6 ms·
One property of the laws of physics is that paths through history do not cross. If it is possible for two situation to time-evolve in to one, then we've got the
by whatshisface 9y ago
One property of the laws of physics is that paths through history do not cross. If it is possible for two situation to time-evolve in to one, then we've got the wrong laws of physics.
- krastanov 9y agoFor the sake of completeness, another way to say the same thing is: The laws of nature are the same if we reverse the direction of time. Until you start talking about entropy and chaos and statistics (which is a fascinating can of worms), the laws that you use to predict the next state of a system are the same that you would use to calculate the previous state of a system. To restate it in another way once again: The function mapping "state of the universe at time t" to "state of the universe at time t+dt" is a one-to-one map, hence two possible pasts could not have created the same present.
- jessriedel 9y agoThis > The laws of nature are the same if we reverse the direction of time. and this > To restate it in another way once again: The function mapping "state of the universe at time t" to "state of the universe at time t+dt" is a one-to-one map are not the same. Even for deterministic theories, time-reversal invariance implies one-to-one mappings but the reverse is not true. And for a stochastic theory it breaks down completely; you can have time-reversal symmetry but still lose information about the past (e.g., each time step the system changes into a completely random state form the state space). Whether quantum mechanics is considered fundamentally stochastic or deterministic depends on interpretation. (Roughly, Copenhagen is stochastic and Many Worlds is deterministic.)
- luk32 9y agoOk imagine you are seeing a screen and from behind you is coming a photon. How do you know whether there was a double slit behind you or not for a single photon? Those are two situations that will lead to the same outcome and you don't know which happened. Also reverse is possible. You have the same situation evolving into two different situations with double slit and interference.
- whatshisface 9y agoYou've just described the motivation for multiverse: Copenhagen has to stick in a concept of "measurement" that projects wavefunctions onto specific states. As a projection operator it's idempotent and many-to-one. However, this mechanism is not necessarily a law of physics: we can explain all of the same results without it. So, deciding whether or not wavefunctions "actually" collapse is 100% philosophy.
- kgwgk 9y agoWhile you no longer need wave functions to collapse, you need universes to branch out. The latter interpretation doesn't seem "better" than the former as far as being a reasonable description of the real world goes. And of course for all practical purposes they are equivalent.
- whatshisface 9y agoThe universes don't need an additional mechanism in order to branch out, wavefunctions will already do this if they're left alone (to be clear about what I'm saying, I mean that if you isolated some particles in a box they would start doing multiverse). The natural behavior of wavefunctions is to do multiverse, and if you want something else you have to introduce an additional mechanism that collapses them.
- kgwgk 9y agoWhich existing mechanism gets you from that metaphysical multiverse to the physical universe?
- whatshisface 9y agoThe "multiverse" would be one big wavefunction (quite physical), and each "universe" would be a partition of the wavefunction in phase space. In this sense "multiverse" and "universe" would just be names for different parts of the wavefunction, like "The Rocky Mountains," and "Kona," would be names for features on a topo map.