable_and_non-discriminat...
- rayiner 9y agoBut the patent on daraprim expired decades ago. It was a single source drug because there wasn’t enough money in the market for another manufacturer to make a competing alternative. There are something like 8,000 prescriptions a year.
- wpietri 9y agoIn which case that sounds like market failure to me, which is another excellent time for regulation. We do this all the time with other "natural monopolies".
- 9y ago
- dwild 9y ago2012 - Malaria person: please dwild, help me. dwild: no 2017 - Malaria person: please dwild, help me. dwild: no 2012 - Sick person: please Daraprim, help me. Daraprim: Sure, for US$13.5 2017 - Sick person: please Daraprim, help me. shkreli: Sure, for US$750 You see the difference? With me, they stayed at the same level of help, none. In the second, he purposefully profited from the help they were getting from Daraprim. He removed something they had beforehand.
- rayiner 9y agoHow is dwild still not strictly worse from a utilitarian point of view?
- btian 9y agoYes I see the difference. Shkreli is charging more. What still better than dwild though. So maybe dwild should go to jail
- ecommerceguy 9y agoGosh I wonder if a replacement was made for Daraprim.. >Imprimis Pharmaceuticals, a specialty pharmaceutical company that creates compounded drugs, released a $1 a pill alternative to , a toxoplasmosis treatment whose price skyrocketed by over 5,000% in recent months. >While the new pill is a boon for patients in need of treatment for the food-borne illness, especially those with weak immune systems like HIV/AIDS and cancer patients, the alternative drug is not an exact copy of Daraprim. >Imprimis’ pill is a combination of pyrimethamine—the sole ingredient in Daraprim—and leucovorin, a medicine that helps reverse the negative effects on bone marrow caused by the way pyrimethamine works in the body. The two medicines work synergistically and are recommended to be taken in tandem by the Centers for Disease Control. Leucovorin is often prescribed alongside Daraprim. Not only was the replacement cheaper, it was daraprim coupled with another drug to fight side effects of daraprim. The judge in this case has a history of using her bench as a bully pulpit. She claims that outside factors had 0 influence on her decision. I find that pretty hard to believe especially with her history. As for the cost increase I believe they were funding a non side effect version of the drug, which would probably be nice for alot of people. Bone marrow is something thats hard to live without. This will be overturned. So what if he's a trolling douchebag.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]