4 ms·
It seems like there's a subset of psychological researchers that want so bad to debunk the years of research into IQ. I get that there are some uncomfortable i
by mywittyname 9y ago
It seems like there's a subset of psychological researchers that want so bad to debunk the years of research into IQ. I get that there are some uncomfortable implications that arise from accepting IQ as a measure of overall intelligence, but, from my understanding, IQ is an excellent predictor of income, social status, and academic & job performance.
My opinion is that we are doing society a huge disservice by dismissing IQ.
- iek2929nsn 9y agoI’m not interested in an individuals IQ predictions I’m interested in theories that accurately model objectively as possible reality If IQ is a good measure for some applications, fine If it’s not when it comes to describing the reality of reality itself, not just contemporary social life, it should be pushed aside for a method that does better
- usr999999 9y agoThis is largely anecdotal, so make of it what you will: I've observed high IQ scores to correlate more often with troubled lives than exceptional performance in job and status. It seems to me that these people tend to extremes and environmental aspects play a strong role in how these tendencies develop. Outright dismissing IQ would be detrimental, but its predictive value seems vague beyond some basic observations.
- dmix 9y agoIt's predictive to an extant. Many people who have taken up the mantel of IQ have taken it too far. And their (largely political) detractors have dismissed them merely because they have taken it too far. But much of it is still true from a more measured perspective. Which has some very inconvenient / awkward implications for many people who are seeking to dismiss it outright, rather than dismiss particular proponents of it... But taking any idea to the extremes, bulldozing over context and constraints of the data, and making grand generalizations from very simple base ideas is the bread and butter of politics, economics, and any bestselling non-fiction. Popular discourse may be a tribal battle between extremes, but real life isn't...
- throwaway337 9y agoIf you look at job performance: http://psycnet.apa.org/record/2003-11198-010 http://psycnet.apa.org/record/2003-11198-010
- ggggtez 9y agoYes, but then again, I'll posit that having Blue Eyes is correlated with income. But I'd like to see someone to try to defend that position scientifically. In reality, all I've done is created an artificial group which is heavily skewed towards richer countries. The color of the eyes had nothing to do with IQ, and yet it's correlated. So what, if anything, is the IQ test measuring? How do you know you haven't simply written a test which measures how much time the person has to think about brain teasers? Researchers should ask these questions to determine if the correlation is actually caused by anything real, or if it's better explained by some other underlying factor.
- haberman 9y ago> Researchers should ask these questions to determine if the correlation is actually caused by anything real, or if it's better explained by some other underlying factor. Yes, absolutely! But this only works if people apply the same skepticism towards the theories they find more politically palatable. See: http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/08/14/beware-isolated-demands-for-rigor/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/08/14/beware-isolated-demands... Since people are notoriously bad at being self-skeptical, the best way to learn what is actually true is by encouraging viewpoint diversity: https://heterodoxacademy.org/ https://heterodoxacademy.org/
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Since people are notoriously bad at being self-skeptical, the best way to learn what is actually true is by encouraging viewpoint diversity: The problem with that concept is that if the available evidence actually does strongly support a position, seeking viewpoint diversity means actively selecting people who either cannot analyze the evidence or who wilfully ignore it's content. Doing so within the research community may help the competent, and honest subset of the community avoid getting stuck in ruts formed by the subtle accumulation of confirmation bias from past results (if the other group doesn't end up getting filtered out by then over time, despite being present in the community, which is improbable), but it also means that you have to actively promote crackpots and their pet theories to do it; in terms of learning what is actually true, I don't think that's a net win.
- techman9 9y agoIs IQ an excellent "predictor of income, social status, and academic & job performance" or merely associated with those?
- nokcha 9y agoIQ can be measured in middle school (before the student has a job or income), and the resulting score can be used to predict future income and job performance. In that sense, it is a predictor rather than a mere association.
- techman9 9y agoOk, but there are still myriad confounding factors, even at that age. Do students from higher income schools in aggregate have higher IQs than those from lower income schools?
- throwaway337 9y agoAll of these things are controlled for. These are professors whose job it is to make sure you don't have such confounding variables. You even have twin studies where one twin was adopted by rich and one by poor parents and it still holds.
- marcelluspye 9y agoSource?
- thraway180306 9y agoWhat about Stoolmiller in Psychol. Bull. 125:392-409 who found families deciding to adopt forming a pointedly restricted range. Being for example exceedingly intelligent with IQ over 120 on average, which is obviously different than general average.
- tomc1985 9y agoThere's a lot of different forms of intelligence that IQ does not measure. The practice tests I've seen tended to ask a lot of abstract questions that, in some cases, seemed to rely on having a specific set of cultural experiences. I remember encountering a question that asked me to clarify the meaning of a 'common' expression, and thinking, "how lucky am I to have been exposed to and know just what this question refers to? Would I have a lower IQ just because I was an immigrant or something?" (It was the US version of the MENSA practice exam on their website circa several years ago) I'm of the opinion that intelligence is unmeasurable, if even comprehendable by us mortals, and that the best proxy we have is one's propensity to learn and be curious. Seems that measuring intelligence is yet another example of the folly of human artifice
- mywittyname 9y agoIQ test questions are abstract because they designed measure abstract thinking capabilities. Abstract thinking is the definition of intelligence because of its general applicability to learning. All learning, be it math, language, engineering, music, etc, amounts to recognizing patterns, generalizing them, and applying the generalization to a different problem. I'd like to point out that basically every academic admission test (SAT, ACT, GRE, MCAT, etc) is an IQ test mixed in with some domain-specific knowledge testing. No offense, but having the opinion that intelligence is not measurable is roughly as ignorant as believing the the solar system is geocentric. It requires throwing aside or ignoring a massive amount of scientific evidence and consensus.
- tomc1985 9y agoWhy not? What makes you think currently-established science measures true "intelligence" and not just whatever phenomenon the test is measuring? To use heliocentrism as an example, how can you possibly know whether our current understanding is accurate or just the next heliocentrism (that we haven't disproven yet)? Some of the smartest people I know wouldn't do well on an IQ test. Many of the questions are abstract but not all of them -- at least in my case several of those questions seemed more cultural than anything else. (And in some cases these supposedly 'abstract' questions seem to have a possibility-space of answers that even the test-writers did not anticipate.) If you define intelligence as the quantification of one's experiences, then sure, I'll roll with your argument, but experience (and abstract thinking) are just small parts of the overall equation, to which I think we still cannot grasp.