3 ms·
We'll have to see how many workers' unions endorse this new deal. I'm sure the Kochs and the Soroses of the world will lament the US not being part of the deal
by mc32 9y ago
We'll have to see how many workers' unions endorse this new deal. I'm sure the Kochs and the Soroses of the world will lament the US not being part of the deal. But theirs is not the opinion that matters.
What's not clear to me is why people who were in Seattle in 1999 protesting the WTO are more or less quiet on things like the TPP which were much worse.
- walterbell 9y agoExcellent question. Not only the individuals but the funding of the organizations who protested Seattle. It is likely that many lessons were learned on all sides in 1999, so that strategies evolved. The WTO apparently failed to reach consensus later (Doha?) as opponents organized, including Indian farmers who committed suicide. The failure of WTO to reach new agreements is what lead to bi-lateral agreements between individual countries, and multi-lateral agreements (like TPP) + exceptions in bi-lateral “side letters”. In that sense, the Seattle protestors eventually won (no new WTO agreements) but the battle has moved to smaller and more secretive (national legislators excluded from some phases) contexts. In addition, for the already established WTO agreements, the US is currently considering new trade barriers that are permissible within existing fine print, which could weaken the old agreements.
- mc32 9y agoIt doesn't cease to amaze and shock me how what were 1980s hard union democrats who fought hard against Reagan's little globalization, dissolved under Clinton's charismaman persona and fell for big globalization. Even NPR, typically on the workers side, pushing FUD like canned goods will get expensive due to steel in the cans. As if half a penny per tin will break people and second as if we didn't have alternatives like glass and aseptic packaging. I'm heartened to learn there could be provisions for us to amend the execution of the NA trade agreement; as it would make sense for our workers.
- crdoconnor 9y agoUnion membership rate declined from 25% to 15% over that period partly because they kept losing the fight against Reagan. I suspect it was less about Bill Clinton's charisma and more about their overall level of political muscle.
- swebs 9y agoI think it's more about what individuals desire. Now we have people who promote socialism in one breath, but free trade in another. It's somewhat insane that the same people pushing for $15/hour minimum wage are the same as those pushing for unrestricted importing of cheap labor from Mexico.
- mc32 9y agoThis! I don't know how people square these disparate ideas. It has to be the result of corporate astroturfing in the most effective, insidious and effective manner that has allowed them, corps, to have their cake and also eat it on the backs of so called socialists who took it hook line and sinker.
- dashundchen 9y agoI think you may be conflating multiple left wing viewpoints in the US, which ranges from centrist free-trade neoliberal types to democratic socialists. I don't think I've seen anyone push for unrestricted immigration from Mexico either - what seems to have support is a path to citizenship for the Dreamers and those who are established and working here. Legal status would provide protection for these workers and students, rather than the vicious cycle of black market labor abuses by companies and abusers who have the threat of life destroying deportation to hang over their heads.
- mc32 9y agoIf that were the case, you'd see full support for a "wall". But a "wall" is topic non grata because it "is racist and xenophobic" and other choice epithets. It's implied in the phrase "people are not illegal" and whenever presenters and other talking heads invariably conflate legal immigration with illegal immigration (when offering reasons to support illegal immigrants they point to the accomplishments of legal immigrants, for example)
- tzs 9y ago> I'm sure the Kochs and the Soroses of the world will lament the US not being part of the deal. But theirs is not the opinion that matters By August 2016, here was the polling among registered voters in the US on TPP: 62% had heard little or nothing about it. Of those who had heard about it: 35% supported it, 22% opposed it, and 43% did not know where they stood or had no opinion [1]. A few months earlier, it had been 72% had heard little or nothing about it, and of those who had 26% supported it and 29% opposed it [1]. This is quite different from the impression one would get reading the discussion here and on Reddit at the time, where the narrative was that most of the public was opposed to it, but corporations and special interests were trying to force it through. I never really understood why people had a hard time believing the public might be in favor. When you look at the lists of companies supporting it, you'd see that it included some of the biggest employers in many areas. It should not be surprising that people whose jobs directly depend on those companies doing well would support something that their employer says will open new foreign markets for their American made goods, or let them compete better in existing foreign markets they export to, or will tighten up safety and environmental rules that their foreign competitors who sell in the US are subject to. [1] http://thehill.com/blogs/ballot-box/presidential-races/291085-poll-support-for-tpp-grows http://thehill.com/blogs/ballot-box/presidential-races/29108...
- mc32 9y agoWhile that may be --that much of the public was not well informed on the topic, it would still have been a detrimental pact for the hoi polloi --looking at the most arduous proponents kind of informs you who was to benefit from the pact --not the blue collar American worker, everyone's punching bag.