2 ms·
These are interesting thoughts, so thank you for sharing. Especially the idea that reversed incentives (for replication) might indeed not be desirable as well w
by Vinnl 9y ago
These are interesting thoughts, so thank you for sharing. Especially the idea that reversed incentives (for replication) might indeed not be desirable as well was insightful to me.
I very much agree that it would be great if "peer reviewed" was not seen as a binary - because the research it represents is not binary. However, basing funding decisions on a lot of portfolio's full of non-binary research results is still, I'm afraid, too much work for e.g. tenure committees.
(The annoying thing here is that just because a system like what you describe is still far from perfect, people will stick with the system that's in place even though that's far worse...)