5 ms·
I found most insightful the following comment by David Edmondson > Something drilled home to me at my Cornell planning program was the American idea of rural a
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y ago
I found most insightful the following comment by David Edmondson
> Something drilled home to me at my Cornell planning program was the American idea of rural as utopia, urban as dystopia. As my professor would put it, our culture strives for a return to the Garden of Eden – it’s seen in our art, our land-use patterns (pre-
and post-independence), our mythology, and our politics. Even Philadelphia was laid out with that idea in mind.
I think that is one of the core issues. The idea of having your own home on your own plot of land is something that is deep in the American psyche.
And it is something that can be accomplished. Why is there not more remote work even at the big tech companies? If everybody was not forced to crowd into Silicon Valley in order to work for the large tech companies, Silicon Valley and San Francisco home prices would get much better quickly.
Many times, people feel like they are forced to live in cities, not because they want to, but because they have to for their job. If we promoted a culture of remote work, then people could live where they wanted, more wealth would get spread out through the country rather than being concentrated in NYC and Silicon Valley, and the affordability of living in cities would rise.
- jeffreyrogers 9y agoI don't think this is true. I used to work for a company in a Connecticut suburb of NYC. Most young people wanted to live in NYC and commute in because they'd rather live in a city.
- nostromo 9y agoI lived in NYC for about five years. I noticed that urban living is prized by people in their 20s, but seems to quickly fall out of fashion later in life. Particularly when it comes to child-bearing age, large cities like New York are fairly impractical for the non-rich. My friends in their 30s and 40s that hadn't left for the suburbs would regularly talk about how they wanted to leave the city.
- electricslpnsld 9y ago> Particularly when it comes to child-bearing age, large cities like New York are fairly impractical Parts of New York City are incredibly child friendly. Park Slope, and huge swaths of Brooklyn and Queens, are chock full of families.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y agoNYC is a big city in terms of land area. Given the distance from Manhattan and core of the city, Brooklyn and Queens would be considered suburbs in a lot of other cities.
- electricslpnsld 9y agoI don't think I've ever heard someone refer to Park Slope, Bed Stuy, or Crown Heights as suburban. Levittown is the usual yard-stick by which American suburbanism is measured.
- cimmanom 9y agoMaybe based on distance as the crow flies. But not based on density, and (when the subways aren't as broken as they are at the moment) not based on commute times.
- Kalium 9y ago> Why is there not more remote work even at the big tech companies? If everybody was not forced to crowd into Silicon Valley in order to work for the large tech companies, Silicon Valley and San Francisco home prices would get much better quickly. You're absolutely right! There's a lot that can be done, and it can be done by the big tech companies. However, I'm told it is possible that there might actually be some advantages to sharing a physical location that are not readily replicated remotely. Maybe those people are wrong and I'm horribly misinformed, but what I've read does suggest that the costs are worth it. Maybe you have better ideas? I hope so! Please, help me understand better!
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y agoThese same tech companies also have remote offices. Obviously, it does not have to be completely face to face. Maybe, in the future, VR will get to the point where you can have a virtual office experience that will be close enough to the real experience from the comfort of your home.
- Kalium 9y agoYou're right! That's absolutely possible. I've had the experience of working with such offices. I've also had the experience of working with a partially distributed team that encourages working from home. In each case, I found distinct disadvantages compared physical co-location. Both for companies and for employees. I share your hope for the possibilities offered by VR, but I'm hesitant to shape urban planning policy for decades around it.
- electricslpnsld 9y ago> Many times, people feel like they are forced to live in cities, not because they want to, but because they have to for their job. Is this true? I work in a suburbanish portion of the bay area, and 90% of my coworkers commute in from San Francisco and Western Oakland. San Francisco is more expensive and is further away, but the advantages of urban living are multi-fold. Walkable neighborhoods, access to more restaurants, bars, and nightlife, access to more culture (museums, openings, concerts, etc), more people to meet and talk to, etc. Given the choice I would almost certainly choose to live in a city vs. a suburb or rural area.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y agoWhat is your coworkers' age range. In the past, young people would start in the city. Once they married/had children, they would move out the suburbs.
- electricslpnsld 9y ago> What is your coworkers' age range. 20s through 50s.
- refurb 9y agoThat's the trend I've noticed. Lots of 20 and 30 year old live in SF. Once the family expands, the first question is "when do we move out of the city?". When you've got kids, things like bars and restaurants take a back seat to good schools and family-friendly neighborhoods. Of all my coworkers with children, maybe 10% chose to stick it out in SF and they seem to bitch non-stop about the schools.
