3 ms·
Funny, I grew up there. At scale, Emilia co-ops are the same as any other business: they want to make money, screw workers. The veneer of social conscience is
by toyg 9y ago
Funny, I grew up there.
At scale, Emilia co-ops are the same as any other business: they want to make money, screw workers. The veneer of social conscience is pretension, these days. A lot of jobs (most?) higher in the food chain are assigned through old-boys’ networks and political patronage (which is common even in the private sector, in Italy). Most large coop groups are struggling and surviving only with mergers. As the political system that allowed them to get established (stable 50-year left-wing governments across the whole region) slowly crumbled, their markets were blown open to competition, and they reacted by turning into more and more traditional businesses - or going bankrupt under clouds of political scandal.
A lot of people in the area think this type of development has fundamentally betrayed its origins and should be reformed at the very least.
EDIT: re-reading, I might have been a bit unfair. Coops had a tremendous social impact, until around the early 1980s. They were part and parcel of a development model that had little to envy to Scandinavian social democracy. It's just that they eventually changed, as all institutions do, prioritizing self-preservation and enrichment over their social role. This is particularly true for larger ones (generally in construction, food distribution, maintenance services, banking, and insurance).
- coliveira 9y agoThese coops may be challenged by other, leaner coops. There is no indication that the problem is, by itself, the fact that these companies are run as coops, since traditional companies are plagued by the same issues you mentioned.
- toyg 9y agoAbsolutely. The point is, though, that the model isn’t intrinsically better than public corporations, once you reach a certain size.
- woodpanel 9y agoInteresting to see, how perceptions differ when you're from the place. I've experienced this too when progressives from the US at home praise certain German policies as the way to go, yet they never seem to put the same effort into researching the local criticism as they put to in taking the positive claims at face-value. I'm a fan of co-ops, but gave up on the idea of replacing the private sector with it. If there's a market for them, they can compete easily (usually through quality). I'm inclined to see them as better agents for social welfare programs [1]. I'd like to hear from the author why they focus on some (in foreign eyes) romantic region in Italy and don't look at the dryer examples of large-scale co-ops that exist throughout the rest of Europe: Germany's and Switzerland's biggest retailers are co-ops (Rewe, Edeka and Migros, Coop). Italy's biggest retailer is also a co-op. German co-op retail-banks claim 20% market share. Austria's Reiffeisen Bank is the country's third largest bank. The world's biggest sugar-producer Südzucker is a co-op. The list of old co-ops that have scaled over time is long and studying them I think would provide much needed insight if we are to claim the "advancedness" of co-ops. Specifically all the scandals that have popped-up, like the "co-op-Scandal" of the late 1980s, one of Germany's biggest cases of financial fraud. [1] For example don't let the city/state build cheap housing, rather subsidize housing co-ops. Once you do that, you get political entanglement in return and in general the imbalance of the private-sector being marginalized. But I prefer that anytime over government housing. Germany is full of both (co-ops and city-run housing, with the latter being usually run-down and the former trumping median private-sector housing while being 30%++ cheaper).
- cjalmeida 9y agoI'm really curious why co-op building companies provide cheaper housing compared to regular private companies. Public sector inefficiency is well studied. Co-ops efficiency however not so much, at least for me.
- woodpanel 9y agoDisclaimer: I rented at two different co-ops in my life. My experience was great. Renters are „invested“ because they are: they buy shares, that spill dividends, they have a say as shareholders of private companies do. Attempt at answering: Co-ops try to provide affordable quality housing thus gains are usually reinvested via repair work and they don’t engage in selling their housing stock on the free market. Property they built, usually stays theirs forever. I think the biggest leverage on prices comes from land allocated to them by a city. As most shareholders are also renters they push the co-op leadership into keeping rents low and over time prices can diverge quite a lot from free market rates.
- cjalmeida 9y agoI see. But that also mean the original investors - the ones that put the initial money - are getting sub par returns. Or government land subsidies play an important role here assuming that private developers have no access to it. I don't see the lower returns as particularly damaging - there has been too much speculation in real state in recent decades. But that might not be the case once (if) returns get lower.
- jmiserez 9y agoIf the original investors are also living there (or bought in), then the cheaper housing costs make up for the lower returns, or no returns at all. The cheap housing is the return. Now technically you could argue that the outcome would be the same if you lived more expensively and you were an investor in some other for-profit housing with high returns. But that’s usually not the case, as the cash amounts you’d need initially are too high for most people.