5 ms·
"Your honor, I must protest this sentence! After all, my clients paid back all the money they stole from the bank!"
by ModernMech 9y ago
"Your honor, I must protest this sentence! After all, my clients paid back all the money they stole from the bank!"
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- gfosco 9y agoNot really a good analogy. They invested with him, he lost it but found another way to make that money back. There wasn't any theft.
- jartelt 9y agoIf I give you money to invest in Alphabet stock and you instead invest it in lottery tickets, that seems like theft to me regardless of whether the lottery tickets pay off or not.
- jonnycomputer 9y agoit surely does sound like people are looking for excuses for the guy. it was fraud, and he has only himself to blame.
- s73v3r_ 9y agoI think it's just that so many people don't want to have to think about their intentions when they do things.
- danso 9y agoHe wasn't prosecuted for theft (or embezzlement). He was prosecuted for fraud.
- meowface 9y agoHe not only lost it, he lied and said he did not lose it and that their money was safe and sound. Big difference. When you fabricate numbers and lie to people who have given you money, you're committing fraud, regardless of your ultimate intentions or if you manage to recover the money through other means.
- ryanlol 9y agoWorded differently, it doesn't sound like that would be such an unreasonable sentencing argument?
- tedunangst 9y agoThat was his argument. The judge decided that payback after the loss was mostly irrelevant, and loss is loss, even if never realized.
- ryanlol 9y agoJust because it didn't work for Shkreli doesn't make it any less of a reasonable argument in general. In Shkrelis case the judge dismissed this argument specifically because he only paid his investors back after they had already became suspicious, had he done so before that his behavior would have almost certainly been viewed differently. It is absolutely normal to take things like this into account during sentencing. And since it seems to be terribly difficult for some people here to understand, I'm not defending Shkreli and nor do I think there's anything wrong with his sentence.
- tedunangst 9y agoAll comments here seem to be terribly difficult to understand.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sol_remmy 9y agoYour sarcasm is showing your ignorance of the law. The level of monetary damages are absolutely considered when sentencing. That is why Bernie Madoff, who caused billions in damages, got a very harsh sentence.
- openasocket 9y agoYou're sentenced based on the severity of the illegal act, not based on the severity after you tried to smooth things over. So he would be sentenced based on the millions he defrauded, not based on the fact that the people were made whole in the long run. Source: I just asked my girlfriend, a third year law student. Also, you know, the judge for Shkreli's case: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-crime-shkreli/pharma-bro-shkreli-to-be-held-responsible-for-10-4-million-in-losses-u-s-judge-idUSKCN1GA2DB https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-crime-shkreli/pharma-... "[U.S. District Judge] Matsumoto said in Monday’s order that under federal law, all of the money that investors put in Shkreli’s funds as a result of his fraud, about $6.4 million, must be considered loss. She also said he should get no credit for paying investors back because he only did so after they became suspicious. "