- naravara 9y ago>The idea of having your own home on your own plot of land is something that is deep in the American psyche. This idea destroys what any normal people think of as actual rural or country life. Densely clustered homes and buildings (like this: http://www.citymetric.com/sites/default/files/styles/nodeimage/public/article_2015/03/skyscraper.jpg?itok=e0_2hUnw http://www.citymetric.com/sites/default/files/styles/nodeima... or like this: http://tomsavagebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/Swiss-town.jpg http://tomsavagebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/Swiss-t...) do a much better job of preserving the landscape and the ecology than sprawling out (like this: http://l7.alamy.com/zooms/d46e2d569d6948eea499aa20f2d1709c/northern-virginia-usa-aerial-of-bedroom-surburban-housing-e0d21x.jpg http://l7.alamy.com/zooms/d46e2d569d6948eea499aa20f2d1709c/n...) does. Also, the appeal of living in the country isn't privately owned "wide open spaces" it's that cozy small town vibe where everyone knows each other and is in each others' business all the time (for better or worse). If all you want to have a ton of space for yourself it's actually fairly easy to do that, it's just hard to expect society to subsidize the infrastructure that makes it convenient and easy to have your social and commercial needs met at the same time. >If we promoted a culture of remote work, then people could live where they wanted, more wealth would get spread out through the country rather than being concentrated in NYC and Silicon Valley, and the affordability of living in cities would rise. Cities have what are called agglomeration effects. Work isn't just punching a clock for a wage, especially not knowledge work. It takes creativity and collaboration to get good results and not being able to do that in real way with your colleagues just doesn't work. Also, most people in nice cities actually rather enjoy it once you take noise and cost of living issues out of the equation. The former is just a problem of not investing enough in noise abatement and the latter is just an issue of not having enough mixed-use urban land available for the number of people who want that lifestyle. >more wealth would get spread out through the country rather than being concentrated in NYC and Silicon Valley Or you could spread a culture of urbanism so places like Cincinnati or Minneapolis can build themselves the same kinds of civic amenities that draw people to New York and Silicon Valley and fostered the kinds of entrepreneurship that made those cities into what they are today. The wealth in NYC and SF aren't properties of the soil. Those places are rich because the people there built businesses that made them rich. Sure, having major ports helped but that hasn't been a significant enough factor to bring cities like Baltimore, New Orleans, or St. Louis to prominence in the modern economy.
- forapurpose 9y ago> people feel like they are forced to live in cities Based on what I know, people are flocking to cities because they want to be there, and companies are locating there in order to be attractive to employees. Cities have very high levels of services (due to economy of scale and density), restaurants, the arts, sports, walkability, bikeability, energy, community ... sustainability ... San Francisco has all that in one of the most beautiful cities in the world. Many people prefer that.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y agoSan Francisco is also less sanitary than many of the poorest slums in the world. https://sf.curbed.com/2018/2/19/17029308/trash-needles-feces-san-francisco-streets-dirty-hazard https://sf.curbed.com/2018/2/19/17029308/trash-needles-feces... I am not sure I want my children dealing with human feces (and the risk of diseases such as hepatitis A) and used needles as part of their childhood experience.
- shard 9y agoHepatitis A vaccines are fairly simple: 2 shots in 6 months give 12 months of protection, and a third shot after 6 more months gives 20 years of protection. Children as young as 1 year old can be given the vaccine. Please talk to your doctor about getting this vaccine to protect you and your loved ones against this disease.
- khedoros1 9y agoAnd, defense in depth: Also don't take your children places where people are pooping on the street, or leaving around needles, if you can help it. Although I don't see why "just get a vaccine" is a sufficient response to "I don't want my children around feces and needles".
- shard 9y agoYou read too much into my reply. My only point was that hepatitis A is a disease that is easily defended against, and I wanted to spread that knowledge.
- paganel 9y agoAnother gem from the comments is this part: > London is now building so-called “co-housing” which sounds like it should be for retirees but is for the working young who have been priced out of even renting (let alone purchase) but IMO that is a shocking non-solution. It is forced barracks living–for people in their 20s and 30s (soon … 40s & 50s)–and seems very redolent of USSR communal apartments with shared kitchens etc. The common thing within the Anglosphere (and places that mimick it, like HK) is the abandonment of public housing for at least the last 35 years (since 1997 for HK), along with tax policies that promote unproductive property speculation. I live in a former communist country, and as an urbanism-buff one of the projects I was thinking about in my head was to hunt down the remaining barrack-like buildings that are still extant (most of them have been built in the 1950s and the early 1960s as a temporary solution for a fast-growing urban population, very few actually still exist). Interesting to see that the "West" is resorting to the same ideas 50-60 years after we did.
- mercutio2 9y agoPeople sometimes redefine terms, but just for reference, this doesn’t sound anything like what the cohousing community [0] is trying to achieve in the US. [0] http://www.cohousing.org/what_is_cohousing http://www.cohousing.org/what_is_cohousing
- blackbagboys 9y agoThis is actually a return to a common urban housing pattern that disappeared with the middle-class exodus from urban centers: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_room_occupancy#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_room_occupancy#History