4 ms·
I Hope for Goldman Sachs’ Bankruptcy: Nassim Nicholas Taleb on Skin in the Game
- lz400 9y agoTaleb is a serious charlatan. I found somebody tweeting this the other day https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H11t5zBd3fU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H11t5zBd3fU
- petermcneeley 9y agoI dont see how that video backs up the claim of charlatan. I see someone saying that our science is limited and that survivorship (evolution) has an intelligence to it. I think to really make this claim you would need to focus on a falsifiable statement(s) that he has made.
- lz400 9y agoHow about his claims that the enlightenment screwed everything up and we were better off with a religious approach? Contradicts all evidence. Post-enlightenment reasoning and culture advanced civilization dramatically.
- petermcneeley 9y agoIn the video he says we are unwiser. That we are arrogant in our application of our limited scientific understanding. This type of statement by him is so vague that it cant really be a claim that is provable one way or another.
- lz400 9y agoSaying that we are unwiser post-enlightenment than in the dark ages is pure charlatanism in my opinion, however vague than statement is. The arrogance argument is more arguable but in the context it makes it look like the only thing we got out of the scientific revolution is arrogance, which is like saying that the only thing we got from discovering penicilin is antibiotic overuse.
- petermcneeley 9y agoThis might be enough for you but im looking for much clearer statements that can be demonstrated to be false. As an example of this I would point to my article on steven pinker. http://darkcephas.blogspot.ca/2018/01/on-group-selection.html http://darkcephas.blogspot.ca/2018/01/on-group-selection.htm...
- lz400 9y agoCharlatans don’t really do clear. Look at Deepak Chopra, it’s also going to be difficult to do demonstrably false stuff. It’s mostly vague mumbo jumbo that’s intuitively nonsense. Still, saying that we are unwiser now than before the enlightenment is demonstrably false by a number of metrics, from medical results to number of books published, literacy and many more.
- audiometry 9y agoEvery time I see 'self-described <i>flaneur</i>' I have a small puke in my mouth.
- mathperson 9y agodid nassim taleb really boast about deadlifting 400 lbs? That isn't very much for a deadlift if you lift consistently...
- jelling 9y agoHe may be a pompous jerk but 400 lbs is still significant.
- scottlocklin 9y agoIt's quite respectable if you're almost in your 60s, which he is.
- audiometry 9y agoThis is respectable: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5r9Rfo1vNDI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5r9Rfo1vNDI
- tomtimtall 9y agoRunning a Marathon every day for a week isn’t really much of an achievement for Extreme runners... but people are still allowed to be proud of running even a single Marathon. He wasn’t claiming to be an olympic weightlifter just sharing his PRs with pride.